Issues
Select Version
Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā(Dutiyo bhāgo)
Visuddhimagga-mahāṭīkā(Dutiyo bhāgo)

Commentary on explanation of the clause ‘With ignorance as condition, formations’

Author: CHA MYANG HEE @ IAPT

Commentary on explanation of the clause ‘With ignorance as condition, formations’

Referring to the explanation ofthe meaning that will be told, it is said but this (ayaṃ pana).Ven. Mahasi says that the word ayam is nominative case and the word vakkhamanam is accusative, so vakkhamanam cannot be the adjective of ayam. Therefore we expect words, such as, “atthasamvanndnam sandhaya aha".
According to the Suttanta method (suttantapariyāyena): this is said because ignorance about four instances is referred to in the suttas, such as, “Which is, bhikkhus, ignorance? Non-understanding of suffering.”S. ii. 4; S. iv. 256.
As ignorance about eight instances from the point of view of function and birth-place occurs in Nikkhepakanda,Dhs. 190.even though it is said about four instances in suttas, in order to explain its meaning, having begun with “according to Abhidhamma method”, it is said “For this is said (vuttanhetam)”, and so on.
For Abhidhamma method is the classification of what should be classified without omitting.Ven. Mahasi says that vibhajitabbam. vibhajanam should be joined as one sentence as given in Sinhalese version. The word vibhajanahhi should be two separate words as vibhajanam hi.
It should be construed with the phrase “non-understanding ofeight instances” after having quoted it.
About remaining instances (sesatthānesu): about suffering, its origin, and about the past, and so on.
As object (ārammanavasena): as making them its object.
Here (idha) :in this Pāli, such as, “non-understanding ofsuffering”.
That (sā): ignorance.
When arisen (uppannā): arisen due to non-uprooting, needless to say about ignorance present.
It prevents penetration of the true individual function and characteristic [of that truth] (yāthāvasarasalakkhaṇaṃ paṭivijjhituṃ na detī ). this is told in order to show the manner of concealing mentioned as “having concealed”.
Rasa is individual nature that is to be penetrated; its own individual nature is saraso, its own individual nature as it is (yathābhūto) is yāthāvasaraso which is referred to, such as, “the meaning of oppression”Psi. 118. Ven. Mahasi suggests a full-stop after “pîlanattho "tiâdinâ vutto.
The past, etc. are also the divisions of the truth ofsuffering. As its own individual nature as it is, should be marked, it is said the true individual function and characteristic [of that truth]. It prevents to know it directly.
Both ofthese together (tadubhayaṃ):beginning and future, five aggregates ofthe past and ofthe future.
Or the middle part being the present is the past and future because it has formal part and latter part.
This is ignorance and these are formations (ayaṃ avijjā ime saṅkhārā). explanation of the aspect of knowing directly regarding the dependent origination and the dependently arisen states.
Here (ettha): in this suffering, and so on.
Even though ignorance arises in suffering by way of object also, it is not able to make cessation and path as its object, thus while arising as concealing them to the person desirous to know them and while arising as condition for assuming what are not cessation and path to be cessation and path, it prevents to penetrate as they really are. In this way it should be understood regarding suffering, and so on.
Therefore there is the sentence, “It is only intended as concealment.”
Non-understanding (aññāṇaṃ) is that which makes one blind about the objects of suffering, etc.The reading dukkhadivisaye given in Sinhalese version is better than dukkhâdivisayo given here. It is the cause of attachment, etc., which make one blind, that is, causing not to see.
Merit, and so on (puññādayo): formations of merit, and so on.
It is merit because it cleanses one’s own process against demeritorious effect and against defilement of suffering.
One gets merit through inclination towards the good and happiness, thus it fulfills inclination ofthe doer by producing the good and happiness; or it is merit because it makes the life honorable.
Therefore puñña should be understood as that which fulfills, and that which causes honorable life, according to the etymology.
Formations ofmerit (puññābhisaṅkhāro):it is merit as well as formations in the sense of making its own effect.
Formations of demerit (apuññābhisaṅkhāro): it should be understood in opposite way because demerit is contradiction ofmerit.
Formations ofthe imperturbable (āneñjābhisaṅkhāro): it does not shake as it is far from the enemies of concentration; it prepares unshakable life.
Bodily formation (kāyasaṅkhāro): it is produced by the body; or it arises from the body; or it is formation of die body.
The same method should be applied to the verbal formation and mental formation.
There the first three are known through the Discourse on Examination (Parivīmaṃsanasutta), etc.
For there it is said, “If he prepares an act of merit, consciousness becomes associated with merit.” S.ii.82
The other three are known through the Discourse on Analysis (Vibhahgasutta).
For there it is said, “These are, bhikkhus, three formations.
What are three?
The bodily formation, verbal formation and mental formation."M. i. 54; S. ii. 4; 43; 59; S. iv. 293.
The sentence, beginning with, but in detail (vitthārato pana) is explanation of the formations ofmerit, etc. according to category and division.
[The sentence], ‘occurring through development ofmeditation only (bhāvanāvaseneva pavattā), not through giving and virtue’ shows the object of act of merit available there.
Therefore volitions of the immaterial sphere are also referred to, “occurring through the development of meditation only (bhāvanāvaseneva pavattā)".
Some, however, say that through the word ‘only’ belonging to the word “through development of meditation only”, volition connected with direct knowledge is excluded.
That is not proper, because it is caused by ignorance. Like that, it is desirable to be the formations of merit. Otherwise mind and mental states with direct-knowledge would not be included in the object of the act of merit. It is also not proper to say, “It is profitable, but it is not the object of act of merit.”
Killing living things, and so on (pāṇātipātādi): the word, and so on (ādi) includes not only the rest ofthe course of unprofitable actions, but also it includes the whole ofunprofitable actions.
In the other (itaresu pana): in the bodily formation, and so on.
The formations of merit, etc., when occurring, occur through these doors. Therefore it is said in order to show that they occur in these doors (dvārato pavattidassanatthaṃ).
Why is it said, “the same twenty volitions”? If profitable and unprofitable volitions that produce bodily and verbal intimations are called bodily formation and verbal formation respectively, that being so, volition connected with direct-knowledge, being profitable, producing verbal intimation, also should be called as verbal formation. Thus regarding this question it is said, “volition connected -with direct-knowledge (abhiññācetanā)”, and so on.
Here (ettha): in the case of bodily and verbal formations, or in the case of bodily and verbal volition.
It is not included (na gahitā): it is not mentioned in Aṭṭhakathā with the intention, “Volition connected with direct-knowledge is not the condition of consciousness.”
Why is it not? Is it not that it is profitable and it has the nature of producing effect?
It is true, but in the process rooted in craving and ignorance which are not cut,Ven. Mahasi suggests that instead of the word anupacchinnatanhavijjamane given here, anupacchinnatanhdvijjamule will be better. In VbhAT. 95, however the reading is anupacchinnatanhavijjamane. it is said to be profitable and to have the nature ofproducing effect as it arises with activity, but it is not said that it produces effect.
But when it produces effect, it may produce the effect of the fine-material sphere.
For kamma of one plane does not produce effect of the other plane.
It may produce the effect ofthe three places having same objects with itself.For it is said in Cittuppādakaṇḍa that the effect of the finematerial sphere has the same object of kamma.
But the effect ofthe fine-material sphere does not have the object, such as, limited (paritta).Volition connected with directknowledge has the object, such as, limited.
Therefore it does not produce effect-thus it should be known.
Direct-knowledge is benefit of concentration of the fourth jhāna arising towards kasiṇa objects.
As there is the expression, “in this way when his mind is calmed down”,D. i. 13; 14, etc.
direct-knowledge looks like the effect of concentration; it does not produce the effect.
Like an obtainment of cause which is benefit ofgiving and virtue in this life, it does not produce the effect.
And like direct-knowledge volition, so also volition connected with agitation is not included (yathā ca abhiññācetanā , evaṃ uddhaccacetanāpi na hoti): it should be examined having taken up separately the states associated with agitation, as there is the expression, “Knowledge about result ofthose unprofitable states is the discrimination of meaning.”Vbh. 295.
That has been already examined above in the explanation of the unprofitable states in the description of aggregates, so it should be known through the method as examined only.
And herein some teachers (eke) having analyzed say — even though ordinary men and learners do not have seeing (dassana) and development (bhāvanā),Seeing refers to the first path; development refers to the remaining three paths. they will have them.At the time of arising ofseeing and development in them, those improfitable states which can be eradicated by them are told as ‘What should be abandoned by seeing, what should be abandoned by development (dassanena pahātabbā, bhāvanāya pahātabbā).
But as ordinary men do not have development, they have no consideration of ‘what should be abandoned by development’.
Therefore even ifunprofitable states which arise within them can not be eradicated by seeing, they are not told as states to be eradicated through development.
If it is said so, some ofthe unprofitable states to be eradicated by seeingVen. Mahasi suggests that the word kenaci should be keci in the sentence kescmci kenaci kadâci ârammanâarammanâdhipatiupanissayapaccayehi paccayo bhaveyyum. Thus it is the adjective of dassanenapahâtabbâ which is nominative case. VbhAT. 95 also reads kesanci keci kadâci. sometimes would be the condition of some of the states to be eradicated through development through object condition, object-predominance condition and decisive support condition.
And in Paṭṭhāna, states to be eradicated by seeing are not said as condition of states to be eradicated by development through any condition.
But the unprofitable states existing in the learners can be eradicated through development, thus they are called, ‘to be eradicated through development (bhāvanāya pahātabbā).
Therefore states to be eradicated by sefeing ofthe learners are not to be tasted and delighted because they are to be given up, vomited, renounced, abandoned, foreshaken, thrown up. Being causes of happiness and being causes ofnon-distraction, as unprofitable states are eradicated, they do not produce grief and agitation.
Therefore states to be eradicated by seeing do not reach the state ofobject and object-predominance, and the state of natural decisive support (pakat-upanissaya) for the states to be eradicated through development.
Depending on the eradicated states, the noble person does not produce defilements like attachment, and so on.
For it is said, “One does not come again, return back, come back to those defilements eradicated by the path of stream-entry.”Nd1.202.
And it is possible to say that mental defilements within the ordinary men, which can be eradicated by seeing, do not become the condition of others through any condition.
For wrong-view and doubt are said to be the object condition of agitation in the expression, such as, “One tastes, takes delight in wrong-view, owing to that there arise greed, wrong-view, doubt, and agitation. Owing to doubt, there arise doubt, wrong-view and agitation.”Ptn. 309.
Because wrong-view and doubt are said to be object condition for agitation. Here the word agitation is said with reference to mind associated with agitation.
Therefore in the explanation of predominance condition, it is said only this much, “Honoring wrong-view, one tastes, delight, honoring it, greed arises, wrong-view arises”,Ptn. 90. and it is not said that, “Agitation arises.”
Therefore even ifit is not said that mental defilements eradicated by seeing and development according to the past, etc., among those defilements that are to be kept in the nature of non-arising through seeing and development, defilements arising within the ordinary men, which can be eradicated by seeing, referring to the future seeing, are called ‘to be eradicated by seeing’. Those defilements arising in the learners, which can be eradicated through development referring to the future development are called ‘to be eradicated through development’.
Out of these two, defilements to be eradicated through development, being bereft of companion, do not produce an effect, therefore volition to be eradicated through development is not said as kamma-condition acting from a different time (nānākkhaṇikakammapaccaya). However, it is not possible to reject producing an effect of lustful desire, etc., for one’s own property, which are devoid of seeing and development which should be referred to, which arise within the ordinary men; and to reject producing an effect of mind associated with agitation, which arises within ordinary men, companion of which is not yet ceased owing to non-cutting of three fetters and defilements existing together with them. Thus the result of the states associated with agitation is told in Vibhaṅga.
If it is so, unprofitable states which are devoid of seeing and development which should be referred to, would be ‘to be eradicated neither by seeing nor through development (nevadassanenanabhāvanāyapahātabbā).Ven. Mahasi suggests that the word navattabbatâ after nevadassanenanabhâvanâya-pahâtabbatâya should be vattabbatâ.
In this way if someone argues, it will not be so, because there is the expression, “States not to be eradicated are said as nevadassanenana-bhāvanāya pahātabbā."Ptn. 17.Unprofitable states have the nature of opposite to the states not to be eradicated.
If some one argues that even then in this triad those unprofitable states would be said as “not-so-classifiable (navattabbā)”, they will not be so.
Because twelve unprofitable consciousnesses mentioned in Cittuppâādakaṇḍa are included by two words.Dassanenapahâtabbâ and bhâvanâyapahâtabbâ.
As all formed-states are included according to the nature, in triad of uppanna (states that have arisen) even though the states ofthe past are not included, they are not said to be “notso-classifiable”.Because there is no ‘not-so-classifiable’ in the states obtained as mind and matter. Similarly here also [among unprofitable states] mentioned in arising ofmind, it should be understood that navattabbatâ is not referred to because there is no navattabbā.
In the place where some mind and mental properties are definitely not told, in that place they have the fourth portion. Therefore like other triads, in that place also having classified the mind and mental properties which should be put together, the Blessed One caused them to be included through the expressions, such as, “siyā navattabbā parittārammaṇā”.Dhs. 239.
As there is not the fourth portion in the triad of ‘states that have arisen’, here also they are not said like that.
Or optionally three primary mattersEarth-, fire-, and air-element. in the fine-material sphere are said to be the matters that are with impingement (sappatighā), as they have the same nature ofmatters that are with impingement.
As it is said, “In beings having no perception, depending on one primary matter that is with impingement, except the visible object, there are two primary matters; depending on two primary matters, there is one primary matter”, in this way the states arising within the ordinary men, having the same nature of the states to be eradicated through development are to be said as the states to be eradicated through development.Ven. Mahasi suggests that the interrogation mark is not needed here.
Therefore there is no contingency of ‘not-so-classifiable’
If it is so, lustful desire, etc. for one’s own property, arising even within the ordinary men, which are to be eradicated through development, are the decisive-support condition of lustful desire, etc. in other’s property.
Greed is predominance condition for greed and wrongview - this meaning is obtained. But three primary matters, being not tangible in the fine-material sphere are not said to be the matters that are with impingement in the ultimate sense.Likewise lustful desire, etc., in one’s own property, arising within the ordinary men, which are devoid of development which is to be referred to, are not the states that are to be eradicated through development in ultimate sense.Therefore the states that are to be eradicated through development are not said as kamma-condition acting from a different time.
And it is not said that the states that are to be eradicated by seeing are the condition of the states that are to be eradicated through development through any condition.
For those defilements, the cause ofwhich is the states that are to be eradicated by seeing, never arise after arising of the path of stream-entry. The consciousness associated with agitation is made away from mere companion through the path of stream-entry, even though it has the cause of dassanena pahātabbā (to be eradicated by the path ofstream-entry).
Any nature ofthe consciousness associated with agitation is not made as non-arising through the path of stream-entry. Thus consciousness associated with agitation is definitely said as bhāvanāya pahātabbā.
Therefore the statement that consciousness associated with agitation arising within them produces an effect when there is companion, and the statement that it does not produce the effect when there is no companion, are not contradictory.
Others said that all that is mere pageantry.
Why?
Because the consciousness associated with agitation is definitely the state to be eradicated through development.
For it is told by the Blessed One, “Which are the states that are to be eradicated through development?
Consciousness associated with agitation.”Dhs. 237.
For if the meaning [of eke] is necessary here, it would have been told, “Consciousness associated with agitation may be eradicated through development, it may be not-so-classifiable (uddhaccasahagato siyā bhāvanāya pahātabbo, siyā na vattabbo) after having told,“Definitely there are no states that are to be eradicated through development”, just as it is told after having classified, “Definitely there are no states that have the future as their object”Dhs. 241. in the triad of the states that have the past as their object.
The application given through the word, such as, “ifit were said (yadi vucceyyuṃ)” in order to prove the word, is not logical.
Why?
The states, such as, greed, wrong-view, doubt, and agitation, the object ofwhich is to be eradicated by seeing are desired to be eradicated by seeing only.
But in Pāḷi through the word agitation, the consciousness associated with agitation is referred to. Having said thus, in order to prove it in the explanation of predominance condition, observation was made that agitation is not mentioned.That observation is also not proper because in Paṭṭhāna we find passage of the text left out.
For in Vibhaṅga knowledge of penetration of minds is obtained as follows: “The state that is the past is the condition of the state that is present, the state that is the future is the condition ofthe state that is present, through the object condition.”In Vibhaṅga ofthis word, “The state that is the present is the condition ofthe state that is the present”, even though [knowledge of penetration of minds] is obtained, but it is not mentioned.
Referring to producing an effect ofthe state to be eradicated through development, the state to be eradicated by seeing should be examined to become a companion.
Is the state to be eradicated by seeing a companion of the state to be eradicated through development like ignorance, etc. are the companions of giving, virtue, etc., by making them capable to produce an effect at the time of their arising only, or like defilements are companions of kamma in producing an effect of rebirth-linking?
Here something else should be told - if the former case, the state of which dassanappahātabba is abandoned, would be known as indeterminate state of bhāvanāpahātabba arising within a learnerjust like giving, etc., arising within [Arahatship] in whose continuity ignorance, craving and conceit are abandoned.
If the latter case, even the state to be eradicated through development would be known as the state to be eradicated by seeing because the individual nature of that leading to the state of loss can not transcend. Therefore according to the way examined before only, with regard to producing an effect of consciousness associated with agitation exposition of the meaning should be known through non-contradiction of Pāḷi and Atthakathā.
That also (sāpi) :volition of agitation.
As a condition for consciousness (viññāṇassa paccayabhāve): as a condition offoil resultant consciousness.The word sampunnassa means both the resultant consciousnesses, that is, pavatti and patisandhi.
If it should be excluded, why is it said, “the same twenty volitions”? In order to show the reason, it is said, “However all these have ignorance as their condition (avijjāpaccayā pana sabbāpetā honti)”
The teacher points out that volition connected with direct-knowledge also has the state of condition.
If it is so, it is to be said as twenty-one together with volition connected with direct-knowledge. It is not so, because of aforesaid reason for not saying so.
That is also the reason for not the other case, that is, volition connected with agitation,Therefore while not saying volition connected with direct-knowledge having the same nature, volition connected with agitation also is not said by the same reason referring to which volition connected with direct-knowledge is not said.
This triad (ayaṃ tiko): triad of bodily formation.
The former triad (purimattikaṃ): the triad of formations of merit.
It is included (pavisati): in which way is it included?
For, formation of merit divided according to the eight volitions of sense-sphere, sometimes becomes bodily formation for one. abstaining from bodily misconduct, and sometimes becomes verbal formation for one abstaining from verbal misconduct.
Thirteen volitions arising at the mind-door, however, become formation of merit and mental formation. The formation of demerit also when arising through bodily misconduct, sometimes becomes bodily formation, when arising through verbal misconduct, sometimes becomes verbal formation, and when arising at the mind-door leaving two doors, becomes mental formation. And formation ofthe imperturbable becomes like that. Thus the latter triad is included in the formal triad only.
Therefore it is said, “So far as the meaning is concerned, ignorance can be understood as condition simplyforformations of merit, and so on (atthato puññābhisaṅkhārādīnaṃyeva vasena avijjāya paccayabhāvo veditabbo).”
Because they exist when ignorance exists (avijjābhāve bhāvato). because formations exist when ignorance exists.
When ignorance does not exist, formations never arise.
Now while showing the existence of ignorance it is said, “when non-understanding is not abandoned (aññāṇaṃ appahīnaṃ hoti)”.
Therefore the teacher shows that non-cessation through the path is here the existence of ignorance, not its presence only.
This meaning has been elaborated before only.
“That called as ignorance (avijjāsaṅkhātaṃ): this word excludes the absence of knowledge, and so on.
For this letter ‘a’ in the expressions, such as, “causeless states, a dwelling where there is no bhikkhu”, etc., is known in the sense of rejecting its association.
For here absence is described.
The letter ‘a’ in “states not produced from condition” is known in the sense ofrejecting its relation.
For that produced from condition is related with condition, but it is not produced from condition, its non-relation is here pointed out.Ven. Mahasi suggests that in the reading appaccayuppannattáti, 'ti' should be removed, and tamsambandhitâ should be atamsambandhitâ. In DhsAT. 28 the reading is also appaccayuppannattâ atamsambandhitâ.
The letter ‘a’ in “states that are non-visible” is known in the sense ofrejecting that nature.
For the state to be seen is ‘visible (nidassana).
Ifthe eye-consciousness is visible, it is in the sense of rejecting the object obtained by the eye-consciousness.Ven. Mahasi suggests that the reading 'na passatiti' is to be removed in this context. In DhsAnuT. 28 also that word is not appeared.
Similarly the letter ‘a’ in “states free from cankers” also is known in this sense.
The letter ‘a’ in “states which are non-impinging, states not aware of object” is known in the sense of rejecting the function ofimpinging and object.
That in “immaterial states, states which are not mental concomitants” is known in the sense of rejecting the state of materiality and mental concomitants.
For here otherness is mentioned.
That in “non-human” is in the sense of rejecting the mere state ofhuman being.
There is no mere nature ofhuman being, others are the same. Thus similarity is here indicated.
That in “He is not a recluse, though a recluse in vowsS. iv. 180; A. i. 108; 126; ii. 239; iv. 128; 201; 205; Ud. 52; Ndl. 231; Pg. 27; 36., one who has not got the son” is known in the sense of rejecting admired virtue.
For blame is here known.
That in “one with little disease,Jâ. 532, 542, 569.a girl with little belly” is known in the sense ofrejecting abundance. That in “states which are not arisen” is known in the sense ofrejecting similarity with ‘arisen’.
For the states that are the past are proper for ‘arisen (uppannā) because they appeared before.
The states that will definitely arise are proper for ‘arisen’ because some start to arise by producing some parts of conditions. The state free from the periods is proper for arisen because it ever exists, needless to say ofthe states that are present. Thus the state being far from that is here described.
That in “asekkhā dhammā"Dhs.2 is known in the sense ofrejecting non-completion. For completion is here described.
For completion is here described.
But because these meanings are not suitable, consequently it should be known that the unprofitable is the state opposite to the profitable, in this way ignorance is opposite to knowledge, therefore nonunderstanding is the state opposite to knowing.
Assuming it to be pleasant (sukhasaññāya gahetvā). perceiving suffering ofthe round of rebirths that should be known to be suffering by the wise men as intrinsic suffering, suffering in change, suffering due to formations, to be pleasant.By this word, the teacher shows arising of craving in that suffering ofthe round of rebirths.
He embarks upon (ārabhati): he causes to arise.
The equipment of craving (taṇhāparikkhāre): formed, prepared, adorned by craving as pleasant, auspicious, and so on.
The fool not knowing that craving is the cause of suffering, prepares bodily formations desiring for them, such as, “Oh, on the dissolution ofthe body, after death, I might reappear in the company of well-to-do nobles!”M.i.289.
Or the equipment ofcraving (taṇhāparikkhāre): the surrounding of craving.
For formations, after having prepared the eye and visible data, etc., which are the bases of craving, giving them to those possessing craving, supporting craving, are like their surroundings.
In some particular destiny (gativisese): in Brahmā world, and so on.
Sacrifice (yañño): like vājapeyya, etc. which are dreadful because of many hundreds of cattle tied upon there.
Mortification for immortality (amaratapo): austerity taken with the idea that it will lead to immortality.
Or thinking that gods are immortal, so may I be a supreme god or an ordinary god, thus one is engaged in ritual practice.Ven. Mahasi suggests that instead ofthe reading 'amaro va', 'amaradevati' will be better.
Or mortification which causes death owing to suffering is amaratapo,
like the word ‘unseen’ is to be known in the sense of ‘seen’, and the word ‘immortality’ should be known in the sense of death.
The formation of merit is said as similar to falling upon the cliff as it produces suffering that causes falling into the birth, and so on.
“It produces great distress (mahāpariḷāhajanikaṃ)”: by this word the teacher shows similarity ofthe fruit ofmerit with a torch made of dry grass in the sense of burning.
The word ‘ca’ in little satisfaction (appassādatañca) includes piercing it on a chopping board, breaking up all limbs, and so on.
Its condition (tappaccayaṃ): condition of the fruit of happy destiny, the nature of which is suffering in change.
The fruit of merit assumed as delightful and enjoyment is similar to lamp’s flame and honey-smeared knife-edge. And the formation of merit in the sense of fruit of merit is said as similar to falling into that flame and licking it.
One embarks upon the formation of demerit which leads to disgust and suffering at the moment ofpresent action as well as at the moment offruit in future.
Just as a child would play with filth, thinking that it is an enjoyment ofsome sense-pleasure without noticing it as inauspicious by imagining it to be pleasant, such as, “Pleasant is the touch ofthis woman wanderer’s tender soft downy arm!”,M. i. 305.and a man - who wants to die, having no mastery over one’s own life, being overpowered by anger and weariness because he is overpowered by defilements, - would eat poison.
Or the state associated with attachment is similar to playing with filth; the state associated with hatred is similar with eating poison.
Results in the immaterial sphere, in which arising and falling are not distinguished owing to non-interruption, changes of which are not being grasped owing to long continuity, and which are suffering due to formations and the suffering-in-change, are the cause of perversion of wrongly perceiving them as eternal, etc., like a goblin city which is dangerous, is the cause ofperversion ofwrongly perceiving it as pleasant owing to accomplishment of sense-desire. Therefore similarity of goblin city is to be applied to the results in the immaterial sphere and the similarity of going towards it is to be applied to the formations of imperturbable.
Formations exist only when ignorance exists, they do not exist in the absence of ignorance. Thus when formations have ignorance as their condition, in order to prove aforesaid meaning with sutta through positive and negative assertion briefly, there is the quotation of sutta, beginning with, “Moreover this is told (vuttampi cetaṃ).''
There an ignorant man means the unintelligent.
Possessed of ignorance (avijjāgato): a person endowed with ignorance, one whose ignorance is not abandoned - this is the implication.