Commentary on the Āsavas to be Abandoned by Seeing
Showing that phenomena that are objects, even though grasped by wholesome and unwholesome states, reach that condition only through the door of attention, he explains the word "manasikaraṇīye" (to be attended to) as meaning "āvajjitabbe" (to be adverted to).
Things that should be attended to because they bring benefit and happiness are called "manasikaraṇīya" (to be attended to); their opposites are called "amanasikaraṇīya" (not to be attended to), hence he says "amanasikaraṇīyeti tabbiparīte" (not to be attended to means their opposites).
In the remaining phrases such as "appajānanto manasikaraṇīye dhamme" (not understanding phenomena to be attended to).
Because attention to wholesome states through aspects of beauty, happiness, permanence, etc., is blameworthy and brings harm and suffering due to being a cause for relishing, while attention to unwholesome states through aspects of impermanence, etc., is blameless and brings benefit and happiness due to being a cause for disenchantment, therefore having said "there is no fixed rule from the nature of the phenomena," he says "but there is from the aspect."
The particle "vā" is commonly seen with the meaning of alternative in passages such as "mamaṃ vā hi bhikkhave" (or indeed, monks, belonging to me) and "devo vā bhavissāmi devaññataro vā" (I will be a god or some other deity), not with the meaning of conjunction. To show its use with conjunctive meaning there, he says "yathā" (as), etc.
And having done so, this sutta passage indicating conjunctive meaning is cited.
"Kāmāsava" (sensual taint) means the influx regarding sensual pleasures consisting of the five strands of sense pleasure.
Therefore he says "pañcakāmaguṇiko rāgo" (desire for the five strands of sense pleasure).
It would be appropriate that all greed except for bhavāsava (taint of existence) is kāmāsava.
"Rūpārūpabhave" (form and formless existence) means desire and lust for both form and formless existence classified by kamma and rebirth.
"Jhānanikantī" (delight in jhāna) means jhāna-relish.
The desire arising together with eternalist or annihilationist views when one relishes with thoughts like "this state is beautiful, permanent, and stable" is the influx regarding existence, hence bhavāsava.
Thus the meaning is that by including all views under eternalist and annihilationist views, the diṭṭhāsava (taint of views) is subsumed under bhavāsava itself due to the accompanying desire.
However, others say "diṭṭhāsava is also included in avijjāsava."
Here, from the statement "bhavāsava arises in the four cittas associated with greed dissociated from wrong views," the status of desire associated with views as bhavāsava should be investigated. Or perhaps "sahagata" (association) has the meaning of objectifying as in passages like "kāmasahagatā saññāmanasikārā" (perceptions and attention associated with sensuality). If so, the inclusion of diṭṭhāsava in bhavāsava would not occur.
For when there is no connection with that condition, etc., inclusion in that is not appropriate. Therefore, following the canonical text as stated, greed associated with wrong views could also appropriately be kāmāsava.
For the kāmāsavas, etc., which are causes of suffering in this life and future lives, are also stated in two ways.
And in the Abhidhamma description of kāmāsava, the meaning arises: "in sense pleasures means in the object sense pleasures of the three realms that are the object of sensual desire, desire connected with views, etc."
For that craving arising there does not all receive the name of sensual desire, etc.
But if greed could be free from both kāmāsava and bhavāsava, then when it arises in cittas dissociated from wrong views, the ignorance-taint associated with it would be dissociated from taints, and its dissociation from taints would have to be stated, like that associated with aversion, doubt, and restlessness: "The delusion arising in the four cittas associated with greed dissociated from wrong views may be associated with taints or dissociated from taints."
From the statement "kāmāsava arises in the eight cittas associated with greed" and "in dependence on kāmāsava comes diṭṭhāsava and avijjāsava," it cannot be said that greed associated with views is not kāmāsava.
And what would be the difference between covetousness and sensual desire - that they are two taints or one taint? And the existence of greed that is not a taint should be investigated, since it is not covetousness and is not of taint-nature.
For in the Abhidhamma there are the seventh and ninth questions: "taints and non-taints are conditions for taints, and taints are conditions for taints and non-taints."
And in the enumeration it is said "seven due to root-cause," not "nine."
But if there were greed associated with views that is not a taint, the seventh and ninth questions would find their answer, and in the enumeration one would have to say "nine due to root-cause," but this is not said.
Regarding greed dissociated from views that is not a taint, what should be said has been said.
Because sutta teaching is figurative discourse, not literal discourse like Abhidhamma teaching, therefore to show only strong sensual desire as kāmāsava, it is said "kāmāsavoti pañcakāmaguṇiko rāgo" (sensual taint is desire for the five strands of sense pleasure), and similarly "rejoicing in existence."
Having included diṭṭhāsava within bhavāsava generally, since only three taints are mentioned here, to show its inclusion therein, he says "evaṃ diṭṭhāsavo" (thus the taint of views), etc.
For he will state the opposition of bhavāsava to the signless liberation.
"Ignorance regarding the Four Noble Truths" - this is said following the sutta method.
For this is a commentary on the suttas, or because of the inclusion of views about the past, etc.
Just as the kāmāsavas, etc., are analyzed in meaning, so showing their arising and growth, he says "kāmaguṇe" (in sense pleasures), etc.
"Assādato manasikaroto" (attending to with relishing) means attending through relishing with thoughts of "beautiful, pleasant," etc.
"Through the basis of the four distortions" means through being the object of perceptions of beauty, etc.
"In the opposite manner to what was stated" means for one who suppresses and eradicates desire and lust by practicing renunciation preceded by seeing danger in sense pleasures with thoughts like "these sense pleasures are impermanent, suffering, subject to change," unarisen sensual taint does not arise and arisen taint is abandoned.
Similarly, regarding exalted phenomena and all phenomena of the three realms, through the practice of emergence by means of attention to impermanence, etc., preceded by seeing danger, unarisen taints of existence and ignorance do not arise, and arisen ones are abandoned. Thus the elaboration on the bright side should be understood as opposite to the method stated on the side of craving.
Why are only three taints mentioned here in this discussion of abandoning by seeing, and not four as in the Abhidhamma?
There, the opposition of kāmāsava to the desireless liberation should be understood through its nature as craving and aspiration.
The opposition of bhavāsava to the signless liberation should be understood due to grasping permanence in existences through the tendency to grasp at permanence and mostly due to attachment to existence. But regarding the view of existence, there is nothing to be said about its being bhavāsava. The opposition of avijjāsava to the emptiness liberation is due to the power of knowledge through the perception of not-self being established.
Here means in this discussion of the taints.
"Described" means stated.
"Without distinction" means generally.
"Of the kāmāsavas, etc." means of the kāmāsavas, etc., that lead to the human and divine worlds.
But the kāmāsavas, etc., that lead to hell, etc., are included right here under "taints to be abandoned by seeing."
Or alternatively, inasmuch as that person is the basis for taints to be abandoned by seeing, to that extent he is also the basis for the kāmāsavas, etc.
For there is no difference in basis due to difference in terminology. To show this, he says "ettāvatā" (to this extent), etc.
Therefore he says "stated generally."
But why, when the taints to be abandoned by seeing are to be shown here, is doubt shown with "Was I in the past?" etc.? He answers: "With doubt as the head here," etc.
Thus means: just as sixteen-factored doubt arises, so does unwise attention.
Depending on the assumption of eternalism, regarding "Was I in the past age?" he doubts his own existence in the past; depending on the assumption of fortuitous origination, regarding "From when did I begin? Before that, was I not?" he doubts his own non-existence in the past.
Why?
Because doubt grasps two aspects as its object.
But since it takes the past as its object, the dependence on eternalist and fortuitous-origination aspects is shown.
Showing that he should not be criticized for why he generates doubt, which is a wandering and meandering mode of proceeding, and nowhere a cause for non-proceeding, he says "It should not be asked what the reason is."
That very state of being a worldling is itself the reason.
If so, he must have only unwise attention - thinking thus, he says: "But doesn't even the worldling attend wisely?"
There means in wise attention.
Birth, sign, and rebirth means birth as warrior, brahmin, etc., sign as householder, renunciant, etc., and rebirth as deva, human, etc.
Depending on means taking as basis.
At that time the measure of beings is medium, therefore one endowed with that is standard-sized; due to its absence, or due to being past that, he should be understood as non-standard.
Some, namely the teachers of essence and accumulation.
For they say: "He thinks 'How am I? By a lord or Brahmā or by past action or causelessly am I born?'"
Therefore it is said "they say he doubts from a cause."
For doubt about causeless arising is indeed just grasping at a cause.
"In succession" means in progression of before and after.
"Age" is a designation for time, and that should be seen as a term used in the locative sense.
Existence and non-existence: depending on the assumption of eternalism, regarding "Will I be in future age?" he doubts his own existence in the future; depending on the assumption of annihilationism, regarding "From this self-state, after that, will I not be?" he doubts his own non-existence in the future. This should be connected with the method stated below.
"In the present age" - since the present of the age is meant here, it is said "taking rebirth-linking as the beginning," etc.
"Kathankathā" (perplexity) - proceeding as "How is this? How is this?" is kathankathā, doubt; he has that, therefore he is "perplexed," so he says "he is perplexed."
What thought is there about this? For the foolish worldling is like a madman - this is the meaning stated in advance.
That boy of the great queen.
"They shaved him" - because they could not shave him unwillingly with a razor while awake due to family custom, like certain family ascetics, they shaved him while asleep; and they say it was also from fear of the king.
"Cooled" - this is a causal statement for attaining sweet taste.
There is also the reading "setibhūta" (become white) - the meaning is become white from long standing in water.
He doubts his own warrior-status like Kaṇṇa thinking himself a charioteer's son.
When birth is being made manifest, referring to his grasping "I," he says "for thus there would be doubt."
"Humans too like kings" means some certain humans like kings - this is the meaning.
The same method: "depending on shape and form," etc.
Here means in the phrase "How am I?"
"A soul within" means he speaks of an inner self conceived by others.
By the word "ādi" (etc.) in "sixteen," he includes things like body measure, rounded shape, thumb-barley-atom measure, etc.
"The designation of a being is the domain of the soul" - this is just the opinion of those holding wrong views. But ultimately it is the domain of self-state, so he says "the coming and going and standing of self-state" - the meaning is the place from which this one came and where he will go.
"Just as this doubt arises" means: just as this doubt with the distinctions stated arises, so through unwise attention.
By this he states that doubt depends on self-adherence.
For just as doubt proceeds depending on self-adherence, since it was said to grasp the aspects of eternalism, fortuitous origination, eternalism and annihilationism, so self-adherence too proceeds depending on that, due to the perplexed person included in "Was I in the past?" etc. having self-grasping as his support through ego-grasping.
Therefore he says "through the strength of unwise attention together with doubt."
"Vikappa" means uncertainty.
For it is said "a certain view arises."
"With a very strong adherence" means with an extremely strong condition of adherence.
"In that and that" means in that existence.
"Only the present" - by determination he excludes existence in the future, not in the past, because of the possibility of existence there too, since annihilationist grasping would occur.
The meaning is: non-existence only in the past, not in the future.
"With perception-aggregate as head" means with perception-aggregate as foremost, making perception-aggregate the head - this is the meaning.
"Aggregate" means all five aggregates.
Grasping as "self" means adhering with the view "the nature of perceiving is my self."
Like an object to be illuminated, or like a lamp illuminating itself, or like the blue object to be perceived, he perceives the self too - thus from such a view, he becomes one holding wrong view. It is said "I perceive the self by the self itself."
This very meaning is stated by grasping perception and other phenomena as "self" and "not-self" in the way stated: "with perception-aggregate as head," etc.
And here, for one grasping a self free from the aggregates, there is eternalist view; but for one grasping the aggregate as "self," there is annihilationist view. So he says "all are just eternalist or annihilationist views."
"Modes of adherence" means modes of distortion.
"He speaks" - by this he shows his own capacity to awaken makers, feelers, and beings to benefit and happiness.
Therefore he says "maker of verbal action."
"He feels" means the feeler, the feeler himself is what should be felt.
For grammarians consider such terms to have predominantly agent-meaning.
Since there is arising and passing away, impermanence absolutely must be desired; and when there is arising and passing, there is absolutely no permanence. Explaining the intention of one who says "permanent," he says "free from arising and passing."
"Essential" means essential through permanence itself.
"For all time" means existing at all times.
"Natural state" means the innate nature, or the nature called innate as stated with "he speaks," etc.
"Equal to eternity" means together with eternity, eternal-equal; the meaning is stable, permanent-time.
"He will stand just so" means: in whatever way he stood before, now stands, in just that way he will stand in the future too - this is the meaning.
This is a direct demonstration, making the demonstrative "this" refer to something directly perceivable and near.
"Gone by view itself is wrong view" - he says that the word "gata" (gone) is merely an augment.
"Gone into views" means included in wrong views - this is the meaning.
Therefore he says "through inclusion in the sixty-two views."
"Mere going of view" means mere grasping of view.
But just as mountain ravines are difficult to escape from, so too is the thicket of views, so he says "a thicket in the sense of difficulty in escaping."
That water, and having taken that, a wilderness to be crossed is called kantāra, a waterless forest; it is also called what is blown by wind.
Another wilderness region is like a wilderness in the sense of difficulty in crossing - thus the marsh of views, so he says "in the sense of difficulty in crossing," etc.
Piercing through is penetration.
Overturning is the state of transformation.
Due to having an unstable nature, what is disturbed is disturbance, so he says "sometimes," etc.
Like bonds to a criminal, the meaning of bondage is making fettered, preventing escape; the meaning of fetter is, through being a condition for the rounds of defilements, kamma and results, even dragging what has gone far and joining it; views are of such kind, so it is said "fetter of views."
Showing the meaning of bondage through achievement of function - this is the meaning.
Therefore he says "bound by the fetter of views... is released," etc.
"By these" means by these he states that they are conditions for suffering beginning with birth.
Even having shown suffering-states beginning with birth in their individual nature, the Blessed One, saying "he is not released from suffering," made clear this meaning: the fetter of views is indeed something causing all harm, greatly blameworthy, the root of all suffering. To show this, it is said "Or what need of much? He is not released from the suffering of the entire round."
Perhaps here, by showing the fetter of views, adherence to rules and vows should also be shown; for by such showing, the taints to be abandoned by seeing would be shown completely. Referring to this objection, he says "Because," etc.
Adherence to rules and vows is grasped by the very grasping of kāmāsava, etc., because it has kāmāsava, etc., as its cause.
For one with sensual lust, etc., not abandoned grasps at rules and vows for the sake of sensual happiness or purity of existence, thinking "thus there is purity of existence," as stated in the suttas: "By this virtue or vow or austerity or holy life I will become a god or some deity," "There permanent, stable, eternal, not subject to change, equal to eternity I will stand just so," and "Purity by virtue, purity by vows, purity by virtue and vows," they grasp at rules and vows.
There, "for the sake of existential happiness and existential purity" means for the sake of existential happiness and for the sake of existential purity.
"Through its being grasped" means through adherence to rules and vows being grasped by the grasping of views, as in "for the abandoning of wrong views," etc.
"Of them" means of those to be abandoned by seeing.
To show through teaching based on the person.
"Of its opposite" means of the spiritually beautiful worldling who attends wisely.
"Of him" means of the text beginning "having heard," etc.
"That much" means from "having heard" up to the phrase "this is suffering" - making this phrase the limit - this is the meaning.
"By the method stated below" means the connection should be understood by the method stated here in the root exposition, taking respectively the meanings of the phrases: noble persons, noble teachings, good persons' teachings, to be attended to, not to be attended to.
"Opposite to what was stated" means the meaning should be understood as completely opposite to what was stated for these phrases: "having heard, a noble disciple, one who sees noble ones, one who sees good persons." But not completely opposite for the phrases "skilled" and "well-trained."
For an arahant in the ultimate sense is indeed skilled in noble teachings and well-trained in noble teachings.
Therefore he says "by opposition and in all ways... should be understood as a noble disciple."
Knowledge of equanimity toward formations is insight that has reached its peak.
But some say "from knowledge of dissolution onward is insight that has reached its peak" - that is inappropriate.
"With meaning appropriate to that" means with the noble meaning appropriate to that person, not in the sense of penetration - this is the meaning.
For this is a spiritually beautiful worldling.
And just as his trainee-status is stated figuratively in the Trainee Sutta beginning "even a spiritually beautiful worldling is also said to be a trainee," so here his noble disciple-status is stated.
Based on the path-factors counted as noble persons' teachings and discipline, which are the enlightenment-factors with the characteristics of insight leading to emergence, or just the three trainings, his status as noble disciple, etc., is stated.
Therefore he says "with meaning appropriate to that."
Or stated simply as "a disciple of a noble one" just as "The Buddha went to Rājagaha."
And the grasping of insight that has reached its peak here is for the sake of grasping one established in the irreversible path, arousing insight - the commentary on meaning as stated is quite fitting indeed.
Just as one intent on insight through the door of elements is a practitioner of element-meditation, one intent through the door of sense-bases, etc., is a practitioner of sense-base meditation, etc., so one intent through the door of truths is said to be "a practitioner of Four Noble Truths meditation."
Work to be done by those wishing to cross the four floods is kamma, development.
That very work is the place, the cause, for attaining distinction, or in work in the sense stated, the place, non-place, the starting of development is the meditation subject, that very thing proceeding through the door of the Four Truths - he has that, therefore he is a practitioner of Four Noble Truths meditation.
Both do not occur here, hence non-occurrence.
And "one who has grasped the Four Noble Truths meditation subject" means one who, having grasped the Four Noble Truths meditation subject from the text and in meaning, stands having made it fit for attention.
"Having mounted the path of insight" means, having stood in seeing name-and-form with conditions, investigating that very name-and-form as impermanent, etc.
"He brings together" - referring to insight-adverting, therefore the meaning is: he brings together, he adverts, so that insight-knowledge proceeds as "this is suffering."
But how here does the meaning "he sees with insight" come to be stated by this "he attends to"? He says "here... is stated."
"Here" means in this sutta - this is the meaning.
And "he sees with insight" means he sees with the eye of knowledge so that further attainment occurs above, he observes - this is the meaning.
The path should also be stated.
For the first pair of truths is difficult to see due to profundity; the other is profound due to difficulty in seeing.
"Application" means insight-application, insight-practice.
"Having that as object" means proceeding having made that material form-aggregate the object.
"Having determined the characteristic according to actuality" means having placed in the heart without confusion the non-reversed object, one's own object, and both the function of defining individual nature, etc., and the characteristic of ignorance, etc.
By this he shows that even though determination of name-and-form characteristics was done before, with determination of conditions it becomes well-determined, as "twice bound is well bound."
For in this way the function of full understanding through knowledge is accomplished.
Because of being determined from conditions and from what is produced by conditions, accomplishment becomes manifest even through what was already accomplished. It is said "having not been, they come to be."
"He applies the characteristic of impermanence" means: for what does not exist must come to be through arising, not what exists; and because of having arising, their impermanence must absolutely be desired due to condition-dependent occurrence; when there is arising, cessation is inevitable - thus there is no room at all for permanence.
And with impermanence well-established, due to constant affliction by things with arising and passing, it is suffering in the sense of being non-ease.
Therefore he says "through being afflicted by arising and passing, he applies the characteristic of suffering as suffering."
Anywhere in conditioned things, due to non-obtainability as in "may I not age, may I not sicken," there is no mastery, so he says "through lack of mastery, he applies the characteristic of not-self as not-self."
"In succession" means through the sequence of knowledge of arising and passing, etc.
"At that moment" means at the moment of the stream-entry path.
"By one penetration alone" means by penetrating with one knowledge alone.
Penetration is penetration into the object, which is called independent movement in the domain through absence of obstruction.
Comprehension is understanding, which is called attainment of the object through reaching without failing.
Having delimited as "this is suffering, this much is suffering, nothing more than this," the very knowing in the manner stated is penetration - penetration through full understanding.
This is stated regarding the occurrence of knowledge in such a way that after knowledge proceeds, there is no confusion about delimiting suffering's individual nature, etc.; not that path-knowledge proceeds even with "this is suffering," etc.
Therefore he says "for at that time he does not," etc.
Abandonment is distinguished abandonment, giving up, eradication of what is abandoned because it should not be abandoned again - abandonment itself is penetration in the manner stated - penetration through abandonment.
This too is stated because knowledge that brings about the non-arising condition of those defilements that, if not abandoned, there could be no path-development, and which would arise in the absence of path-development - knowledge that destroys their foundation, proceeds without obstruction through independent movement in that manner of proceeding, taking up independent movement.
Realization is making manifest; abandoning hearsay-mode, reasoning, etc., and making an object in its individual form is taking it as just that according to its nature - that itself is penetration in the manner stated - penetration through realization.
But this is stated thus: because that knowledge cannot take cessation as object due to not eradicating a certain obstruction, through eradicating it, that very thing proceeds having been made manifest in its individual form.
Development is production and increase; there, in the first path in the sense of production, in the second, etc., in the sense of increase, or in both senses it should be understood in both ways.
For even the first path, developing full understanding, etc., proceeding in the insight leading to emergence according to capacity, proceeds increasing - thus even there development can be understood in the sense of increase.
And in the second, etc., too, development is in the sense of production through abandoning unabandonded defilements and accomplishing another person.
That itself is penetration in the manner stated - penetration through development.
For this too is stated taking just the proceeding in such a way that after knowledge proceeds, there is no confusion about delimiting path-phenomena in their individual form. Let alone the path-phenomena attained just as they are, even regarding fruit-phenomena proceeding just as they are, this one is free from confusion regarding truth-phenomena attained just as they are.
Therefore it is said "one who has seen the teaching, attained the teaching, understood the teaching, fathomed the teaching."
And because his investigations proceeding from the path-course taking as object truth-phenomena attained just as they are, urged by the nature of phenomena, are of path, fruit, remaining defilements abandoned by the path, and nibbāna.
For truth-phenomena of suffering are identity view, etc.
And this commentary on meaning should be explained also in "through full understanding and comprehension," etc.
"He comprehends with one comprehension" - to show more clearly the meaning stated "he comprehends," he says "but not with one knowledge after another," etc.
But a contentious debater says: "Noble path-knowledge accomplishes its function regarding the Four Truths through different comprehensions, not through one comprehension.
For it fully understands suffering at one time, abandons origin at one time, realizes cessation at one time, develops the path at one time; otherwise the doing of four functions by one knowledge in one moment would not be fitting.
Nor is there any sutta seen anywhere stating this."
He should be told: If noble path-knowledge comprehends the truths through different comprehensions, not through one comprehension, then being so, it would proceed regarding each truth at different moments, not at one moment; that being so, it results that it only fully understands part by part of suffering, etc., and abandons part by part - thus with different comprehensions there would be partial abandonment of the triad of fetters, etc., to be abandoned by the first path, etc. - thus partial stream-entry path-status results, and from that very thing partial stream-winner status follows because of the immediately following fruit of supramundane wholesome states - but that is not fitting.
For it cannot be understood that the very same stream-winner is both a stream-winner and not a stream-winner without temporal difference.
Moreover, this proponent of different comprehensions should be asked: "Does path-knowledge penetrate the truths by object or by function?"
If knowing he should say "by function," having said "for one penetrating by function, why different comprehension?" he should be made to understand by showing the order.
If he should say "by object," then being so, for that knowledge, like insight-knowledge, thorough full understanding and eradication of suffering and origin would not be fitting due to non-abandonment.
Likewise seeing of the path.
For it is not fitting that the path proceeds taking itself as object; but with the imagining of another path, instability results. Therefore for path-knowledge penetrating without confusion, penetrating the three truths by function and cessation both by function and by object, there is absolutely no different comprehension.
For it was said: "Monks, whoever sees suffering, he also sees origin of suffering," etc.
This was not said referring to seeing at another time, because when investigating the state of having comprehension of one truth-seeing and comprehension of other truth-seeing by the Venerable Elder Gavampati, beginning "Now, friends, whoever sees suffering, does he also see origin of suffering... the path leading to cessation of suffering?" he brought that matter for the purpose of establishing that meaning, and because he connected seeing of the triad of truths individually; otherwise, since what was seen before is not seen again, the connection of seeing origin, etc., would be meaningless.
For the supramundane path does not proceed in the manner of accomplishing actions like the mundane path, because of eradicating; and with such connection, all seeing would be immediately after seeing, thus there would be non-cessation of seeing - thus he should be made to understand that different comprehension is not fitting both from scripture and from reasoning.
If he accepts the instruction in this way, that is good.
If he does not accept, he should be instructed from the Abhidhamma in the Odhisokathā.
"Cessation as object" - the restriction should be taken as: cessation only as object, not as just "as object."
By that, penetration by function regarding cessation is also established.
"At that time" means at the comprehension of the truths.
"Twenty-factored," etc. - this is showing the individual form of the three fetters that were stated.
"In the four taints" - this is stated according to the Abhidhamma method, not the sutta method.
For nowhere in the suttas have four taints come.
If doubt is not a taint, then why is it said "identity view, doubt, adherence to rules and vows - these, monks, are called taints to be abandoned by seeing"? He says "'To be abandoned by seeing,'" etc.
"Included here" - by this he shows that here the inclusion of doubt among taints is made through similarity of function in the knowledge-aggregate, like right intention.
All self-grasping is free from identity view - there is none, it is said "of the six views... analyzed."
For that view, while existing in one citta-arising and in the continuity, is one in both places: there, first, oneness in what arises together; the other, oneness in abandonment. To show both of those having been delimited, he says "by view-taints," etc.
"In every way" means in every manner - the meaning is: by the manner of oneness in what arises together and oneness in abandonment.
"The remainder" means remaining from the view-taint.
"The three taints" means sensual taint, existence-taint, and ignorance-taint.
For thus it was said before "in the four taints."
Therefore, because many taints are indeed to be abandoned here, therefore the plural statement was made: "these, monks, are called taints to be abandoned by seeing."
"Of the ancients" means of the commentary teachers; and they say "of the ancient Middle-Length reciters."
What should be said regarding "to be abandoned by seeing," etc., is just what was stated above.
The Commentary on Taints to be Abandoned by Seeing is finished.