Not an OffenseEe titles this vagga "Not an Offense, Etc.'' By offense (āpatti) is
meant a transgression of monastic discipline.
1 5 0 (1 )
"Bhikkhus, those bhikkhus who explain what is not an offense
as an offense are acting for the harm of many people, for the
unhappiness of many people, for the ruin, harm , and suffering of many people, of devas and human beings.
These bhikkhus generate much demerit and cause this good Dhamma to
disappear."
151 (2)-159 (10)
(151) "Bhikkhus, those bhikkhus who explain what is an offense as
no offense...
......
(152)... a light offense as a grave offense... (153)... a
grave offense as a light offense... (1 5 4 )... a coarse offense as
not a coarse offense... (155)... an offense that is not coarse as a
coarse offense... (156)... a remediable offense as an irremediable
offense... [21} (157).. .an irremediable offense as a remediable
offense... (1 5 8 )... an offense with redress as an offense without
redress... (1 5 9 )... an offense without redress as an offense with
redress are acting for the harm of many people, for the unhappiness of many people, for the ruin, harm , and suffering of many
people, of devas and human beings.Mp: "Five classes of offenses are called light (lahuka) and two are
called grave (gāruka, lit. "heavy"). Two are coarse and five are
not coarse. Six classes are remediable and one is irremediable.
Offenses with redress are the same as those that are remediable;
the offenses, without redress are the same as those that are irremediable." The two graveclasses of offenses are (1) the pārājikas,
which entail permanent expulsion from the Sahgha, and (2) the
saṅghādisesas,. which require formal meetings of the Saṅgha and a
complex process of rehabilitation. The five light classes are thullaccaya (gross transgression), pācittiya (explation), pātidesanīya
(to be acknowledged), dukkaṭa (misdeed), and dubbhāsita (bad
speech). These can be exonerated by confession to another monk.
The grave offenses are also called "coarse" (duṭṭhulla); the light
ones, not coarse (aduṭṭhulla). The pārājikas are "irremediable"'
(anavasesa) and. "without redress" (appaṭikamma), because they
do not allow for expiation; the other six classes are "remediable"
(sāvasesa) and "with redress" (sappaṭikamma) because they can be
cleared by expiation.
These bhikkhus generate
much demerit and cause this good Dhamma to disappear."
1 6 0 (1 1 ) .
' Bhikkhus, those bhikkhus w ho explain what is no offense as
no offense are acting for the welfare of many people, for the
happiness of many people, for the good, welfare, and happiness
of many people, of devas and humans.
These bhikkhus generate
much merit and sustain this good Dhamma."
161 (12)-169 (20)
(161) "Bhikkhus,- those bhikkhus who explain an offense as an
offense...
......
(1 6 2 )... a light offense as a light offense... (1 6 3 )... a
grave offense as a grave offense... (1 6 4 )... a coarse offense as
a coarse offense... (165) ..an offense that is not coarse as not a
coarse offense.. .(166)-. .a remediable offense as a remediable
offense... (1 6 7 ).. .an irrem ediable offense as an irremediable
offense ..- ( 1 6 8 ) ...an offense with redress as an offense with
redress... (1 6 9 )... an offense without redress as an offense without redress are acting for the w elfare of many people, for the
happiness of many people, for the good, w elfare; and happiness
of many people, of devas and humans.
These bhikkhus generate
much merit and sustain this good Dhamma." [22]