Issues
Select Version
Tikanipātapāḷi
Tikanipātapāḷi

78(8)Setting Up

Author: Bhikkhu Bodhi @ IAPT

78(8)Setting Up

Then the Venerable Ananda approached the Blessed One “
...
The Blessed One then said to him:
“Ananda,are all behavior and observances,[austere]life-styles,and spirituai life fruitful when set up as the essence?'Silabbatam jīvitam brahmacariyam upatthānasaram.From these quence,it is unclear whether upatthanasara is one term parallel to the others or a distributive applying to each of the predecessors.Mp glosses as if the latter is the case,that is,as if it meant the setting up of the former three practices,taking them to be the core or essence of spiritual life:Upatthanena saram'idam varamidam nittha'ti evam upatthitan(“Setting them up as the essence,having set them up [with the conviction]that they are excellent,the goal").The same sequence of terms is at Ud 6:8,71,29-32.Ud-a351,9-17,allows both interpretations:either as a distributive or as one additional type of ascetic practice,perhaps the“carrying out“of certain ascetic practices.Collectively,the three (or four)terms represent the extreme of self-mortification;specific practices are described below at 3:156 S2 where they are called“the blistering way of practice."The opposite extreme is the view that there is no harm in sensual pleasures,which corresponds to the sensualist practice described at 3:156 S1.The Buddha's"middle way,"at 3:156 S3,avoids the two extremes.
“Not exclusively so,Bhante.”
“Well then,Ananda,distinguish [themJ.”
Bhante,suppose one cultivates behavior and observances,an[austere]lifestyle,and a spiritual life,setting them up as if they were the essence.If unwholesome qualities then increase and wholesome qualities decline,such behavior and observances,[austere]lifestyle,and spiritual life,set up as the essence,are fruitless.
But if unwholesome qualities decline and wholesome qualities increase,then such behavior and observances,[austere]lifestyle,and spiritual life,set up as the essence,are fruitful.”
This is what the Venerable Ananda said.
The Teacher agreed.
Then the Venerable Ananda,thinking,“The Teacher has agreed,"paid homage to the Blessed One,circumambulated him keeping the right side toward him,and left.
Then,not long after the Venerable Ananda had left,the Blessed One addressed the bhikkhus:
“Bhikkhus,Ananda is a trainee,
but it is not easy,to find one equal to him in wisdom.”