Commentary on detailed explanation of the clause ‘With feeling as condition, craving’
Here (idha): in this world or in this teaching six kinds of craving are described.
Or here (idha): in the clause ‘with feeling as condition, craving’.
There (tattha): in those six kinds of craving.
Mode of occurrence in the visible-data, etc., of craving accompanied by each eternity view and annihilation view is agreeable to rejoicing those [sassaia and uccheda]. As it has special mode from occurrence with mere sense-desire enjoyment, craving is threefold according to mode of occurrence referred to.
Out of selfish affection (mamattena): with great fondness, with craving of enjoyment, thus it is told.
There feeling should be seen like a son; visible-data, etc. - which are cause of feeling, — like milk, etc.; and six [kinds of people], - beginning with, painters, etc., who furnish respectively sixfold object, such as, visible-data, etc. - like a nurse who gives milk, etc.
There a weaver is one who provides cloth of pleasant contact, and a physician should be seen as a provider of mental-data object, as nutritive essence of elixir and as life faculty supported by elixir.
And these all (sabbapesā): classification of one hundred and eight kinds of craving also.
Object condition is mere object of craving that is arising. It does not produce as decisive-support condition does. Thus it is said, “in one way (ekadhāva)”, only in the way of decisive-support that produces.
Or by ‘decisive-support’, object-decisive- support condition is included.
And by that [object-decisive-support condition], another object condition which is similar to the nature of object condition is also described. Therefore it should be understood that the state of condition is told in the way of decisive-support condition.
Through the sentence, beginning with, “or because (yasmā vā)” the teacher shows that not only resultant pleasant feeling, but also three resultant feelings are specially a decisive-support condition for craving, and commonly the other feelings also are [a decisive-support condition for craving].
The peace of equanimity is counted pleasure too, thus by one who announced (Upekkhā pana santattā , sukhamicceva bhāsita). therefore that also is a decisive-support condition for craving as longing for more.
But equanimity that is unprofitable resultant should be included in suffering, because it is undesirable; the other is included in pleasure, because it is desirable. Therefore it can be said that equanimity is a decisive-support condition, like suffering and like pleasure.
By the clause “with feeling as condition, craving” if there is a contingency of arising of taṇhā through the presence of condition of everybody who has feeling,Because even the Blessed One has feeling which is the cause of craving, but feeling in him does not cause craving because feeling in him is not assisted by inherent-tendency. in order to prevent it, there is the sentence, beginning with, “‘though feeling is condition (vedanāpaccayā cāpi)”.For the discussion of Ven. Naanamoli’s translation, see (5) of‘Minor problems ...’ in chapter 1 of this thesis.
If someone asks that due to absence of expression “Feeling assisted by inherent tendency is a condition for feeling” it is not possible to prevent over-generalization, it is not so.
For we are dealing with an exposition of the round of rebirths.
Since there is no round of rebirths without inherent tendencies, feeling accompanied by inherent tendency is the condition - this meaning is implicitly pointed out.
Or optionally it is known that only feeling accompanied by inherent tendency is the condition because it follows the expression “with ignorance as condition”.
And due to the words “With feeling as condition, craving” the decision needed is this, “There is craving only with feeling as condition”, and not “With feeling as condition there is only craving.” Therefore there is definitely no over-generalization here.
Of one who practiced (vusīmato): of one who has lived, of one who has practiced the religious life - this is the meaning.
Or path is called perfection because it fulfills. One who has practiced has perfection, thus he is called vusīmā.
Vusīmā is Arahant referring to supreme superiority. Or the highest fruit is vusī because it perfects, one who has got it is vusīmā.