Issues
Select Version
AI Translations
language.en-US
Dhammasaṅgaṇī-anuṭīkā
  • Vīsatigāthāvaṇṇanā
  • Nidānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Sumedhakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 1. Cittuppādakaṇḍaṃ
  • Tikamātikāpadavaṇṇanā
  • Dukamātikāpadavaṇṇanā
  • Suttantikadukamātikāpadavaṇṇanā
  • Kāmāvacarakusalapadabhājanīyavaṇṇanā
  • Kāmāvacarakusalaṃ
  • Kāyakammadvārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Vacīkammadvārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Manokammadvārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kammakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Akusalakammapathakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kusalakammapathakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kammapathasaṃsandanakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Dhammuddesavārakathā
  • Phassapañcamakarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Jhānaṅgarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Indriyarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Maggaṅgarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Balarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Mūlarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Kammapatharāsivaṇṇanā
  • Passaddhādiyugalavaṇṇanā
  • Yevāpanakavaṇṇanā
  • Kāmāvacarakusalaṃ
  • Niddesavārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Koṭṭhāsavārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Suññatavārādivaṇṇanā
  • Rūpāvacarakusalaṃ
  • Catukkanayo
  • Paṭhamajjhānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Dutiyajjhānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Tatiyajjhānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Pañcakanayavaṇṇanā
  • Paṭipadācatukkādivaṇṇanā
  • Kasiṇakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Abhibhāyatanakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Vimokkhakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Brahmavihārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Asubhakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Arūpāvacarakusalakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Tebhūmakakusalavaṇṇanā
  • Lokuttarakusalavaṇṇanā
  • Lokuttarakusalaṃ
  • Pakiṇṇakakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Paṭhamamaggavīsatimahānayavaṇṇanā
  • Catumagganayasahassavaṇṇanā
  • Akusalapadaṃ
  • Dhammuddesavāro
  • Paṭhamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Niddesavārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Tatiyacittavaṇṇanā
  • Catutthacittavaṇṇanā
  • Navamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Ekādasamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Dvādasamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Abyākatapadaṃ
  • Ahetukakusalavipākavaṇṇanā
  • Aṭṭhamahāvipākacittavaṇṇanā
  • Vipākuddhārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Rūpāvacarārūpāvacaravipākakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Lokuttaravipākakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kiriyābyākatakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 2. Rūpakaṇḍaṃ
  • Uddesavaṇṇanā
  • Tividharūpasaṅgahavaṇṇanā
  • Catubbidhādirūpasaṅgahavaṇṇanā
  • Rūpavibhatti
  • Ekakaniddesavaṇṇanā
  • Dukaniddeso
  • Upādābhājanīyavaṇṇanā
  • Noupādābhājanīyakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Catukkaniddesavaṇṇanā
  • Pañcakaniddesavaṇṇanā
  • Pakiṇṇakakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 3. Nikkhepakaṇḍaṃ
  • Tikanikkhepakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Dukanikkhepakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Suttantikadukanikkhepakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 4. Aṭṭhakathākaṇḍaṃ
  • Tikaatthuddhāravaṇṇanā
  • Dukaatthuddhāravaṇṇanā
Dhammasaṅgaṇī-anuṭīkā
  • Vīsatigāthāvaṇṇanā
  • Nidānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Sumedhakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 1. Cittuppādakaṇḍaṃ
  • Tikamātikāpadavaṇṇanā
  • Dukamātikāpadavaṇṇanā
  • Suttantikadukamātikāpadavaṇṇanā
  • Kāmāvacarakusalapadabhājanīyavaṇṇanā
  • Kāmāvacarakusalaṃ
  • Kāyakammadvārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Vacīkammadvārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Manokammadvārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kammakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Akusalakammapathakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kusalakammapathakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kammapathasaṃsandanakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Dhammuddesavārakathā
  • Phassapañcamakarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Jhānaṅgarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Indriyarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Maggaṅgarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Balarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Mūlarāsivaṇṇanā
  • Kammapatharāsivaṇṇanā
  • Passaddhādiyugalavaṇṇanā
  • Yevāpanakavaṇṇanā
  • Kāmāvacarakusalaṃ
  • Niddesavārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Koṭṭhāsavārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Suññatavārādivaṇṇanā
  • Rūpāvacarakusalaṃ
  • Catukkanayo
  • Paṭhamajjhānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Dutiyajjhānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Tatiyajjhānakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Pañcakanayavaṇṇanā
  • Paṭipadācatukkādivaṇṇanā
  • Kasiṇakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Abhibhāyatanakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Vimokkhakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Brahmavihārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Asubhakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Arūpāvacarakusalakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Tebhūmakakusalavaṇṇanā
  • Lokuttarakusalavaṇṇanā
  • Lokuttarakusalaṃ
  • Pakiṇṇakakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Paṭhamamaggavīsatimahānayavaṇṇanā
  • Catumagganayasahassavaṇṇanā
  • Akusalapadaṃ
  • Dhammuddesavāro
  • Paṭhamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Niddesavārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Tatiyacittavaṇṇanā
  • Catutthacittavaṇṇanā
  • Navamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Ekādasamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Dvādasamacittavaṇṇanā
  • Abyākatapadaṃ
  • Ahetukakusalavipākavaṇṇanā
  • Aṭṭhamahāvipākacittavaṇṇanā
  • Vipākuddhārakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Rūpāvacarārūpāvacaravipākakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Lokuttaravipākakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Kiriyābyākatakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 2. Rūpakaṇḍaṃ
  • Uddesavaṇṇanā
  • Tividharūpasaṅgahavaṇṇanā
  • Catubbidhādirūpasaṅgahavaṇṇanā
  • Rūpavibhatti
  • Ekakaniddesavaṇṇanā
  • Dukaniddeso
  • Upādābhājanīyavaṇṇanā
  • Noupādābhājanīyakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Catukkaniddesavaṇṇanā
  • Pañcakaniddesavaṇṇanā
  • Pakiṇṇakakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 3. Nikkhepakaṇḍaṃ
  • Tikanikkhepakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Dukanikkhepakathāvaṇṇanā
  • Suttantikadukanikkhepakathāvaṇṇanā
  • 4. Aṭṭhakathākaṇḍaṃ
  • Tikaatthuddhāravaṇṇanā
  • Dukaatthuddhāravaṇṇanā

Tikaatthuddhāravaṇṇanā

Author: AI Translations @ JJ

The term atītārammaṇāvāti is cited as uddhaṭaṃ (extracted), but in many texts, the commentary reading is atītaramāṇaṃ.
Therefore, based on the explanation in the Paṭiccasamuppāda-vibhaṅga-vaṇṇanā (Vibh. A. 227), it is said: “At the time of death, relatives say, ‘Dear child, a Buddha-pūjā is being performed for your benefit; generate a serene mind,’” and so forth. This describes the presentation of objects such as visible forms through the five sense doors, the occurrence of fourteen consciousnesses ending with tadārammaṇa (resultant consciousness), and the arising of the rebirth-linking consciousness (paṭisandhicitta) in relation to that very object, which exists for a single moment. Thus, it is stated that the rebirth-linking consciousness has a present object (paccuppannārammaṇa).
Due to the weakened intensity caused by proximity to death, there are two bhavaṅga (life-continuum) moments, one āvajjana (adverting consciousness), five javana (impulsion) moments, two tadārammaṇa (resultant) moments, and one cuticitta (death consciousness), making eleven consciousness moments that have passed. Hence, it is said, “with five consciousness moments remaining in life.”
In other cases (itaratthā), it refers to the death consciousness without a tadārammaṇa object.
Now, to explain in detail the meaning briefly stated as itaratthā, it begins with “yadā hi” and so forth.
Since the death consciousness lacks a tadārammaṇa and the rebirth-linking consciousness has a present object, it is cited as “rūpā … pe … jjantassā” (forms, etc., of the dying person).
Six bhavaṅga moments have present objects, and nine consciousness moments have passed, so with seven consciousness moments remaining in life, the rebirth-linking occurs with the sign of destiny (gatinimitta).
By stating, “It takes the existing body as an object,” it is shown that through the pleasant and subtle perception, the present aggregate of derived material form (bhūtupādāyarūpasaṅghāta) is transformed into a state of rapid change, not a future one.
Etthantare means “in the interim,” from the non-manifest time until the manifest time.
Since some things become manifest quickly for some and slowly for others, it is said without specification as “one or two continuity periods” (ekadvesantativārā).
Some say, “It is stated for the sake of smooth expression.” Others, however, say: “In this interim, material and immaterial phenomena that are taken as present constitute one continuity period (santativāra). This is divided into two parts: one portion from the non-manifest time up to mostly the manifest time, and another from mostly the manifest time up to the fully manifest time. These are the two continuity periods.
The remaining divisions of continuity periods should be understood in this manner.
Here, without assuming uniformity in terms of time, the division of continuity should be explained based on the similar occurrence of phenomena.”
They say that material phenomena arising from temperature, consciousness, etc., even if occurring similarly for some time, are called continuity periods.
When it is said, “atiparittā” and so forth, the immaterial continuity (arūpasantati) is included here as defined by the material continuity mentioned above.
It is said, “Gathered among present phenomena,” meaning they are drawn by craving and views as objects to be grasped.
The statement, “Friend, the mind and mental phenomena,” refers to phenomena as object and subject, belonging to one existence and included in one continuity, which, when taken without division, constitute the addhāpaccuppanna (duration-present). But when division is made, the khaṇasantatipaccuppanna (moment-continuity-present) is obtained. Hence, it is said, “This is both when it is addhāpaccuppanna.”
To them refers to the majority.
Without dividing into past, etc. indicates the method by which āvajjana (adverting) and so forth operate in a uniform manner.
It is established (siddhaṃ hoti) means that even with a momentary present object, this text is well-applied to the preparatory and higher knowledge (cetopariyañāṇa).
The past triad (atītattika) remains undivided, as when phenomena are taken as present in the momentary sense here, it reveals the condition of immediacy (anantarapaccaya) included in other terms. Thus, in the Paṭṭhāna, the past triad is properly extracted without being destroyed.
Alternatively, atītattika refers to the Paṭṭhāna’s past triad text, which, for the reasons stated, remains undivided, unseparated, and consistent with other contexts.
As it occurs means that āvajjana has a future object, while javana has present or past objects, or future, present, or past objects, as applicable.
The intention is that there should not be diversity of objects when taken as present in terms of duration (addhā).
This meaning is stated to show that in a single javana process within one consciousness moment, āvajjana and so forth can have future and other objects. To demonstrate the intended higher knowledge consciousness occurring in the momentary present, it begins with “tenā” and so forth.
The three (tīṇi) refer to: “A phenomenon with a past object is a condition for a phenomenon with a past object through repetition condition (āsevanapaccaya); a phenomenon with a future object for one with a future object; a phenomenon with a present object for one with a present object” (Paṭṭhāna 2.19.34). This means three answers to questions, independent of phenomena included in other terms.
There is no non-repetition means that when repetition is obtained, there is no reason in the Dhamma teaching for its absence. By not stating it, the negation of other questions is understood.
This argument refers to the claim that “even with āvajjana and javana having future or present objects, higher knowledge (cetopariyañāṇa) is established.”
Support condition (nissayabhāva) indicates the validity of the method stated due to its coherence.
That refers to consciousness.
To them refers to the statement that āvajjana and javana have momentary present or ceased objects.
Here, it touches on a specific time, and āvajjana occurs only with a future object, which is not fitting.
Alternatively, if one makes an effort saying, “I know what this person’s mind will be,” then even the preparatory and higher knowledge consciousnesses would have only future objects. Thus, the future or present object nature of āvajjana and javana is not established everywhere. Hence, it is said, “because it is stated regarding occurrence.”
Fault occurrence (dosāpattiyā) means either by incurring a fault or due to a fault.
Understanding a part of a group expresses the view of earlier proponents literally, while knowing the attained expresses the position determined by oneself.
Earlier proponents would not agree because they hold that the term addhāsantatipaccuppanna (duration-continuity-present) is not found in the Abhidhamma matrix’s term paccuppanna.
Here, despite differences in nature, there is no fault of diverse objects due to the absence of difference in mode, as explained by the unity method. Thus, the momentary present object nature of higher knowledge (cetopariyañāṇa) is shown through clarifying the intention of earlier proponents.
However, the commentary states: “When there is a difference in nature, there is no absence of the fault of diverse objects. Thus, in a single consciousness, the present object nature is explained in terms of duration and continuity.” In both arguments, what is reasonable should be considered and accepted.
For this reason means that because no text in the past or arising triads indicates that higher knowledge takes present phenomena as objects, for that reason.
In two knowledges refers to past-life knowledge and higher knowledge (pubbenivāsacetopariyañāṇa).
Taken through action means that, despite being objects, the four aggregates are taken through the door of action by knowledge of action’s consequences (kammūpagañāṇa) as wholesome or unwholesome, without division.
The nature of bad conduct is characterized by association with greed, etc., and good conduct by association with non-greed, etc. Thus, in explaining bad and good conduct, greed and so forth are also explained. Hence, it is said, “bad conduct … explanation occurs.”
  1. For a dhamma without intrinsic nature (asabhāvadhamma), there might be some internal aspect due to the appropriation of internal phenomena by the designation "I" and so on, but for a dhamma with intrinsic nature (sabhāvadhamma), [such designation] does not exist as a being's continuum—thus it is said: "sabhāva... pe... ahonta" (intrinsic nature... [abbreviated]... it would not be).

  1. 对于无自性法(asabhāvadhamma),因“我”(ahaṃ)等概念的施设及对内在法(ajjhattadhamma)的执取,或可有某种内在的范畴;但对于有自性法(sabhāvadhamma),因其处于非有情相续中,故不能说其具有此内在性。所以说“sabhāva…pe… ahontaṃ”(自性……乃至……非有)。

  1. For a non-intrinsic phenomenon, there might be some internal aspect due to the grasping of internal phenomena through designations like ‘I,’ and so forth, but for an intrinsic phenomenon, it is not said to be so, as it is not in the continuity of a non-being. This is stated as ‘inherent nature… not existing.’

For thus, in [the phrase] "for one reviewing one's own aggregates and so on," by way of explaining the meaning of the expression "ajjhattārammaṇā" (having an internal object), [the commentary] will state: "What is internally grasped takes the designation 'I' by the word 'ādi' (and so on)."


例如,于“attano khandhādīni paccavekkhantassa”(观察自己的蕴等时)之处,将通过解释“ajjhattārammaṇā”(内在所缘)一词的含义而说:“(它)以‘ādi’(等)字包括了被执取为内在的‘我’这一概念”。


Thus, in the phrase ‘for one who reflects on one’s own aggregates, and so forth,’ as an explanation of the meaning of the term ‘internal object,’ it will be said, ‘taking up the designation “I” internally, including other designations with the word “etc.”’

If so, should its internal nature also be stated in the Internal Triad?


若然,则对于属于内三法组(ajjhattattika)的事物,是否亦应承认其为内在呢?


If so, should the internal nature also be stated in the internal triad?

No, because just as external nature, so too internal nature is intended in the Internal Triad in an absolute sense (without alternative interpretation).


不,因为在内三法组中,内在性一如外在性,是被直接地、而非转喻地意指的。


No, because just as the external nature is intended in a direct sense in the external triad, so too is the internal nature in the internal triad intended in a direct sense.

As it says: "asabhā... pe... na vutta" (without intrinsic nature... [abbreviated]... not stated).


正如他所说:“asabhā…pe… na vuttaṃ”(无自性……乃至……没有说)。


As it is said: ‘non-inherent… not said.’

"Ākiñcaññāyatanādi" (the base of nothingness and so on) — by the word "ādi" (and so on), it includes [the base's] blameworthy preliminary and access consciousnesses, and the consciousness that reviews, contemplates with relish, etc., which occurs with that as object.


“Ākiñcaññāyatanādi”(无所有处等)中的“ādi”(等)字,包括了其转向心、作为其前行的近行心,以及以它为所缘而生起的运转、省察、味着等心。


‘Ākiñcaññāyatana, etc.’—with the word ‘etc.,’ it includes blameworthy states, the preliminary and access consciousnesses preceding it, and also the consciousnesses that arise with it as an object, such as reviewing, relishing, and so forth.

Having drawn in the base of nothingness by the word "taṃ" (that), [the text] speaks, but it is not stated that [it refers to] all of that—rather, the meaning is: whatever are its preliminaries.


通过‘彼’(taṃ)字牵引出无所有处而说,但并非指所有‘彼’,其义是:以及它的前行心。


It speaks of the dimension of nothingness by drawing it in with the word ‘that,’ but it is not said to be ‘all,’ the meaning being that which precedes it.

"Lesavacanam" (partial statement) — a statement of only a portion by way of partial similarity, by sameness of object.


‘部分语’(lesavacana)是指由于部分相应或所缘相同,而只说及一部分。


‘Lesavacanaṃ’ (partial statement) means the statement of only a part, due to partial similarity by way of having a common object.

For "lesa" means: it is smeared (lissati), adheres (silissati), clings by a portion—thus "lesa."


因为‘部分’(lesa)是黏着(lissati)、附着(silissati)、执着(allīyati)于一部分。


For ‘lesa’ means to cling or stick, to adhere partially.

"Yesaṃ" (of which) — of sense-sphere wholesome, unwholesome, and great functional adverting consciousnesses, of the wholesome-functional division, and of the fourth formless [jhāna].


‘哪些’是指欲界的善、不善、大唯作、转向心,以及色界第四禅的善、唯作之差别。


‘Yesaṃ’ (of which) refers to the sense-sphere wholesome, unwholesome, great functional, and advertence consciousnesses, and to the fourth fine-material jhāna with its division into wholesome and functional.

"Evaṃ upekkhāsahagataniddesādīsu" (thus in the description accompanied by equanimity and so on) — the meaning is: among those stated as associated with neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling, having stated only the description "accompanied by equanimity," the other should not be stated.


像这样,在‘舍俱行解释’等之中,对于那些被说为与不苦不乐受相应者,只说了‘舍俱行解释’,其余的就不必说了。


Thus, in the expositions of states accompanied by equanimity, and so forth, where their association with neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling is stated, the meaning is that by stating only one such exposition, the others need not be stated.

By the word "ādi" (and so on), it includes the description of sense-sphere [phenomena] associated with roots and so on.


‘等’字包括了‘有因相应的欲界’等解释。


By the word ‘ādi’ (etc.), it includes the expositions of sense-sphere states associated with roots, and so forth.

For even there, among dhammas stated as "limited with root" and so on, having stated only one, the other should not be stated.


在那里,对于以有限、有因等方式被说及的诸法,也只说其一,其余的就不必说了。


There too, when certain phenomena are described as being limited, having a root, and so forth, only one is stated, and the others need not be.

"Abhāvanāniṭṭhappavattiyā" (by the supreme occurrence of the mode of non-existence) — the meaning is: by the supreme occurrence of the mode of non-existence, or by the supreme occurrence of non-existence.


‘非修习的究竟生起’(abhāvanāniṭṭhappavatti)是指非修习行相的卓越生起,或指‘无’的卓越生起。


‘Abhāvanāniṭṭhappavattiyā’ (by the occurrence culminating in non-development) means by the supreme occurrence of the mode of non-development, or by the supreme occurrence of absence.

The intention is: it should not be stated as having an internal object and so on.


其意趣是:它通过内在所缘等方式而成为‘不可说’。


The intention is that it has become indescribable by way of being an internal object, and so forth.

"Tāni" (those) — the adverting and so on that have the same object as the base of nothingness.


‘那些’是指与无所有处有相同所缘的转向等心。


‘Tāni’ (those) refers to advertence and so forth, which have the same object as the dimension of nothingness.

If so, why is it said "abhāvanāsāmaññe" (in the generality of non-existence)?


如果这样,那为什么说‘在非修习的共通性中’呢?


If so, why was it said, ‘due to the generality of non-development’?

For doesn't the consciousness that occurs by way of reviewing, relishing, etc., [with] the object of the base of nothingness occur with the mode of non-existence?


难道以无所有处为所缘,通过省察、味着等方式而生起的心,没有以非修习行相的生起吗?


For consciousnesses that occur by way of reviewing, relishing, and so forth, with the dimension of nothingness as their object, do not occur in the mode of non-development.

No, because what is intended is what should not be developed.


不,因为其意趣是‘应被非修习’。


No, because it is intended in the sense of what ought not to be developed.

For "abhāvana" (non-development) means "it should not be developed," not "it does not develop."


所谓‘非修习’(abhāvana),是因为它不被修习(na bhāvīyati),而不是因为它不修习(na bhāveti)。


For ‘abhāvana’ means ‘not being developed,’ not ‘does not develop.’

In "gahaṇavisesanimmitāni" (created by special perception) and so on, this is the intention: although for the most part exalted dhammas occur [with regard to] objects that do not intrinsically exist, being merely forms created by the knowledge of development, yet by way of grasping an external form, the external nature of kasiṇas and so on [is stated], and thus dhammas with those as object are called "having external objects."


在“由特殊执取所造作”等句中,其意趣是:虽然广大法通常生起于那些仅是由修习智所造作、自性上不存在的行相为对象中,但是,由于执取外在行相,遍处(kasiṇa)等是外在的,因此以它们为所缘的法被称为“外在所缘”。


In phrases such as ‘gahaṇavisesanimmitāni’ (created by a specific grasping), this is the intended meaning: Although for the most part sublime phenomena arise in regard to objects that are mere forms created by meditation-knowledge and do not exist by their own nature, yet by way of grasping the external aspect, there is the externality of the kasiṇas, and so forth. Therefore, the phenomena that have them as objects are called ‘having an external object.’

For the appearance of kasiṇas is known especially by means of the enlarged kasiṇa, abandoning the continuum. But the absence of first formless consciousness has neither an external mode nor an internal mode—thus in that which lacks both modes, the base of nothingness itself, occurring with an unshared mode of occurrence, is stated as having an object not to be stated, not the others which occur with other modes.


因为遍处的显现,是在脱离了(自身)相续之后,通过已增长的遍处而被特别了知的。然而,对于第一无色识的非有,既没有外在行相,也没有内在行相。由于它缺少这两种行相,以一种不共的生起行相而生起的无所有处(ākiñcaññāyatana),才被称为“不可说所缘”,而不是其他以其他行相生起的(法)。


For the appearance of kasiṇas, having abandoned their continuity, is especially recognized by way of the enlarged kasiṇa. However, for the absence of the consciousness of the first immaterial sphere, there is neither an external aspect nor an internal aspect. Since it is devoid of both aspects, only the dimension of nothingness, which occurs with a mode of occurrence not common to any other, is said to have an ‘indescribable object,’ not the others, because they occur with the other aspect.

"Kāmāvacarakusalāna" (of sense-sphere wholesome) — this should be seen as merely an example.


“欲界善”应被视为仅是一个例子。


‘Kāmāvacarakusalāni’ (sense-sphere wholesome states) should be seen as a mere example.

The case ending should be changed in meaning to: "the resultant of the base of nothingness, [and] the resultant of the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception, etc."
"Abhinīhārāsambhavato" (because of impossibility of determining) — because of the impossibility of determining the attainment consciousness.
Having taken "only wholesome [is] the object of resultant," [the text] states "vipākassa" (of the resultant) and so on.
Even though [kasiṇas are] dhammas without intrinsic nature, because they can be grasped with an external mode, like the external nature of kasiṇas, here absolutely by the appropriation of internal phenomena, the designation "I" might have internal nature—thus it is said: "ajjhatta" (internal) and so on.
"And by the word 'khandhādi' (aggregates and so on), the word 'ādi' includes elements, bases, and so on," they say.
"Esa nayo" (this is the method) — [the commentary] states the explanatory method beginning with "having taken the formless aggregates as 'aggregates'" and so on.
"Paresaṃ khandhādiggahaṇe" (in stating others' aggregates and so on) — in the statement, in the utterance of this phrase "paresaṃ khandhādi" (others' aggregates and so on).
Connection: [The commentary] states all upādā-designation by the word "ādi" (and so on).