Issues
Select Version
The Book of the Tens
The Book of the Tens

27(7)Great Questions(1)

Author: Bhikkhu Bodhi @ IAPT

27(7)Great Questions(1)

On one occasion the Blessed One was dwelling at Savatthī in Jeta's Grove,Anāthapindika's Park.
Then,in the morning,a number of bhikkhus dressed,took their bowls and robes,and entered Savatthi for alms.
Then it occurred to those bhikkhus:
"It is still too early to walk for alms in Savatthī.
Let us go to the park of the wanderers of other sects."
Then those bhikkhus went to the park of the wanderers of other sects.
They exchanged greetings with those wanderers
and,when they had concluded their greetings and cordial talk,sat down to one side.
Those wanderers then said to them:
"Friends,the ascetic Gotama teaches the Dhamma to his disciples in such a way as this:

'Come,bhikkhus,directly know all phenomena.Sabbam dhammam.I understand the singular to be doing service for the plural sabbe dhamme.

Dwell having directly known all phenomena.'Ce and Ee sabbam dhammam abhinnaya abhinnaya.Be lacks the repetition.

We too teach the Dhamma to our disciples in such a way as this:
'Come,friends,directly know all phenomena.Dwell having directly known all phenomena.'
What now is the distinction,the disparity,the difference between the ascetic Gotama's [49]teaching of the Dhamma and our teaching,between his instruction and our instruction?"
Then those bhikkhus neither applauded nor rejected the statement of those wanderers.
Without applauding it,without rejecting it,they rose from their seats and left,[thinking]:
"We shall find out what the Blessed One has to say about this statement."
Then,when those bhikkhus had walked for alms in Savatthi,after their meal,on returning from their alms round,they approached the Blessed One,
paid homage to him,sat down to one side,
and said:
"Here,Bhante,in the morning,we dressed,took our bowls and robes,and entered Sāvatthī for alms...[They here report the entire course of events;down to:]
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
[50]We rose from our seats and left,(thinking):
'We shall find out what the Blessed One has to say about this statement.'"
“Bhikkhus,when wanderers of other sects speak thus,they should be answered in this way:
'A question about one,a concise statement about one,an explanation of one.Despite the grammatical form of the sentences,I believe that this rendering does better justice to the sense than a literal translation,"One question,one concise statement,one explanation."The"twos"and higher numbers do not present"two questions, etc.,""three questions,etc.,"and so forth,but a question about two items,a question about three items,and so forth.A question about two,a concise statement about two,an explanation of two.A question about three,a concise statement about three,an explanation of three.A question about four,a concise statement about four,an explanation of four.A question aboutfive,a concise statement about five,an explanation of five.A question about six,a concise statement about six,an explanation of six.A question about seven,a concise statement aboutseven,an explanation of seven.A question about eight,a con-cise statement about eight,an explanation of eight.A question about nine,a concise statement about nine,an explanation of nine.A question about ten,a concise statement about ten,an explanation of ten.
If wanderers of other sects were questioned thus,they would not be able to reply and,further,they would meet with distress.
For what reason?
Because that would not be within their domain.
I do not see anyone,bhikkhus,in the world with its devas,Mara,and Brahma,in this populationwith its ascetics and brahmins,its devas and humans,who could satisfy the mind with an answer to these questions apart from the Tathāgata or a disciple of the Tathāgata or one who has heard it from them.
(1)"When it was said:‘A question about one,a concise statement about one,an explanation of one,'
with reference to what was this said??The Chinese parallel at EA 46.8(T II 778b17)provides some interesting points of contrast.The Pali version is more cogent with respect to certain items,particularly the fours,fives,sixes,and tens;here EA 46.8 has the four noble truths,the five spiritual faculties,the six principles of communal harmony,and the ten kinds of mindfulness(the six recollections,mindfulness of the body,of death,of breathing,and of peace).EA 46.8 provides explanations of the items in each group,which calls our attention to what is missing in the Pali version.While the Pali version announces three categories for each number—the question (panha),the concise statement(uddesa),and the explanation(veyyakarana)—the sutta presents only two,the question and the concise statement,but not the explanation.The Kumārapanha section of the Khuddakapatha(S4)partly overlaps this list,but since the latter simply lists items to be remembered,without reference to disenchantment and dispassion,it includes positive sets:the four noble truths,the seven enlightenment factors,the eightfold path,and the ten factors of an arahant.
When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with one thing,completely dispassionate toward it,completely liberated from it,completely sees its delimitations,and completely breaks through its meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What one thing?
All beings exist through nutriment. [51]When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with this one thing,completely dispassionate toward it,completely liberated from it,completely sees its delimitations,and completely breaks through its meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
"When it was said:'A question about one,a concise statement about one,an explanation of one,'it is with reference to this that this was said.
(2)"When it was said:'A question about two,a concise statement about two;an explanation of two,'
with reference to what was this said?
When a bhikkhuis completely disenchanted with two things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What two things?
Name and form.When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with these two things...in this very life he makes an end of suffering."
When it was said:'A question about two,a concise statement about two,an explanation of two,'it is with reference to this that this was said.
(3)"When it was said:'A question about three,a concisestatement about three,an explanation of three,'
with referenceto what was this said?
When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with three things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,inthis very life he makes an end of suffering.
What three things?
The three kinds of feelings.Pleasant feeling,painful feeling,and feeling that is neither painful nor pleasant.When a bhikkhu is comapletely disenchanted with these three things...in this very life hemakes an end of suffering.
"When it was said:'A question about three,a concise state-ment about three,an explanation of three,'it is with referenceto this that this was said.
(4)"When it was said:'A question about four,a concise statement about four,an explanation of four,'
with reference to what was this said?
[52]When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with four things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What four things?
The four kinds of nutriment.Edible food,contact,mental volition,and consciousness.These are called nutriment (ahara)in the sense that they sustain the continuity of existence.When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with these four things:..in this very life he makesan end of suffering.
"When it was said:'A question about four,a concise statement about four,an explanation of four,'it is with reference to this that this was said.
(5)"When it was said:'A question about five,a concise state-ment about five,an explanation of five,'
with reference to what was this said?
When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with five things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What five things?
The five aggregates subject to clinging.When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with these five things...in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
"When it was said:'A question about five,a concise statement about five,an explanation of five,'it is with reference to this that this was said.
(6)"When it was said:'A question about six,a concise statement about six,an explanation of six,'
with reference to what was this said?
When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with six things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,andcompletely breaks through their meaning,in this very life hemakes an end of suffering.
What six things?
The six internal sense bases.When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with these six things...in this very life he makes an end of suffering.[53]
"When it was said:'A question about six,a concise statement about six,an explanation of six,'it is with reference to this that tlis was said.
(7)"When it was said:'A question about seven,a concisestatement about seven,an explanation of seven,'
with reference to what was this said?
When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with seven things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What seven things?
The seven stations for consciousness.See 7:44.When a bhikkhu is com-pletely disenchanted with these seven things...in this very lifehe makes an end of suffering
"When it was said:'A question about seven,a concise statement about seven,an explanation of seven,'it is with reference to this that this was said.
(8)"When it was said:'A question about eight,a concisestatement about eight,an explanation of eight,'
with referenceto what was this said?
When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanited with eight things;completely dispassionate toward them;completely liberated from then,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What eight things?
The eight worldly conditions.See 8:6. When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with these eight things...in this very life hemakes an end of suffering.
"When it was said:'A question about eight,a concise statement about eight,an explanation of eight,'it is with reference to this that this was said.
(9)"When it was said:'A question about nine,a concise statement about ruine,an explanation of nine,'
with reference to what was this said?
When a bhikkhu is completely disenchanted with nine things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What nine things?
The nine abodes of beings.See 9:24. [54]When a bhikkhu is completely disenchantedwith these nine things...in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
"When it was said:'A question about nine,a concise statement about nine,an explanation of nine,'it is with reference to this that this was said.
(10)"When it was said:'A question about ten,a concise statement about ten,an explanation of ten,'
with reference to what was this said?
When a bhikkhuis completely disenchanted with ten things,completely dispassionate toward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
What ten things?
The ten unwholesome courses of kamma.I follow Be and Ee dasasu akusalesu kammapathesu,as agaimst Cedasasu akusalesu dhammesu.Ce has dasasu kusalesu kammapathesu at 10:28 S10. When a bhikkhu is completelydisenchanted with these ten things,completely dispassionatetoward them,completely liberated from them,completely sees their delimitations,and completely breaks through their meaning,in this very life he makes an end of suffering.
"When it was said:A question about ten,a concise statement about ten,an explanation of ten,it is with reference to this that this was said."