Issues
Select Version
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā

3. Pakiṇṇakaparicchedavaṇṇanā

Author: PTS @ IAPT

The Explanation of the Summary of Objects

The summary by way of distinguishing the essential objects [of the mind], and by way of the consciousness which can take those objects is the summary of objects.
Form (rūpa) is what exhibits (rūpayati) modifications in colour, it displays this condition to the mind; because consciousness and mentalities lean (ālambīyati) on that, like a weak man on a stick, or because they come (āgantvā) and enjoy (ramanti) themselves there, this becomes an object (ālambana/ārammaṇa); such is a visible-form object.
Sound is what is sounded, what is spoken; that itself as an object is a sound object.
Smell is what gives out a smell (gandhīyati), it points out its own nature like one who spreads [the muck of] gossip saying, 'There is this [here];A play on gandha, smell, and gandhana, 'pointing out or alluding to the faults of others', q. vv. MW. that itself as an object is a smelll object.
Taste is what beings taste, what they savour; that itself as an object is a taste object.
What is touched is tangible; that itself as an object is a tangible object.
A dhamma as an object is a mind object.

Therein: of visible, etc., objects.

Visible form itself: visible form itself reckoned as the sphere of colours.

Sound, etc.: sound, etc., reckoned as the sphere of sounds, etc. However, the sphere of tangible things is reckoned as the three elements excluding the water element.
Leaving aside the five kinds of sense-object and the sense organs, the remaining types of materiality are the sixteen subtle kinds.
Present: actually occurring.
All six: all six, beginning with visible form, etc.
Because nibbāna and concepts do not perish, they cannot occur by way of past, etc., time, and so are called free of time.
As appropriate: according to whether [the consciousnesses] are sense-sphere impulsions, or the impulsions of the higher knowledges and other higher consciousnesses, and so forth.
For the objects of the sense-sphere impulsions, other than that which produces smiles, are sixfold, belonging to the three times and free of time;
the object of that which produces smiles belong only to the three times,
thus one must declare that its object is exclusively a limited object.
The objects of the higher-knowledge impulsions, which occur by way of the divine eye, etc., are sixfold, belonging to the three times and free of time as appropriate.
But the details of this will be made clear in Chapter Nine.See below, Chapter IX, §41.
The objects of the remaining [consciousness] are past or free of time as appropriate.
The construction is: 'The objects of the door-free reckoned as ... are of all six kinds.' However, the objects of these [consciousnesses] do not, like that of adverting, come into range unapprehended by any [previous consciousness]; nor are they like those of the impulsions belonging to the five sense-doors which are exclusively present; nor are they like the impulsions belonging to the mind-door which belong only to the three times orReading with Ce 1898, Se 1922, Be CSCD, kālavimuttaṃ vā. are uniformly free of time; and, because of their proximity to death, they are unlike [the objects] of earlier impulsions, which lack any designation, such as 'kamma' or 'sign of kamma', relating to the manner in which their occurrence is brought about - with reference to all this, he says, they have usually been apprehended in the preceding existence according to circumstances ... and are designated 'kamma' (yathāsambhavaṃ ... pe ... sammataṃ).
Therein, according to circumstances means according to its production [as an object] of relinking, existence-continuum and decease belonging to this and that level [of existence] by way of being apprehended through this and that door, and so forth.
For, in the first place, the five types of sense-object, beginning with visible form, apprehended through any of the six doors, as present or past as appropriate, as an object of sense-sphere relinking and existence-continuum are known as 'sign of kamma'; likewise the object of the decease consciousness, which is past only.

But a mind-object, which is apprehended only through the mind-door as past, is known as 'kamma' or 'sign of kamma'; a visible object, similarly apprehended only through the mind-door as exclusively present, is known as 'sign of destiny'.

In this way the objects of sense-sphere relinking, etc., apprehended according to circumstances as past or present through the six doors are known as 'kamma', 'sign of kamma' and 'sign of destiny'.

But in the case of relinking, etc., with the higher [consciousnesses] the exclusively mind-object of the form sphere and the first and third formless attainments which is apprehended through the mind-door as a concept is known as 'sign of kamma'; likewise [the objects] of the second and fourth formless attainments, although they are only in the past. In this way the objects of higher relinking, existence-continuum and decease apprehended through the mind-door as concepts or past [consciousness and mentalities] are known as 'sign of kamma'.
Have usually been apprehended in the preceding existence ... through the six doors: in most cases apprehended by impulsions belonging to the six doors that occurred close to death in the immediately preceding existence.
But those [beings] who have fallen from [the realm of] unconscious existence have not apprehended an object of relinking through any door in the immediately preceding existence -- just this is the exception assumed by 'usually' here.
For it is by the force of kamma alone that the object presents itself as a sign of kamma, etc.,Reading with Ce 1898, Se 1922, Be CSCD, kammanimittādikam ārammaṇaṃ for the relinking of such beings.
Indeed the question of the sign of relinking for one who has fallen from unconscious existence is raised in the Saccasaṃkhepa, which states:
A kamma done in a previous existence can take the opportunity [to bear fruit];
relinking takes place with regard to the objective field presented by just that [kamma].Sacc 171.
[We have] stated that the objective field of the relinking is presented by the force of kamma alone,
for otherwise, since the objects apprehended by impulsions [generally] are presented precisely by the force of kamma, the restrictive sense of the words 'by just that' [in the quoted verse] would be lost.
But is it not the case that the objective field for relinking of those [beings who have fallen from unconscious existence] also arises as something apprehended by impulsions through any door in [the course of] becoming as kamma?
That is true [of the kinds of object] known as kamma and sign of kamma, but that which is known as sign of destiny presents itself to all [beings] only at the time of death, so how could apprehending of this arise in [the course of] becoming as kamma?

Besides, 'apprehended through the six doors' is said in the present context only in reference to what is apprehended by impulsions that occur close to death.Ee adds 'not with reference to what is apprehended by impulsions in sense [sic] existence' (na kāmabhave javanagahitaṃ).

And in consideration of this, on this very point the Ācariya [Anuruddha] says in the Paramatthavinicchaya:

Whatever the objective field presented at the six doors to the being close to death, depending on that, relinking occurs in the next existence.Pm-vn 89.
By the word present, etc., he excludes a future object's being the objective field for relinking.
For a future object is not something experienced like a past kamma and sign of kamma, nor is it something that has come into the range [of consciousness], like a present sign of kamma and sign of destiny; so one should state only the natural state itself of kamma and sign of kamma.
Of these: of those consciousnesses whose objects are visible form, etc., present, etc., and kamma, etc.
Each have just their respective object, beginning with visible form means that their respective objects are one of visible form, etc.
Have the five objects beginning with visible form means that their object is of the five kinds beginning with visible form.
The remaining: the remaining eleven sense-sphere resultants other than the twice-five consciousnesses and the types of receiving.
Have in every way the objects of the sense sphere: they occur in all ways in activity by way of the six kinds of object that belong to the six doors and are free of doors, and they have exclusively those six kinds of object that by nature belong to the sense sphere as their objective fields.
For, taking the resultants first here, they are active by way of investigating with the five objects beginning with visible form, etc., and by way of relinking, etc., with sense-sphere objects, namely the six kinds of object.
The smiling consciousness occurs with the six kinds of object, but only as included in [the class of] limited objects, as follows: with a visible object when one is happy at seeing a place suitable for striving; with a sound as object when, hearing a lot of noise in the place where goods are being distributed, one is happy, reflecting that one has got rid of such persistent craving; with a smell as object when one is happy with the smells of incense, etc., at the time of worshipping a shrine (cetiya); with a taste as object when, at the time of eating, one is happy sharing tasty alms food with one's fellow spiritual practitioners; with a tangible sensation as object when one is happy at the time of fulfilling the minor duties of discipline; with a dhamma as object when one is happy in response to a sense-sphere dhamma apprehended by the knowledge of previous lives, etc.
The twelve unwholesome impulsions and the eight wholesome impulsions dissociated from knowledge - these twenty consciousnesses being intrinsically dull cannot occur with reference to transcendent dhammas [as objects], so, excluding the nine transcendent dhammas, they occur with reference to [objects] of three levels and concepts, thus he states the words beginning, The unwholesome.
Of these [twenty], in the case of the unwholesome, the four arisings of consciousness associated with fixed view, at the time of clinging to, enjoying, and taking pleasure in limited objects, have sense-sphere objects; when they occur in a similar manner with reference to the twenty-seven higher dhammas, they have higher objects; when they occur with reference to conventional dhammas, they have concepts as their object.
The arisings of consciousness dissociated from fixed view, when they occur with reference to these same dhammas by way of simply enjoying and taking pleasure in them, the [arising of consciousness] associated with aversion, when it occurs by way of hostility and regret, that accompanied by doubt, when it occurs by way of not being able to make a decision, and that accompanied by restlessness, when it occurs by way of distraction and not being calm -- these arising of consciousness have limited, higher, and conceptual objects. The eight arisings of consciousness dissociated with knowledge - the four wholesome and the four kiriya - when, [in the mental continua] of trainees, ordinary persons, and those who have destroyed the taints, they occur in connection with limited dhammas (such as when reflecting on generosity or listening to the dhamma without full attention), they have sense-sphere objects; when they occur at the time of reflecting on a familiar jhāna, they have higher objects; when they occur at the time of preparatory work [for jhāna] with the kasiṇa signs, etc., they have concepts as objects. This is how it should be understood.
They have all types of object except the path and fruit of arahatship because of their occurring in the [consciousness] flows of trainees and ordinary persons.
For, excepting the ordinary consciousness of the arahat, trainees are unable to have knowledge of the consciousness called path and fruit belonging to a higher person, as they have not attained this. Likewise, ordinary persons [are unable to have knowledge of the path and fruit] of the stream-enterers, etc. But for trainees when reviewing their own respective path and fruit, and at the time of the preparatory work for a higher knowledge that has as its object the path and fruit of another's [consciousness] flow, and again at the time of determining the path and fruit by the actual higher-knowledge consciousness, there occur the wholesome impulsions with reference to dhammas of the paths and fruits equivalent to their own or lower. It is in consideration of this that the path and fruit of arahatship are left out.
But sense-sphere objects, higher objects, concepts and nibbāna become the objective field of the wholesome impulsions of ordinary persons and trainees at the time of the preparatory work and at the time of the purification of change of lineage for higher knowledges with various objects, such as [arise] when reflecting on generosity or listening to the dhamma with full attention, when observing formations, or when carrying out the preparatory work of kasiṇa [meditation], and also at the time of discriminating visible forms by means of the divine eye, etc.
They have all types of object in every way: they have all types of object in every way as sense-sphere objects, higher objects, all the transcendent objects, and concepts. The meaning is that they do not have all objects in the restricted that the unwholesome [consciousness] do.
For nothing at all is considered beyond the range of the kiriya impulsions when they occur by way of omniscient knowledge, etc., and of determining when it occurs as the precursor to various consciousnesses.
Of the formless consciousnesses, the second and fourth have higher objects because of their having the first and third formless [attainments] as their [respective] objects.
The remaining ... have concepts as objects: the fifteen form-sphere and the first and third formless [consciousnesses], making twenty-one, because of their occurring with the concepts of the kasiṇas, etc., have concepts as object.
Twenty-five consciousnesses -- twenty-three sense-sphere resultants, the five-door adverting, and the smiling [consciousnesses] -- have only limited sense-sphere objects;
the sense-sphere is limited in that, because of its feeble power, its nature seems in every respect deficient compared with the higher, etc.
In all cases here the intended meanign should be understood in terms of exact delimitation: six consciousnesses have only higher [objects].
End of the explanation of the summary of objects.