Issues
Select Version
Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā(Dutiyo bhāgo)
Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā(Dutiyo bhāgo)

Commentary on detailed explanation of the clause ‘With becoming as condition, birth’, etc.

Author: CHA MYANG HEE @ IAPT

Commentary on detailed explanation of the clause ‘With becoming as condition, birth’, etc.

In the expression “as regards the clause [with becoming as condition] birth ect. (Jātītiādīsu)” the word etc. includes all occurring in: “With birth as condition, there is aging-and-death, and sorrow, lamentation, pain, grief, and despair.”
Therefore there is the sentence, beginning with, “of birth, etc. (8jātiādīnaṃ*)”.
Occurrence as rebirthprocess becoming itself is birth, therefore it is stated “not rebirth-process becoming (na upapattibhavo)”.
But birth of that which is being born is jāti, therefore rebirth-process becoming also can be said as condition for birth, due to absence of birth in the absence of rebirth-process becoming.
For the matter which is arising as a proximate cause for the birth of matter is stated through the expressions, “Collected matter is the proximate cause of production (upacaya); continuous matter is the proximate cause of continuity (santati).”
Inferiority and superiority (hīnapaṇītatā)'. the state of looking down and the state of honourable belonging to aggregates which are arising.
For the undesirable is hīnaṃ and the desirable is paṇītaṃ.
By the word etc. good complexion, bad complexion, low, high, etc. are included.
Even in the case of twins (yamakānampi sataṃ): being born even as twins.
And that (so ca): the difference of beings.
Because different reasons belonging to different continuities is absent in any way, it is stated “in the internal continuity (ajjhattasantāne)”.
Since there is no other reason (Aññassa kāraṇassa abhāvato): since the other different reason is not known apart from [the kamma-process becoming] belonging to one’s own continuity; and because it is difficult to prevent contingency, if the other reason exists, since it doesn’t present always in all; because difference of fruit is not known when the reason is not different.
Therefore it is stated, “It has only kamma-process becoming as root-cause (kammabhavahetukova)
By that (tena tena): by painful state other than aging and death, such as, misfortune of relative.
The states, beginning with, sorrow, which have arisen depending on aging and death are bound up with aging and death; the others are not bound up with.
As the portion of decisive-support (upanissayakoṭiya): part of decisive-support.
For upanissaya which is not found in Paṭṭhāna, which is stated according to Suttanta method - when there exists condition, there arises fruit; when there doesn’t exist condition, there doesn’t arise fruit - it is said as the portion of upanissaya.
It is said that condition of Mahāpadesa is upanissaya.