Issues
Select Version
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā

Paṭṭhānanayavaṇṇanā

Author: PTS @ IAPT

Having in this way indicated by way of analysis the method of dependent arising, he now, in order to indicate the method of the Paṭṭhāna, states the words beginning motivation causal condition.
Therein a motivation (hetu) is that by means of which something stands (hinoti), stands firm (patiṭṭhāti).
Since verbal roots can have several meanings, it should be understood that here the word hi has the sense of standing firm.
Alternatively a motivation is that which consists in the laying down of kamma and by which something moves (hinoti); as when a tree takes up nourishment through its roots, with this as a causal condition the fruit arrives, occurs, and grows big and strong.
Motivation Causal Condition is that which is both motivation and a causal condition;
in becoming a motivation it is a causal condition; it is a causal condition by being a motivation is what is said.
As a motivation in the sense of root and a causal condition in the sense of a helper, the causal condition of motivation is in short a dhamma that is a helper in the sense of a root.
It should be understood as the six dhammas of greed, etc., which are the helpers in the sense of a root which is reckoned as accomplishing the well founded state of materialities -- those produced by consciousness in the case of [mental] activity, and by kamma in the case of relinking -- and of mental dhammas -- in both cases -- like the roots of tree.
The object is what is lent on, like a walking stick, etc., by a weak person; what is apprehended by consciousness and mentalities.
For those dhammas with reference to which consciousness and mentalities occur are called the object causal condition of the latter.
Indeed, no dhamma exists that cannot become an object causal condition of consciousness and mentalities.
Dominance causal condition is a causal condition that has become the lord of those [dhammas] that occur subject to it.
Contiguity causal condition is a causal condition where no gap occurs between the causal condition and what is produced by it.
Immediate-contiguity causal condition is a causal condition of extreme contiguity since there is no sharing of position.See Vism 535 (Chapter XVII, §76) and Vism-mhṭ (Be) II 273.
A dhamma that has ceased immediately prior and is capable of generating the appropriate consciousness after itself is called a contiguity causal condition and an immediate-contiguity causal condition.
For the difference between them is merely one of words;
from the point of view of meaning, both are terms for what has ceased in immediate contiguity.
Certainly no difference in meaning obtains,
but what is argued by some -- namely, that the causal condition of contiguity refers to the state of contiguity of purpose (attha) and the causal condition of immediate contiguity to the state of contiguity in time -- is refuted by the statement [in the Paṭṭhāna] that 'when one emerges from cessationm, the sphere of neither perception nor non-perception is a causal condition by way of the causal condition of immediate contiguity for the fruit [consciousness]'.Tikap 160.
For [consciousness of] the sphere of neither perception nor non-perception, having ceased for a period of seven days or so, becomes immediate-contiguity causal condition for the attainment of the fruit [consciousness]. Therefore, without being obstinate, one should demonstrate that the difference here is merely one of words, not of meaning.
For the state of contiguity causal condition is cessation since this has the capacity to produce because of the absence of any gap between the cessation of the prior dhammas and the arising of the subsequent ones. The state of the causal condition of immediate-contiguity is cessation which becomes capable of producing because of exact contiguity, bringing, as it were, [a thing] into a state of identity with itself through the absence of such disjunctions (vibhāga) as being above, below, or close by.Cf. Vism-mhṭ (Be) II 273-74. In this way, the difference is merely one of words.
Indeed, because there is no interruption by a dhamma of the same immaterial nature between the sphere of neither-perception-nor-non-perception and the fruit [in the case of the attainment of cessation] and the earlier decease consciousness and relinking, in the case of rebirth in the unconscious realm, although [both] these arise at a different time, and because material dhammas, being of a different nature, do not have the capacity to form an interruption -- the capacity of the causal condition constituted by ceasing to produce with no gap and to produce, as it were, by bringing into a state of identity, still exists. So here too their state as the causal conditions of contiguity and immediate contiguity obtains. Therefore, while there is no difference as to dhamma, both those who have understanding and for those who might be led [to understanding] should likewise be convinced that the difference is one that merely concerns the sense of the prefix.
Since, when it does not arise, the things that arise with it also do not arise, like a lamp and its light, conascence causal condition is a causal condition by its arising along with that which has arisen along with it. These are the four immaterial aggregates, the four [material] elements, and, at the moment of rebirth, the heart-base and resultant dhammas.
Reciprocity causal condition is a causal condition by its being something that supports the dhammas which help it, like the three sticks [of a tripod] supporting each other.
And the nature of reciprocity causal condition consists in giving help precisely by virtue of that reciprocity, and not in mere conascence. This is the difference between the two.
Thus something that is simply a conascence causal condition is not a reciprocity causal condition. Since neither mind, which is a conascence causal condition for materialities generated by consciousness, not the [material] elements, which are a conascence causal condition for dependent materialities, are brought out as reciprocity causal condition.
For if, merely by being conascent, there existed the state of reciprocity causal condition as helping the things that help it, then the conascence and reciprocity causal conditions would have to be the same.
Like a canvas for a painting, the four aggregates become the support (nissaya) for conascent mind and materiality. Like the earth for trees and mountains, because it bears them, the material elements and the heart-base are supports for conascent materialities and the seven consciousness-elements respectively. Hence, these are called support causal condition as being leant on (nissīyati) by the things supported (nissitaka). When it is strong, the support becomes a causal condition that is a decisive-support causal condition (upanissaya-paccaya) since the prefix upa indicates excess. But its difference will be explained.
The six bases and six objects, which having arisen prior to that which has arisen with them as a causal condition, give help by their occurring [first], constitute prenascence causal condition.
The dhammas constituting consciousness and mentalities generated afterwards, which help by supporting the body [of materialities] that starts (??) to be the cause for the continuation of the [mental] continuity when that causal condition of postnascence does not exist, constitute postnascence causal condition;
it should be seen as like [the effect of] the volition associated with hunger on the bodies of young vultures.
As in the case of a previously familiar book, for that book subsequently, repetition is the way something similar -- in being wholesome, etc. -- makes [something] of the same class reach a state distinguished by its proficiency and strength. In this way dhammas of one class are repetition causal condition for dhammas of the same class [resulting] from that causal condition.
For dhammas of one class cannot by their proficient repetition make dhammas of a different class acquire their own condition (gati) -- reckoned as their wholesome, etc., state -- [but] distinguished by its proficient and strong state, and in consequence those [dhammas] do not acquire that. But it should be understood that these [dhammas that constitute repetition causal condition] are the ordinary wholesome and unwholesome impulsions and the blameless kiriya impulsions which are contiguous and past.
Kamma causal condition is the volition that, by constituting action understood as the application of consciousness, helps conascent and resultant [consciousness and mentalities] and kamma-produced materialities belonging to a different [later] moment.
Result causal condition consists of the resultant consciousness and mentalities that, by their own exertion-free and quiescent state, help bring about the exertion-free and quiescent state of conascent mind and materiality.
For, since it cannot be achieved by application, their exertion-free and quiescent state is produced simply by the past performance of kamma. Their quiescent state does not result from the stilling of defilements.
Indeed, it is precisely because of their quiescent state that it is difficult to be aware of the existence-continuum, etc.
It is difficult to be aware of the resultants [in the consciousness process], on the other hand, because they merely fall upon, receive and investigate [the object].
One is aware of their apprehending a visible form, etc., only with the occurrence of impulsion.
Food causal condition consists of the four foods which give help by supporting material and immaterial [dhammas].
For although it has the function of generating [dhammas], the principal function of food is just supporting.
So while it does generate, it does so by giving support by virtue of their continuation; hence the nature of food is just to give support.
Faculty causal condition is a causal condition in the sense of being dominant, which is understood as making the dhammas produced by that causal condition follow after it in [performing] various functions.
Jhāna causal condition consists of application of thought, etc., which, having come close (upagantvā) to the object by virtue of contemplating (upanijjhāna) it or contemplating the characteristics [of impermanence, etc.], are what watch (nijjhānaka) the object.
Path causal condition consists of right view, etc., which give help in the sense of leading away from happy destinies and merit, or unhappy destinies and what is bad.
Association causal condition consists of mental dhammas that give help by their characteristic of association, which is understood as their arising together as if they were one, although in an ultimate sense they are different.
Dissociation causal condition consists of the bases, consciousness, and mental concomitants which, although they are joined by being bound to each other, give help by their acquiring a state of differentiation through their separation by their being dissociated.
Existence causal condition consists of those dhammas that will be stated [by Anuruddha] with the words beginning conascent, prenascent, etc.,Abhidh-s 43.3 (Chapter VIII. 34) and which give help by their nature of supporting a dhamma that is alike in being existent, which is understood as being essentially present.
For, although they do generate [dhammas], the work of existence causal conditions is greatest precisely at the [moment of] presence (ṭhiti), and so only their nature of supporting is taken [into account].
Non-existence causal condition consists of the consciousness and mentalities which, having just ceased, give help by providing the opportunity for the consciousness and mentalities arising immediately after those that do not get the opportunity to last themselves since there is no second [arising] when a single arising of contact, etc., occurs.
Disappearance causal condition consists of those dhammas that, precisely by their disappearance, give help to dhammas which do not occur unless they disappear from their existence.
Non-disappearance causal condition is just the existence causal conditions giving help by virtue of their not arriving at [the point of] ceasing.
Existence causal condition consists in the giving help by the fact of mere co-existence, [while] non-disappearance causal condition consists in the giving help by virtue of not arriving at [the point of] ceasing -- the difference between these causal conditions should be seen as to do with this, and not with any difference in dhammas.
Having faith in the Blessed One as teaching the twenty-four causal conditions having understood the difference in the capacity of dhammas in all its aspects, one reaches through study the knowledge that dhammas are distinguished in this way, and should make the effort to understand this with the knowledge that comes through reflection and cultivation [of meditation].
For it should be understood that although there may be no difference in the assemblage of dhammas, a causal condition stated above [in one way] for persons who need to be trained in this or that way, is stated again in a different way, just as the 'dissociated from motivations' couplet [is stated] after the 'without motivations' couplet has been stated.This refers to the first two of the hundred couplets that comprise the Abhidhamma mātikā; see Dhs 2.
A resultant undetermined [dhamma] has come to its resultant state by virtue of kamma and has, as it were, fallen after being thrown by the force of kamma; when it occurs, having taken hold of its own existence, and exhausted that (paribhāvetvā), it neither causes another [resultant] to occur nor arises by taking the power of the previous resultant.
And, since it follows from the statement na maggapaccayā ... āsevane ekaṃPaṭṭh (Be) I 63 (§221) that, among the kiriya [consciousnesses] without motivations, repetition is brought out only in the case of the smile-producing [consciousness], the pair of adverting [consciousnesses] do not constitute repetition causal condition. Therefore, having in mind that only impulsions reach the state of repetition causal condition, he states the words beginning previous impulsions.
Although the statement is general, only ordinary wholesome, unwholesome and undetermined [impulsions] should be understood here, since the state of repetition is not brought out [in the Paṭṭhāna] in the case of the transcendent impulsions.
In consideration of this, the commentary to the Paṭṭḥāna says that 'but certainly there is no transcendent repetition causal-condition'.Paṭṭh-a 45; (Be) 373.
Therein a wholesome [transcendent consciousness], since it precedes one of a different class, does not cause the latter to acquire the quality of repetition, while the fruit consciousnesses, although they arise as impulsions, do not acquire repetition and do not cause something else to acquire it in the way stated in the case of the resultant undetermined.
And what has been said by Ācariya Dhammapāla Thera, namely, that there is no impulsion free from repetition,I have been unable to trace where this has been said is to be regarded as having been said by way of what is mostly [the case];
otherwise, it must follow that the Ācariya's way of expressingabhidhāyakatta, which is not in CPD, but cf. MW s.v. abhidhāyakatva. himself is careless.
There is no statement that the path [consciousness] does not acquire repetition from the change of lineage [consciousness], since variation in class (jāti) is not indicated by virtue of [a change in] level (bhūmi).
Thus, indeed, it is said in the Paṭṭhāna that change of lineage is a causal condition for the path by means of repetition causal condition, that purification is a causal condition for the path by means of repetition causal condition.Tikap 172; Paṭṭh (Be) I 154.
Since they lack the characteristic of the fourfold association [with consciousness] consisting of arising together, etc.,See Chapter II, §1 material dhammas, while they arise along with [consciousness] do not have the nature of association causal condition; with this in mind he states dhammas constituting consciousness and mentalities are a causal condition for each other.
A natural decisive-support is a decisive-support causal condition by its very nature (pakati), by its own intrinsic nature irrespective of any other kind of causal condition.
It is said to be any individual decisive support, apart, that is, from object and contiguity.Reading with Be CSCD, ārammaṇānantarehi.
Or else, a natural decisive-support causal condition is a decisive-support causal condition that is 'ready' (pakata),
where the pa in pakata is a prefix. It shows that it is something, with its capacity to give rise to its own effect, that has been produced and practised in a [mental and physical] continuity. Therefore, natural decisive-support causal conditions consist of greed, etc., or faith, etc., that have been produced in one's own mental continuity, or seasonal change and food, etc., that have been repeatedly experienced.
And this is how it is explained.
In order now to show that all these causal conditions are in summary just four, he states All ... are comprised by the object ... causal conditions.*
For that causal condition does not exist which might not become an object of the consciousness and mentalities, and does not become a decisive-support causal condition for what has arisen as a result of its own causal conditions; and -- by virtue of complementing the fruits and causes of the occurrence of the world, since that is caused by kamma -- they all fail to pass beyond the nature of kamma; and in the ultimate sense and by ordinary convention they are things actually occurring. Hence, all [causal conditions] are comprised in four.