Commentary on detailed explanation of the clause ‘With the sixfold base as condition, contact’
Associated with twenty-two kinds of mundane consciousness (bāvīsatilokiyaviññāṇasampayuttā): associated with twenty-two kinds of mundane resultant consciousness.
Therefore that twenty-two (bāvīsati) only.
There (tattha): in that sixfold base, in those six bases - this is the meaning.
Internal (ajjhattaṃ): only those included in one’s own continuity are included.
For that which is produced by kamma included in one’s own process is a condition for contact having such like nature.
But visible object, etc, and external states that are not kamma produced are the object of contact. They are not conditions of contact as occurrence, of which cause is kamma defilements included in one’s own process like eye, etc. Therefore they are included in the opinion of some teachers, but when there is the state of condition in any way, it is not possible to reject it. Thus they are included according to opinion of other teachers.
There (tattha): in the expression ‘with the sixfold base as condition, contact’.
Firstly the teachers who belonged to Mahāvihāra take [consciousness, etc.) as resultant only, while pointing out that as consciousness that is condition as well as effect is to be included in one’s own process similarly mentality-materiality, sixfold base, contact and feeling which are condition as well as effect are to be included in one’s own process.
abhidhammabhājanīya Pāḷi expression, “with sixth base as condition, contact” is quoted referring to the immaterial plane. Therefore it is said, “according to the text ‘with the sixth base as condition, contact’ (chaṭṭhāyatanapaccayā phassoti pāḷianusārato). ”
All kinds of contact are not possible [from one base] - in this way it should be construed.
Eighteen kinds of contact would be derived from all bases. The singular number would be proper as “saḷāyatanapaccayā phasso”. After that if all contacts would arise from one base, there is no classification of contact through classification of base due to arising of all contacts from all bases. Thus the singular number would be proper through non-classification of that, but it is not proper because it doesn’t happen like that. Therefore it aroused the question, beginning with, “not from all the bases (na sabbāyatanehi)”.
Or to make known program of non-arising of the other also it is said, “All the kinds of contact are not from one base (nāpi ekamhā āyatanā sabbe phassa).”
But it should be known that only this statement “One contact is not derived from all kinds of base” is the reason which describes non-suitability of talking of single contact.
Or this is stated as an example.
Neither all kinds of contact are derived from one base, nor one contact from all kinds of base. In this way one contact is not derived from all kinds of base.
Therefore referring to a single contact is not proper.
There is the sentence, beginning with, “there this is the answer (tatridaṃ vissajjanaṃ)” while showing the answer that one contact is derived from many bases.
Mental datum base consisting of the remaining associated states (avasesasampayuttadhammayatanā). consciousness concomitants associated with contact, except contact.
Contact, which is of one kind, comes into being from many bases (ekopanekāyatanappabhavo). even single contact is derived from several bases.
Five bases may be explained in six ways in contact’s conditionality; one [should be presented] in nine ways in conditionality; six external bases may be explained in conditionality through object condition, etc. according as appropriate - thus it is to be construed.
For the variously-classed [resultant mind contact] (anekabhedassa): for the manyfold resultant contact, as profitable resultant contact, etc., and as [those contacts] arising through five doors, etc., avoiding contacts associated with twofold five consciousnesses.
And those (tani ca): visible-data base, and so on.
For it is said, “And mind consciousness enjoys object of those five consciousnesses.”
And likewise (tathā ca): it is said referring to present visible object, etc. and to present concrete matter included in mental-data base.
As object condition (Ārammaṇapaccayamattena): it is stated referring to all those that are not present and other mental-data base.