Issues
Select Version
Tikanipātapāḷi
Tikanipātapāḷi

34(4)Causes

Author: Bhikkhu Bodhi @ IAPT

34(4)Causes

“Bhikkhus,there are these three causes for the origination of kamma.
What three?
Greed is a cause for the origination ofkamma;hatred is a cause for the origination of kamma;delusion is a cause for the origination of kamma.
(1)"Any kamma,bhikkhus,fashioned through greed,born of greed,caused by greed,originated by greed,ripens wherever the individual is reborn.
Wherever that kamma ripens,it is there that one experiences its result,either in this very life,or in the[next]rebirth,or on some subsequent occasion.There are some differences in the readings: Ce ditthe va dhamme, upapajje va, apare va pariyaye; Be ditthe va dhamme upapajja va apare va pariyaye; Ee ditth' eva dhamme upapajje va apare va pariyaye. Mp says: "This is stated to show that the kamma is [of the type] either to be experienced in this present life, or to be experienced follow ing rebirth, or to be experienced in some subsequent existence." For an Abhidhamma explanation of this triad, see CMA 205. Some scholars have argued from the variant readings that only two alternatives are involved: either in this life or upon rebirth. However, I translate in accordance with the commen tarial understanding. While the commentaries may be impos ing a later interpretation on more archaic texts that asserted only two ways in which kamma can ripen, as a translator I feel responsible to the text that has been transmitted rather than to theories about a more archaic original. The recognition of a threefold ripening of kamma is not exclusive to the Theravada school but is also found in the treatises of the Sarvastivada Abhi dharma system. Definitions of the three types— for example, in1640 The Anguttara Nikaya the Abhidharma Mahavibhasa Sastra at T XXVII 592a22—593b8, and in the Abhidharmakosa at T XXIX 81cio-i6— are exactly the same as in the Pali tradition and thus likely precede the divisioii of the schools.372
(2)“Any kamma fashioned through hatred,born of hatred,caused by hatred,originated by hatred,ripens wherever theindividual is reborn.
Wherever that kamma ripens,it is therethat one experiences its result,either in this very life,or in the[next]rebirth,or on some subsequent occasion.
(3)“Any kamma fashioned through delusion,born of delusion,caused by delusion,originated by delusion,ripens wherever the individual is reborn.
Wherever that kamma ripens,it is there that one experiences its result,either in this very life,or in the-[next]rebirth,or-on some subsequent occasion.
“Suppose,bhikkhus,seeds that are intact,unspoiled,not damaged by wind and the sun's heat,fecund,well preserved,were deposited in well-prepared ground in a good field and receive proper rainfall:
and receive proper rainfall:
in this way,those seeds would grow,increase,and mature.
So too,any kamma that is fashioned through greed...hatred...delusion,born of delusion,caused by delusion,originated by delusion,ripens wherever the individual is reborn.
Wherever that kamma ripens,it is there that one experiences its result;either in this very life,or in the[next]rebirth,or on some subsequent occasion.
“These are the three causes for the origination of kamma.
“Bhikkhus,there are these three [other]causes for the origination of kamma.
What three?
Non-greed is a cause for the origination of kamma;non-hatred is a cause for the origination of kamma;non-delusion is a cause for the origination of kamma.
(1)“Any kamma,bhikkhus,fashioned through non-greed, born of non-greed,caused by non-greed,originated by non- greed,is abandoned when greed has vanished;it is cut off at the root,made like a palm stump,obliterated so that it is no more subject to future arising.This statement has to be carefully interpreted. For an arahant— who has abandoned greed, hatred, and delusion— kamma created earlier, whether good or bad, is still capable of ripening during the final life. But because there is no more rebirth, with his passing all accumulated kamma from the past becomes defunct. Thus the intention of this statement is not that an arahant's past kamma cannot ripen while the arahant lives, but that it becomes defunct with the arahant's passing; for there will be no further continuum of existence within which its fruits might arise. Brahmali writes: "There must be a distinction here between 'non-greed' (alobha) and the situation when 'greed has vanished' (lobhe vigata). The former must refer to the motivation behind a particular action, the latter to the full uprooting of greed, attained only by the non-returner or even the arahant. Only in the light of this distinction does this statement make sense."
(2)“Any kamma fashioned through non-hatred,born of non-hatred,caused by non-hatred,originated by non-hatred; is abandoned when hatred has vanished;it is cut off at the root, made like a palm stump,obliterated so that it is no more subject to future arising.
(3)"Any kamma fashioned through non-delusion,born of non-delusion,caused by non-delusion,originated by non-delusion,is abandoned when delusion has vanished;it is cutoff at the root,made like a palm stump;obliterated so that it isno more subject to future arising
“Suppose,bhikkhus,there are seeds that are intact,unspoiled,[136]not damaged by wind and the sun's heat,fecund,well preserved.
Then a man would burn them in a fire,
reduce them to ashes,
and winnow the ashes in a strong wind or let them be carried away by the swift current of a river.
In this way,those seeds would be cut off at the root,made like a palm stump,obliterated so that they are no more subject to future arising.
So too,any kamma that is fashioned through non-greed..
non-hatred...non-delusion,born of non-delusion,caused by non-delusion,originated by non-delusion,is abandoned when delusion has vanished;it is cut off at the root,made like a palm stump,obliterated so that it is no more subject to future arising.”
“These,bhikkhus,are the three causes for the origination of kamma.”
Whatever kamma an ignorant person [has done]born of greed,hatred,and delusion,
it is to be experienced right here:there exists no other site [for it].I read .with. Ce and Be mohajan capaviddasu-, as against Ee's mohajan capi 'viddasu. Mp (both Ce and Be) also reads mohajan capaviddasu, which it resolves into mohajancapi aviddasu. It paraphrases the meaning thus: "Whatever kamma the blind, ignorant worldling creates born of greed, hatred, and delusion—whether the kamma so fashioned be little or much— it is to be experienced right here (idh'eva tam vedaniyam), that is, it is to be experienced by the fool here in his very own being (idha sake attabhaveyeva); this means that it ripens in his own individual beings There exists no other site [for it] (vatthum annam na vijjati): there is no other site for the ripening of that kamma; for the kamma done by one person does not ripen in another's being."
Therefore a wise person should abandon [any deed]born of greed,hatred,and delusion.
A bhikkhu,giving rise to knowledge,should abandon all bad destinations.Tasma lobharn ca dosam ca, mohajam capi viddasu. Ee reads.The last pada mohan capi 'viddasu, which is missing a syllable. The text does lack a verb and direct object qualifed by mohajam. Mp supplies these in its paraphrase: "Therefore a wise person does not do that kamma born of greed and so forth" {yo iridu . . . tam lobhajadibhedam kammam na karoti). It will be noted that Mp con siders lobham and dosam to be truncated forms of lobhajam and dosajam, and I translate accordingly. For the verb, I see jahe of pada d to implicitly extend up into padas a and b, thus doing a dual service.