The Root of All ThingsList of Abbreviations
AN Anguttara Nikaya
BBS Burmese-script Buddhasasana Samiti edition of the
Majjhima Nikaya
BPS Buddhist Publication Society of Kandy, Sri Lanka
Cv Culavagga (Vinaya Pitaka)
Dhp Dhammapada
DN Digha Nikaya
Jat Jataka
Kh Khandhaka (Vinaya Pitaka)
MA Majjhima Nikaya Atthakatha
Miln Milindapanha
MLS Middle Length Sayings (see Bibliography, Horner)
MN Majjhima Nikaya
Ms Ven. Nanamoli's manuscript translation of the Majjhima
Nikaya
MT Majjhima Nikaya Tlka
Mv Mahavagga (Vinaya Pitaka)
Nm Bhikkhu Nanamoli
Pac Pacittiya
Par Parajika
PED Pali-English Dictionary (Pali Text Society)
PTS Pali Text Society
Pts Patisambhidamagga
Pug Puggalapannatti
SBJ Sinhala-script Buddha Jayanti Tripitaka Series edition of
the Majjhima Nikaya
SN Samyutta Nikaya
Sn Sutta Nipata
Thag Theragatha
THUS HAVE I HEARD.For a fuller treatment of this important and difficult
sutta, see Bhikkhu Bodhi, Discourse on the Root of
Existence. This work contains, besides a translation of the
sutta, a lengthy analytical study of its philosophical significance
and copious extracts from the very helpful commentarial
literature that has accumulated around it.
Nm's rendering of this sutta in Ms was highly conjectural;
thus, while I have retained most of his terminology,
I have substituted my own rendering of the syntax to
bring out the meaning that accords with the traditional
interpretation and that seems warranted by the original
Pali text as well. The key passages as Nm rendered them
will be given in the Notes. On one occasion the Blessed One was
living in Ukkattha in the Subhaga Grove at the root of a royal
sala tree.
There he addressed the bhikkhus thus:
"Bhikkhus."MA explains that the Buddha delivered this sutta to dispel
the conceit that had arisen in five hundred bhikkhus
on account of their erudition and intellectual mastery of
the Buddha's teachings. These bhikkhus were formerly
brahmins learned in the Vedic literature, and the
Buddha's cryptic utterances may well have been intended
to challenge the brahmanic views to which they may
still have adhered. -
"Venerable sir," they replied.
The Blessed One said this:
"Bhikkhus, I shall teach you a discourse on the root of all
things.Sabbadhammamulapariyaya. MT explains that the word
"all" (sabba) is being used here in the restricted sense of
the "all of personality" (sakkayasabba), that is, with reference
to all states or phenomena (dhamma) comprised
within the five aggregates affected by clinging (see
MN 28.4). Supramundane states - the paths, fruits, and
Nibbana - are excluded. The "root of all things" - that is,
the special condition that maintains the continuity of the
process of repeated existence - MT explains to be craving,
conceit, and views (which are the underlying springs
of "conceiving"), and these in turn are underlaid by ignorance,
suggested in the sutta by the phrase "he has not
fully understood it."
Listen and attend closely to what I shall say." -
"Yes,
venerable sir," the bhikkhus replied.
The Blessed One said this:
"Here, bhikkhus, an untaught ordinary person,The "untaught ordinary person" (assutava puthujjana) is
the common worldling, who possesses neither learning
nor spiritual accomplishment in the Dhamma of the
noble ones, and allows himself to be dominated by the
multitude of defilements and wrong views. See Bodhi,
Discourse on the Root of Existence, pp. 40-46 who has no
regard for noble ones and is unskilled and undisciplined in their
Dhamma, who has no regard for true men and is unskilled and
undisciplined in their Dhamma, perceives earth as earth.Pathavim pathavito safijanati. Although perceiving "earth
as earth" seems to suggest seeing the object as it really is,
the aim of Buddhist insight meditation, the context
makes it clear that the ordinary person's perception of
"earth as earth" already introduces a slight distortion of
the object, a distortion that will be blown up into fullfledged
misinterpretation when the cognitive process
enters the phase of "conceiving." MA explains that the
ordinary person seizes upon the conventional expression
"it is earth," and applying this to the object, perceives it
through a "perversion of perception" (sannavipallasa). The
latter is a technical expression explained as perceiving the
impermanent as permanent, the painful as pleasurable,
what is not self as self, and what is foul as beautiful
(AN 4:49/ii.52). Nm reads the ablative suffix -to of the
Pali as signifying derivation and translates the phrase:
"From earth he has a percept of earth."
Having perceived earth as earth, he conceives [himself as] earth,
he conceives [himself] in earth, he conceives [himself apart]
from earth, he conceives earth to be 'mine/ he delights in earth.The Pali verb "conceives" (mahnati), from the root man,
"to think," is often used in the Pali suttas to mean distortional
thinking - thought that ascribes to its object
characteristics and a significance derived not from the
object itself, but from its own subjective imaginings.
The cognitive distortion introduced by conceiving consists,
in brief, in the intrusion of the egocentric perspective
into the experience already slightly distorted by
spontaneous perception. According to the commentaries,
the activity of conceiving is governed by three defile-merits,
which accounts for the different ways it comes to manifestation: craving (tanM), conceit (mftna), and views (ditthi).
MA paraphrases this text thus: "Having perceived
earth with a perverted perception, the ordinary person
afterwards conceives it - construes or discriminates it -
through the gross proliferating tendencies (papanca) of
craving, conceit, and views, which are here called 'conceivings
.'...He apprehends it in diverse ways contrary
[to reality]."
The four ways of conceiving (mannana): The Buddha
shows that the conceiving of any object may occur in any
of four ways, expressed by the text as a fourfold linguistic
pattern: accusative, locative, ablative, and appropriative.
The primary significance of this modal pattern - enigmatic
in the Pali as well - seems to be ontological. I take
the pattern to represent the diverse ways in which the
ordinary person attempts to give positive being to his
imagined sense of egohood by positing, below the
threshold of reflection, a relationship between himself as
the subject of cognition and the perceived phenomenon
as its object. According to the fourfold pattern given, this
relationship may be one either of direct identification
("he conceives X"), or of inherence ("he conceives in X"),
or of contrast or derivation ("he conceives from X"), or of
simple appropriation ("he conceives X to be 'mine'").
But care is needed in interpreting these phrases. The
Pali does not supply any direct object for the second and
third modes, and this suggests that the process at work
in conceiving proceeds from a deeper and more general
level than that involved in the forming of an explicit
view of self, as described for example at MN 2.8 or
MN 44.7. The activity of conceiving thus seems to comprise
the entire range of subjectively tinged cognition,
from the impulses and thoughts in which the sense of
personal identity is still inchoate to elaborate intellectual
structures in which it has been fully explicated.
Nm, however, understands the implicit object of conceiving
to be the percept itself, and accordingly translates:
"having had from earth a percept of earth, he conceives
[that to be] earth, he conceives [that to be] in earth, he
conceives [that to be apart] from earth," etc.
The fifth phrase, "he delights in X," explicitly connects
conceiving with craving, which is elsewhere said to
"delight here and there." This, moreover, hints at the
danger in the worldling's thought processes, since craving
is pointed to by the Buddha as the origin of suffering.
MA gives prolific examples illustrating all the different
modes of conceiving, and these clearly establish that
the intended object of conceiving is the misplaced sense
of egoity.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.MA states that one who fully understands earth does
so by the three types of full understanding: the full
understanding of the known (nataparinnci) - the definition
of the earth element by way of its unique characteristic,
function, manifestation, and proximate cause;
the full understanding by scrutinization {tiranaparinfia): the contemplation of the earth element by way of the
three general characteristics of impermanence, suffering,
and non-self; and the full understanding of abandonment
(pahanaparinfia) - the abandoning of desire
and lust for the earth element through the supreme
path (of arahantship).
"He perceives water as water.
Having perceived water as
water, he conceives [himself as] water, he conceives [himself] in
water, he conceives [himself apart] from water, he conceives
water to be 'mine/ he delights in water.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives fire as fire.
Having perceived fire as fire, he
conceives [himself as] fire, he conceives [himself] in fire, he conceives
[himself apart] from fire, he conceives fire to be 'mine/ he
delights in fire.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood
it, I say.
"He perceives air as air.
Having perceived air as air, he conceives
[himself as] air, he conceives [himself] in air, he conceives[himself apart] from air, he conceives air to be 'mine,' he delights in air.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives beings as beings.Bhuta. MA says that "beings" here signifies only living
beings below the heaven of the Four Great Kings, the
lowest of the sense-sphere heavens; the higher grades of
living beings are covered by the terms to follow. MA
exemplifies the application of the three types of conceiving
to this situation as follows: When a person becomes
attached to beings as a result of sight, hearing, etc., or
desires rebirth in a certain class of beings, this is conceiving
due to craving. When he ranks himself as superior,
equal, or inferior to others, this is conceiving due to conceit.
And when he thinks, "Beings are permanent, stable,
eternal," etc., this is conceiving due to views.
Having perceived beings
as beings, he conceives beings, he conceives [himself] in beings,
he conceives [himself apart] from beings, he conceives beings to
be 'mine,' he delights in beings.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives gods as gods.MA: The gods of the six sense-sphere heavenly worlds
are meant, except for Mara and his retinue in the heaven
of the gods who wield power over others' creations. See
the account of Buddhist cosmology in the Introduction,
pp. 31-33.
Having perceived gods as
gods, he conceives gods, he conceives [himself] in gods, he conceives
[himself apart] from gods, he conceives gods to be 'mine,'
he delights in gods.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives Pajapati as Pajapati.Prajapati, "lord of creation," is a name given by the
Vedas to Indra, Agni, etc., as the highest of the Vedic
divinities. But according to MA, Pajapati here is a name
for Mara because he is the ruler of this "generation"
(paja) made up of living beings.
Having perceived
Pajapati as Pajapati, he conceives Pajapati, he conceives [himself]
in Pajapati, he conceives [himself apart] from Pajapati, he
conceives Pajapati to be 'mine,' he delights in Pajapati.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives Brahmā as Brahmā.Brahma here is Mahabrahma, the first deity to be born at
the beginning of a new cosmic cycle and whose lifespan
lasts for the entire cycle. The Ministers of Brahma and
the Assembly of Brahma - the other deities whose position
is determined by attainment of the first jhana - are
also included.
Having perceived
Brahmā as Brahmā, he conceives Brahmā, he conceives [himself]
in Brahmā, he conceives [himself apart] from Brahmā, he conceives
Brahmā to be 'mine,' he delights in Brahmā.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the gods of Streaming Radiance as the gods
of Streaming Radiance.MA: By mentioning these, all beings occupying the plane
of the second jhana - the gods of Limited Radiance and
the gods of Immeasurable Radiance - should be included,
for all these occupy a single level.
Having perceived the gods of
Streaming Radiance as the gods of Streaming Radiance, he conceives
the gods of Streaming Radiance, he conceives [himself] in
the gods of Streaming Radiance, he conceives [himself apart]
from the gods of Streaming Radiance, he conceives the gods of
Streaming Radiance to be 'mine,' he delights in the gods of
Streaming Radiance.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the gods of Refulgent Glory as the gods of
Refulgent Glory.MA: By mentioning these, all beings occupying the plane
of the third jhana - the gods of Limited Glory and the
gods of Immeasurable Glory - should be included.
Having perceived the gods of Refulgent
Glory as the gods of Refulgent Glory, he conceives the gods of
Refulgent Glory, he conceives [himself] in the gods of Refulgent
Glory, he conceives [himself apart] from the gods of Refulgent
Glory, he conceives the gods of Refulgent Glory to be 'mine,' he
delights in the gods of Refulgent Glory.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the gods of Great Fruit as the gods of Great
Fruit.These are divinities on the plane of the fourth jhana.
Having perceived the gods of Great Fruit as the gods of
Great Fruit, he conceives the gods of Great Fruit, he conceives
[himself] in the gods of Great Fruit, he conceives [himself apart]
from the gods of Great Fruit, he conceives the gods of Great
Fruit to be 'mine,' he delights in the gods of Great Fruit.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the Overlord as the Overlord.Abhibhu. MA says this term is a designation for the nonpercipient
realm, called thus because it vanquishes
(abhibhavati) the four immaterial aggregates. The identification
sounds contrived, especially because the word
"abhibhu" is a masculine singular noun. Elsewhere
(MN 49.5) the word appears as part of Baka the Brahma's
claim to theocratic hegemony, yet MA rejects identifying
the Abhibhu with Brahma here as a redundancy.
Having perceived
the Overlord as the Overlord, he conceives the Overlord,
he conceives [himself] in the Overlord, he conceives [himself
apart] from the Overlord, he conceives the Overlord to be
'mine/ he delights in the Overlord.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the base of infinite space as the base of infinite
space.This and the next three sections deal with conceiving in
relation to the four immaterial planes of existence - the
cosmological counterparts of the four immaterial meditative
attainments. With §18 the division of conceiving by
way of planes of existence is completed.
Having perceived the base of infinite space as the
base of infinite space, he conceives [himself as] the base of infinite
space, he conceives [himself] in the base of infinite space, he
conceives [himself apart] from the base of infinite space, he conceives
the base of infinite space to be 'mine,' he delights in the
base of infinite space.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the base of infinite consciousness as the
base of infinite consciousness.
Having perceived the base of
infinite consciousness as the base of infinite consciousness, he conceives [himself as] the base of infinite consciousness, he
conceives [himself] in the base of infinite consciousness, he conceives
[himself apart] from the base of infinite consciousness, he
conceives the base of infinite consciousness to be 'mine,' he
delights in the base of infinite consciousness.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the base of nothingness as the base of nothingness.
Having perceived the base of nothingness as the base of
nothingness, he conceives [himself as] the base of nothingness, he
conceives [himself] in the base of nothingness, he conceives [himself
apart] from the base of nothingness, he conceives the base of
nothingness to be 'mine,' he delights in the base of nothingness.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the base of neither-perception-nor-nonperception
as the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.
Having perceived the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perceptionas the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception, he conceives
[himself as] the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception,
he conceives [himself] in the base of neither-perception-nor-nonperception,
he conceives [himself apart] from the base of
neither-perception-nor-non-perception, he conceives the base of
neither-perception-nor-non-perception to be 'mine/ he delights
in the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the seen as the seen.In these four sections the phenomena comprising personality
are considered as objects of perception classified
into the four categories of the seen, heard, sensed, and
cognized. Here, sensed (muta) signifies the data of smell,
taste, and touch, cognized (vinnata) the data of introspection,
abstract thought, and imagination. The objects of
perception are "conceived" when they are cognized in
terms of "mine," "I," and "self," or in ways that generate
craving, conceit, and views.
Having perceived the
seen as the seen, he conceives [himself as] the seen, he conceives
[himself] in the seen, he conceives [himself apart] from the seen,
he conceives the seen to be 'mine/ he delights in the seen.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the heard as the heard.
Having perceived
the heard as the heard, he conceives [himself as] the heard, he
conceives [himself] in the heard, he conceives [himself apart]
from the heard, he conceives the heard to be 'mine/ he delights
in the heard.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the sensed as the sensed.
Having perceived
the sensed as the sensed, he conceives [himself as] the sensed, he
conceives [himself] in the sensed, he conceives [himself apart]
from the sensed, he conceives the sensed to be 'mine,' he
delights in the sensed.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives the cognized as the cognized.
Having perceived
the cognized as the 'cognized, he conceives [himself as]
the cognized, he conceives [himself] in the cognized, he conceives
[himself apart] from the cognized, he conceives the cognized
to be 'mine/ he delights in the cognized.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives unity as unity.In this section and the next, the phenomena comprising
personality are treated as twofold - by way of unity and
diversity. The emphasis on unity (ekatta), MA informs us,
is characteristic of one who attains the jhanas, in which
the mind occurs in a single mode on a single object. The
emphasis on diversity (nanatta) prevails in the case of the
non-attainer who lacks the overwhelming unitive experience
of jhanas. Conceivings stressing diversity come to
expression in philosophies of pluralism, those stressing
unity in philosophies of the monistic type.
Having perceived unity as
unity, he conceives [himself as] unity, he conceives [himself] in
unity, he conceives [himself apart] from unity, he conceives
unity to be 'mine/ he delights in unity.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives diversity as diversity.
Having perceived
diversity as diversity, he conceives [himself as] diversity, he
conceives [himself] in diversity, he conceives [himself apart]
from diversity, he conceives diversity to be 'mine/ he delightsin diversity.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives all as all.In this section, all phenomena of personality are collected
together and shown as singlefold. This idea of totality
can form the basis for philosophies of the pantheistic or
monistic type, depending on the relation posited
between the self and the all.
Having perceived all as all, he
conceives [himself asl all, he conceives [himself] in all, he
conceives [himself apart] from all, he conceives all to be 'mine,'
he delights in all.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"He perceives Nibbana as Nibbana.MA understands "Nibbana" here to refer to the five
kinds of "supreme Nibbana here and now" included
among the sixty-two wrong views of the Brahmajala
Sutta (DN 1.3.19-25/L36-38), that is, Nibbana identified
with the full enjoyment of sense pleasures or with the
four jhanas. Enjoying this state, or yearning for it, he conceives
it with craving. Priding himself on attaining it, he
conceives it with conceit. Holding this imaginary Nibbana
to be permanent, etc., he conceives it with views.
Having perceived
Nibbana as Nibbana, he conceives [himself as] Nibbana, he
conceives [himself] in Nibbana, he conceives [himself apart]
from Nibbana, he conceives Nibbana to be 'mine,' he delights
in Nibbana.
Why is that?
Because he has not fully understood it, I say.
"Bhikkhus, a bhikkhu who is in higher training,The sekha, the disciple in higher training, is one who has
reached any of the three lower planes of sanctity -
stream-entry, once-returning, or non-returning - but
must still train further in order to reach the goal, arahantship,
the supreme security from bondage. MN 53 is
devoted to expounding the training he must undertake.
The arahant is sometimes described as asekha, one
beyond training, in the sense that he has completed the
training in the Noble Eightfold Path. Nm rendered sekha
as "initiate" and asekha as "adept," which have been
changed here to avoid their "esoteric" connotations. whose
mind has not yet reached the goal, and who is still aspiring to
the supreme security from bondage, directly knows earth as
earth.It should be noted that, whereas the ordinary man is
said to perceive each of the bases, the one in higher training
is said to directly know them (abhijanati). MA explains
that he knows them with distinguished knowledge/
knows them in accordance with their real nature as
impermanent, suffering, and non-self. Nm r e n d e r e d
"From earth he has direct knowledge of earth."
Having directly known earth as earth, he should not
conceive [himself as] earth, he should not conceive [himself] in
earth, he should not conceive [himself apart] from earth, he
should not conceive earth to be 'mine/ he should not delight in
earth.
Why is that?
So that he may fully understand it, I say.The disciple in higher training is urged by the Buddha to
refrain from conceiving and delight because the dispositions
to these mental processes still remain within him.
With his attainment of stream-entry he eradicated the fetter
of personality view and thus can no longer conceive
in terms of wrong views. But the defilements of craving
and conceit are only uprooted by the path of arahantship,
and thus the sekha remains vulnerable to the conceivings
to which they are capable of giving rise. Whereas direct
knowledge (abhihha) is the province of both the sekha and
the arahant, full understanding (parihha) is the province
exclusively of the arahant, as it involves the full abandoning
of all defilements.
"He directly knows water as water...He directly knows
all as all...
"He directly knows Nibbana as Nibbana.
Having directly
known Nibbana as Nibbana, he should not conceive [himself as]
Nibbana, he should not conceive [himself] in Nibbana, he
should not conceive [himself apart] from Nibbana, he should
not conceive Nibbana to be 'mine/ he should not delight in
Nibbana.
Why is that?
So that he may fully understand it, I say.
"Bhikkhus, a bhikkhu who is an arahant with taints
destroyed, who has lived the holy life, done what had to be
done, laid down the burden, reached the true goal, destroyed
the fetters of being, and is completely liberated through final
knowledge,This is the stock description of the arahant, repeated in
many suttas. directly knows earth as earth.
Having directlyknown earth as earth, he does not conceive [himself as] earth, he
does not conceive [himself] in earth, he does not conceive [himself
apart] from earth, he does not conceive earth to be 'mine/ he
does not delight in earth.
Why is that?
Because he has fully understood it, I say.When ignorance has been abolished by the attainment of
full understanding, the subtlest dispositions to craving
and conceit are also eradicated. Thus the arahant can no
longer engage in conceiving and delight.
"He directly knows water as water...Nibbana as
Nibbana.
...
Why is that?
Because he has fully understood it, I say.
"Bhikkhus, a bhikkhu who is an arahant...completely liberated
through final knowledge, directly knows earth as earth.
Having directly known earth as earth, he does not conceive [himself
as] earth, he does not conceive [himself] in earth, he does not
conceive [himself apart] from earth, he does not conceive earth to
be 'mine/ he does not delight in earth.
Why is that?
Because he is
free from lust through the destruction of lust.This section and the following two are stated to show
that the arahant does not conceive, not only because he
has fully understood the object, but because he has eradicated
the three unwholesome roots - lust (or greed), hate,
and delusion. The phrase "free from lust through the
destruction of lust" is used to stress that the arahant is
not merely temporarily without lust, but has destroyed it
at the most fundamental level. Similarly with hate and
delusion.
"He directly knows water as water...Nibbana as
Nibbana
.. .
Why is that?
Because he is free from lust through the
destruction of lust.
"Bhikkhus, a bhikkhu who is an arahant...completely liberated
through final knowledge, directly knows earth as earth.
Having directly known earth as earth, he does not conceive [himself
as] earth, he does not conceive [himself] in earth, he does not
conceive [himself apart] from earth, he does not conceive earth to
be 'mine/ he does not delight in earth.
Why is that?
Because he is free from hate through the destruction of hate.
"He directly knows water as water...Nibbana as
Nibbana.
......
Why is that?
Because he is free from hate through the
destruction of hate.
"Bhikkhus, a bhikkhu who is an arahant...completely liberated
through final knowledge, directly knows earth as earth.
Having directly known earth as earth, he does not conceive
[himself as] earth, he does not conceive [himself] in earth, he does not conceive [himself apart] from earth, he does not conceive
earth to be 'mine,' he does not delight in earth.
Why is that?
Because he is free from delusion through the destruction of
delusion.
"He directly knows water as water...Nibbana as
Nibbana.
.......
Why is that?
Because he is free from delusion through the destruction of delusion.
"Bhikkhus, the Tathagata,On this word, the epithet the Buddha uses most often
when referring to himself, see the Introduction, p. 24. The
commentaries give a long detailed etymology, into which
they try to compress virtually the entire Dhamma. The
passage has been translated in Bhikkhu Bodhi, Discourse
on the Ail-Embracing Net of Views, pp. 331-44. accomplished and fully enlightened,
directly knows earth as earth.
Having directly known
earth as earth, he does not conceive [himself as] earth, he does
not conceive [himself] in earth, he does not conceive [himself
apart] from earth, he does not conceive earth to be 'mine/ he
does not delight in earth.
Why is that?
Because the Tathagata has fully understood it to the end, I say.Parinhatantam tathagatassa. So BBS and SBJ eds. and MA,
though PTS ed. reads simply parinnatam. MA glosses:
"fully understood to the conclusion, fully understood to
the limit, fully understood without remainder." It
explains that while Buddhas and disciple-arahants are
alike in abandoning all defilements, there is a distinction
in their range of full understanding: whereas disciples
can attain Nibbana after comprehending with insight
only a limited number of formations, Buddhas fully
understand all formations without exception.
"He directly knows water as water...Nibbana as
Nibbana.
......
Why is that?
Because the Tathagata has fully understood it to the end, I say.
"Bhikkhus, the Tathagata, accomplished and fully enlightened,
directly knows earth as earth.
Having directly known
earth as earth, he does not conceive [himself as] earth, he does
not conceive [himself] in earth, he does not conceive [himself
apart] from earth, he does not conceive earth to be 'mine,' he
does not delight in earth.
Why is that?
Because he has understood that delight is the root of suffering, and that with being [as
condition] there is birth, and that for whatever has come to be
there is ageing and death.This sentence gives a highly compressed statement of the
formula of dependent origination (paticca samuppMa),
usually expounded in twelve factors (as in MN 38). As
interpreted by MA, "delight" is the craving of the previous
life that brought into being the "suffering" of the five
aggregates in the present life, "being" the kammically
determinative aspect of the present life that causes future
birth, followed by future ageing and death. This passage
shows the cause for the Buddha's elimination of conceiving
to be his penetration of dependent origination on the
night of his enlightenment. The mention of "delight"
(:nandi) as the root of suffering links up with the sutta's
title; moreover, by referring to the earlier statement that
the ordinary person delights in earth, etc., it shows suffering
to be the ultimate consequence of delight.
Therefore, bhikkhus, through the
complete destruction, fading away, cessation, giving up, and
relinquishing of cravings, the Tathagata has awakened to
supreme full enlightenment, I say.MA explains the sequence of ideas thus: The Tathagata
does not conceive earth and does not delight in earth
because he has understood that delight is the root of suffering.
Further, by understanding dependent origination,
he has completely abandoned the craving here
called "delight" and has awakened to supreme full
enlightenment. As a result he does not conceive earth or
delight in earth.
"He directly knows water as water...Nibbana as
Nibbana.
......
Why is that?
Because he has understood that delight
is the root of suffering, and that with being [as condition] there is
birth, and that for whatever has come to be there is ageing and
death.
Therefore, bhikkhus, through the complete destruction,fading away, cessation, giving up, and relinquishing of cravings,
the Tathagata has awakened to supreme full enlightenment,
I say."
That is what the Blessed One said.
But those bhikkhus did not
delight in the Blessed One's words.The bhikkhus did not delight in the Buddha's words,
apparently because the discourse probed too deeply into
the tender regions of their own conceit, and perhaps their
residual brahmanic views. At a later time, MA tells us,
when their pride had been humbled, the Buddha
expounded to these same bhikkhus the Gotamaka Sutta
(AN 3:123/i.276), in the course of which they all attained
arahantship.