Issues
Select Version
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā

The Explanation of the Enumeration in Full

Author: PTS @ IAPT

The Explanation of the Enumeration in Full

Consciousness of stream-entry path associated with the five factors of application of thought, etc., of the first jhāna is first jhāna stream-entry consciousness, etc.; alternatively, being similar to the first jhāna in the factors of jhāna, it is what is both first jhāna and consciousness of stream-entry path.
Indeed the four paths are also similar to the various jhānas by virtue of one among foundation jhāna, observation jhāna, and personal aspiration; so with the appearance of the factors of application of thought, etc., each gets designated 'first jhāna', etc., and divides into five.
Therefore, he has said by division according to association with jhāna factors, and so on [Chapter 1, §41]. Therein when insight leading to emergence [of the transcendent path] occurs to one who attains and emerges from whichever jhāna, from the first jhāna [to the fifth], and observes formations, that [jhāna] is the foundation jhāna as it is the basis for insight leading to emergence. Insight leading to emergence (vuṭṭhāna-gāminī vipassanā) is discussed at Vism 661-66 (Chapter XXI, §§83-110); see also Chapter IX, §56 of Abhidh-s and commentary.
When it occurs to one observing whatever jhāna, that [jhāna] is the observed jhāna.
When the meditator has the aspiration that he should gain the path with five factors similar to the first jhāna, or the path with four factors, and so on, similar to any one of the jhānas from the second jhāna [to the fifth], that is called personal aspiration.
Herein for one who produces the path by attaining one of the five jhānas. emerging from it and observing various formations, the path is similar to whichever of the five jhānas is this foundation jhāna.
If, however, there is no particular jhāna for the foundation of insight and one produces the path just by observing one of the five jhānas, the path is similar to the observed jhāna.
When, however, one produces the path by attaining one of the five jhānas, emerging from it, and observing another [jhāna], then it is similar to one of these two according to one's personal aspiration.
But if a person has no such aspiration and, having emerged from some lower jhāna, he has observed the dhammas of some higher jhāna, the path he produces is similar to the observed jhāna, paying no attention to the foundation jhāna.
But having emerged from some higher jhāna and having observed the dhammas of some lower jhāna, the path he produces is similar to the foundation jhāna, paying no attention to the observed jhāna --
for higher jhānas are stronger than lower jhānas.
Feeling in all cases is fixed by the insight leading to emergence.
Thus the one who practises bare insight must have all the factors of jhāna,
for, since he he lacks the foundation jhānas, etc., there is no fixing [of the factors] on their account and the path can only be fivefold in accordance with the insight.The point being, presumably, that the meditator who has not learned to control pleasant feeling by attaining the third and fourth jhānas prior to the emergence of the path will inevitably practise insight with the two sense-sphere consciousnesses accompanied by pleasant feeling and connected with knowledge.
Even in the case of one who has attained jhāna, but does not make jhāna the foundation, but observes various formations, the path produced must also be fivefold in accordance with the insight. This is the essence drawn from the commentaries, etc.
However, the elaboration of the authoritative view of the Theravāda, etc., should be understood according to the system stated in the commentaries, etc.
In afct, as in this case, so the full system of everything should be taken as stated in the various [books].
Here a summary discussion is set out in order to help those who are frightened of books.
As consciousness belonging to the form sphere is taken in accordance with the division into fivefold jhāna, beginning with the first, and spoken of as first jhāna, and so on, so the unsurpassed consciousness is also taken as strem-entry path-consciousness of the first jhāna, and so on.
So the formless also, because of its similarity in jhāna factors by its association being with equanimity and one-pointedness, is included in the fifth jhāna; it gets the designation 'fifth jhāna' is what is meant.
Alternatively, the construction is: just as consciousness belonging to the form sphere and the unsurpassed are included in the division into first jhāna etc., with the expressions 'wholesome consciousness of the first jhāna' and 'stream-entry path-consciousness of the first jhāna', and so on, so too is the formless included in the fifth jhāna.
That this is indeed the construction intended by the Ācariya [i.e. Anuruddha] is shown by the fact that it is explicitly stated in the Nāmarūpapariccheda;
for it is stated there:Nāmar-p 24
The consciousness belonging to the form sphere and the unsurpassed [consciousnesses] ...
... are included in the dicvision into first jhāna, etc., and the formless [is included] in the fifth.
Therefore: since, like form-sphere [consciousness], the unsurpassed too is taken in accordance with the division into first jhāna, etc., and the formless is included in the fifth -- or, since, by making each fivefold by division according to the jhāna factors, unsurpassed consciousness is said to be of forty kinds, and just as form-sphere consciousness and unsurpassed consciousness are included in the division of first jhāna, etc., so the formless is included in the fifth -- therefore each ordinary jhāna, beginning with the first, is threefold and [each] Transcendent [jhāna] is eightfold [making each one] elevenfold;
but the last jhāna is twenty-threefold: 'three form-sphere, twelve formless-sphere and eight transcendent [jhānas]' is what is meant.
The increase in number by way of foundation jhāna, and so on, affects only the [numbers of] wholesome and resultant [types of consciousness]; indicating the number of just these types in the enumeration of one hundred and twenty-one [consciousnesses], he stated the words beginning thirty-seven.
[Here ends the explanation of the chapter on consciousness in the explanation of the Summary of the Topics of Abhidhamma called Exposition of the Topics of Abhidhamma.]