Issues
Select Version
Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā(Dutiyo bhāgo)
Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā(Dutiyo bhāgo)

Commentary on detailed explanation of the clause ‘With consciousness as condition, the mentality-materiality’

Author: CHA MYANG HEE @ IAPT

Commentary on detailed explanation of the clause ‘With consciousness as condition, the mentality-materiality’

  1. (638) By analysis ofmind and matter (vibhāgā nāmarūpānaṃ): by classification (pabhedato) of mind and matter.
Then by the teacher who shows firstly the classification of mind, it is said, “Because of inclining on to the object it is the three aggregates, such as, feeling, etc.” in order to show the cause and effect without mixture, even though consciousness also is mind only.
But here in the explanation of rounds of existence as nibbana has no condition and as it has not got the sense of inclining, there is no contingency at all with regard to nibbana.
For it is mind in the sense of making [citta and cetasika] bend (nāmanaṭṭhena) to itself and not in the sense of inclining (nāmanaṭṭhena).
Their analysis tesaṃ vibhāgo: analysis of mind and matter as pleasant, etc. and as earth, etc.
  1. [Expecting] one abode of beings (ekaṃ sattāvāsaṃ): abode of non-percipient beings.
In the five (pañcasu): in the first four and in the abode of non-percipient beings.
  1. By mentioning of womb-lying beings (gabbhaseyya), womb-bom (jalābuja) beings are included. Therefore it is said “and in the case of the egg-bom (aṇḍajānañcā)”.
In the case of the egg-bom beings who are sexless - in this way it should be construed.
Heads of continuity (santatisīsāni): basic processes of material group.
Even though there are no mutable material phenomena at the moment of rebirth-linking, there are characteristic of material phenomena and space element. Thus they are, in ultimate sense, non-concretely produced matters. Hence removing it, it is said “as concrete matter (rūparūpato)”.
It is said, “twenty-three states (tevīsati dhammā)” bringing touch, etc. in formation aggregate as unity.
Canceling (apanetvā): not taking the earth, etc. belonging to another material groups owing to same characteristic.
  1. Of them (tesaṃ): of these Brahmās.
In detail (vitthārena): without making abbreviation of matters in the four heads of continuities also.
  1. Of the remaining kinds ofapparitionally born beings in the sense-sphere becoming (kāmabhave pana yasmā sesaopapātikānaṃ): here there are not apparitionally bom beings said in the sense-sphere becoming, so that the mentioning of the word 'remaining' may be meaningful, but apparitionally-bom and moisture bom beings are the remaining from egg-bom and womb-bom beings. Therefore the word 'remaining' is mentioned -in this way it should be understood.
Or optionally “of the remaining kinds of apparitionally born beings (sesaopapātikānaṃ)” is said with reference to the remaining from the apparitionally bom beings of Brahmā, etc.
But they are immaterial also. Thus it is said, “in sense-sphere becoming (kāmabhave)”.
It is possible to know mind and matter of those whose sense-bases are immatured through enumeration of states in the way stated in the description of rūpamissakaviññāṇa (consciousness mixed with matter) as appropriate. Therefore it is not stated -thus it should be known.
  1. Due to temperature that occurred together with rebirth-linking consciousness (paṭisandhicittena saha pavattaututo): due to fire element of matters arisen together with rebirth-linking consciousness.
Because of weakness of physical basis (vatthudubbalatā) of rebirth-linking consciousness as heart-basis has arisen at that moment.
  1. The bare octad 681 originated by nutriment appears as soon as their body is suffused by nutriment -in this way it is to be constmed.
One hidden (tiro): one beyond the reach of sight due to lying in the womb of the mother.
At the least there are the two bare octads originated by temperature and consciousness. Thus with reference to the time at which sound becomes manifest, it is said, “at most, of the two [sound] enneads (ukkaṃsato dvinnaṃ navakānaṃ)”.
Formerly (pubbe): the matter of which beginning is two continuities,682 of which an end is seven groups is mentioned previously: and that matter is said as just arising of each consciousness in three moments here [in the expression, ‘with consciousness as condition there arise mind and matter’]. Therefore it is said, “with the already mentioned seventy kamma-originated material groups that arise three times in each conscious moment (pubbe ... pe ... sattatividham)".
  1. That is twofold also (duvidhampi taṃ): the sound is twofold also as originated from temperature and originated from consciousness.
196.In order to carry on (saṇṭhātuṃ): in order to stand a long period, but it only stands merely in its moment.
Separately placed in thefour directions (catuddisā vavatthāpitā): separately placed in the four directions at feet, by joining their heads.
Like boats with brokenfloats (bhinnavāhanikā viya): standing by embracing mutually.
  1. (639) And in the course of existence in the five constituent becoming (pañcavokārabhave ca pavattiyaṃ): it is told with reference to the time of occurrence of five consciousnesses produced by kamma that doesn't produce matter and to the condition of consciousness which is co-born.
For at that time from consciousness there arises the mind only.
But it can be said that with kamma consciousness as condition, there arise both mind and matter; and with post-nascent consciousness as condition matter is supported.
The sentence, beginning with, ‘in the non-percipient being (asaññesū) is composed with reference to condition of kamma consciousness.
And in the course of existence in the five constituent becoming (pañcavokārabhave ca pavattiyaṃ): it is proper to say that it is said with reference to the time of appearance of matter from kamma other than kamma that produces life-continuum, etc. and to another time than the time of arising of life-continuum, etc.
For it can be said that matter arising through kamma that produces life-continuum at the time of arising of life-continuum and the resultant, [namely, life-continuum] have condition of kamma consciousness.
For mind and matter arising through kamma in the course of existence, which don't depend on condition of co-nascent consciousness, don't depend on condition of kamma consciousness.
In both cases (sabbattha): at the time ofrebirth-linking and in the course of existence.
Mind-and-matter through condition of co-bom consciousness and mindand-matter through the condition of kamma consciousness should be applied as appropriate.
Mind and matter and mind-matter (nāmañca rūpañca nāmarūpañca): here the word nāmarūpa (mind-matter) is similar to the word nāma(mind) through the word nāma which is one part, and similar to the word rūpa (matter) through the word rūpa which is one part. Therefore there is the remainder of one of its kind. Thus it is ekadesasarūpekasesa (keeping any one part to represent the rest of its kind). The meaning is that the remainder of the word nāmarūpa and omission of the other word nāmarūpa.
  1. Not-resultant (avipākaṃ): consciousness other than the resultant.
When it is known as twofold, then this word is correctly said -thus it should be applied.
  1. At the time of profitable or any other consciousness (kusalādicittakkhaṇet): it should be understood that by the word etc. (ādi) those (matters) originated by kamma that doesn’t produce the result even at the moment of resultant consciousnessjust like at the moment of unprofitable consciousness and functional consciousness, are included.
But at the moment ofthe resultant consciousness, both mind and matter are obtained by the way stated before through the condition of kamma formation consciousness. Therefore to remove the moment of such resultant consciousness, it is said, “at the time of profitable or any other consciousness”.
  1. (640) According to Suttanta method (suttantikapariyāyato): it is said because in Paṭṭhāna, decisive-support condition for matters is not stated.
But in Suttanta when this exists, that exists, and when this doesn’t, that also doesn’t; that [condition] is the decisive support, the origin, the cause and the source for that [effect]. Therefore the state of decisive-support of consciousness for the matter is said as follows: “Mind-and-matter has consciousness as its cause.”
In Vanapatthapariyāya discourse 683 dwellings are described as postures which depend on forest, village, market town, town, district, person: and gaining of requisites for the life, such as, robe from that place with difficulty and with ease. And the forest, etc, don’t reach the state of object-decisivesupport, etc. for postures and for gaining robe, etc.
Therefore non-existence without [some condition] should be understood as the state of decisive-support.
Kamma-formation consciousness is for mind only object condition at the time ofrebirth-linking, of which object is kamma. Therefore there is nothing to be said. The state of condition as one kind for matter only is stated according to Suttanta method.
For when it is said that this consciousness is a condition for matter which is suspected, it is a condition for mind. Therefore there is nothing to be told.
  1. There is the sentence, beginning with, “but how is it (kathaṃ panetaṃ)”: it questions on [mentality-materiality of] rebirth-linking which is not clear, because its course of existence is clear.
Mind is to be known that it has consciousness as condition according to sutta‘, matter is according to logic.
The teacher said, “for the kamma-originated also (kammasamuṭṭhānassāpi hi)”, etc. to make it confirm through sutta, having established according to logic.
Only for the consciousness-originated (cittasamuṭṭhānasseva): like in the case of the consciousnessoriginated [matter] (cittasamuṭṭhānassa viya).
Here because for the wise men who examine, mere mentality-materiality is seen as appearing in ultimate sense, there is neither being nor soul. Therefore, announcing that, “Mentality-materiality has consciousness as condition”, the highest wheel of the righteousness - that was not moved forth by any one - was inaugurated by the Blessed One.
For inaugurating of the wheel of the righteousness is presentation of emptiness.
Or optionally through the word of mere mentality-materiality, the truth of suffering in the round of existence (saṃsāra) is stated.
And by presentation of truth of suffering, its origin and its cessation, and the way leading to cessation are explained only.
Due to absence of suffering which has no cause and due to absence of [any effect] not ceased because of cessation of cause, cessation can not be attained without means. Thus inaugurating of the wheel of righteousness which is the presentation of the four truths should be explained.