Issues
Select Version
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā
Abhidhammatthavibhāvinīṭīkā

The Explanation of Causal Conditions

Author: PTS @ IAPT

The Explanation of Causal Conditions

Now in order to indicate for those dhammas, constituting mind and materiality that have already been stated, the causal conditions by way of the methods of dependent arising and the Paṭṭhāna, he begins with the words For Those.
For those dhammas which, because of their being conditioned by causal conditions, are conditioned, having arisen as a result of causal conditions, there are the causal-condition dhammas which are accordingly -- in this manner -- the causal conditions -- aids to their enduring and arising; I shall now explain here -- in the following summary of causal conditions -- the analysis of this -- the division of the various causal conditions for those things arisen as a result of causal conditions, and the mode of those causal conditions -- as appropriate -- according to the various modes of acting as a causal condition of the various causal conditions when a dhamma has arisen as a result of causal conditions. This is the manner of construing.
Therein, it is dependent arising in that, depending on an assemblage of causal conditions, there is the arising of the effects coming together as a result of that; it is the mode of causal conditions.
It is the Paṭṭhāna because in it are grounds (ṭhāna), or causal conditions, of various sorts, and so forth; it is the Great Treatise on universal causality (samanta-paṭṭhāna) according to a method without limit. The method of Paṭṭhāna is the method taught in this work.
Therein : of these two methods.
The coming into existence by the existence of something is the state of something whose tendency is to come into existence as a result of the existence of a dhamma which is the causal condition; that state itself is the simple manner; characterized by this it is characterized by the simple manner of coming into existence by virtue of the existence of something else.
This should also be taken as indicating the characterization [of dependent arising] as the simple manner of [something's] non-existence in the absence of a [given] thing.
For the characteristic of a causal condition should be explained as both positive and negative.
Thus the Blessed One has said,
'This existing, that exists; this arising, that arises;
this not existing, that does not exist; this ceasing, that ceases.'M I 263, II 32, III 63; S II 65, 95; A V 184.
A causal condition is that from which an effect comes;
a circumstance (ṭhiti) is where the effect stands (tiṭṭhati) since that is what its existence depends upon; the specific circumstance of the causal condition is the circumstance, understood as a causal condition, which exists as something specific or distinctive.

For the method of dependent arising, since it operates according to the simple manner of coming into existence by [virtue of] the existence of something [else], does not require the distinction of the rules of the causal conditions of motivation, etc., and applies generally.

The method of the Paṭṭhāna, however, operates by being specific about the way in which the different causal conditions, beginning with motivation, have various distinctive types of capacity to act as a causal condition for some other dhamma. Hence it is explained with reference to the specific circumstance of the causal condition (āhacca-paccaya-ṭṭhitim ārabbha pavuccati).

But some explain āhacca-paccaya-ṭṭhiti as a style of speaking where the throat and palate, etc., are struck.According to MW āhatya-vacana, and -vāda mean 'an explicit or energetic explanation'.
But one only has to hear this for it to be apparent that their pronouncement is ridiculous,
for one cannot teach the method of dependent arising - or any other method - without the throat and palate, etc., being struck.
By mixing: by also applying the Paṭṭhāna method specifically to dependent arising and, by using the causal conditions of motivation, etc., combining [that] with [the general principle of] coming into existence as a result of the existence of something [else], teachers -- the writers of [Abhidhamma] summaries, etc. -- elaborate -- explain it in detail.The detailed combined method is found at Vibh-a 138-88 and Vism 529-76 (Chapter XVII, §58-272) What he means is that he, however, will explain them separately.

The Explanation of the Method of Dependent Arising

Ignorance (avijjā) is that which does not discriminate (na vijānāti).The definition of avijjā that follows is a summary of Vibh-a 134 and Vism 526 (Chapter XVII, §43) Or ignorance is what finds (vindati), partakes of, what should not be found (avindya), i.e. misconduct of the body, etc.; or what does not find what should be found, i.e. good conduct of the body, etc.; or what does not made known (na viditaṃ karoti) what should be known, i.e. the four truths, etc.; or what promotes (javāpeti) things that do not exist (avijjamāna),Things that do not exist from an ultimate standpoint, i.e. men, women, etc.; Vibh-a 134 = Vism 526 (Chapter XVII, §43). or what does not promote (na javāpeti) things that do exist (vijjamāna).Things that do exist from an ultimate standpoint, i.e. the aggregates, etc. It is a name for lack of knowledge of the four truths and the four items beginning with the past.The past, the future, the past and future, dependently arisen dhammas; see Dhs 195-96 (§1100).
The causal condition of ignorance is the causal condition that is ignorance itself; from that causal condition of ignorance.
Formations (saṅkhāra) are what construct (abhisaṅkharonti) the conditioned (saṅkhata) -- that is, wholesome and unwholesome kammas.
They are threefold: meritorious formation, demeritorious formation, and imperturbable formation.
Therein the thirteen sense-sphere and form-sphere wholesome volitions are meritorious formation; the twelve unwholesome volitions are demeritorious formation; the four formless volitions are imperturbable formation. Thus these twenty-nine volitions are called formations.
The nineteen types of resultant consciousness (citta) [occurring] by way of relinking and the thirty-two [occurring] by way of activity are called consciousness (viññāṇa).
Mind-materiality (nāma-rūpa) is mind and materiality.
Therein mind in this context is the three aggregates beginning with feeling; materiality, the materiality produced by kamma in two ways as the elements and what is dependent. It should be understood that the pair of mind and materiality are here what accompanies relinking consciousness.
Because of the causal condition of mind and materiality: it should be understood that here 'mind-body' can be taken according to its separate parts as mind, materiality and mind-together-with-materiality.Cf. Vibh-a 173-77, Vism 562-65 (Chapter XVII, §§203-19).
The six internal spheres of the eye, etc. -- or, in the opinion of some, also the six external spheres of visible forms, etc. -- are called spheres.
The sixfold-sphere is the six spheres and [just] the sixth sphere.Since in the formless realms there exists only the sixth sphere, that of mind (manāyatana); see Vibh 179, Vibh-a 174, Vism 562 (Chapter XVII, §204).
Conatct through the six doors beginning with eye-contact, etc., is called contact.
The three kinds that are happiness, pain and equanimity are called feeling.
Craving is of three kinds: craving for the objects of sense-desire, craving for existence, and craving for non-existence;
but by way of the six kinds of object, etc., there are one hundred and eight varieties.See above, Chapter VII, §52. By way of sense-desire grasping, etc., there are four graspings.
Herein weak craving is called 'craving', strong [craving] 'grasping'.
Or wanting an object that is not in one's reach is craving, like a thief's searching with his hand in the dark, and taking hold of the object once it is within one's reach is grasping, like the thief's taking hold of what has come to hand.
Craving is opposed by wanting little; grasping is opposed by contentment;
craving is the root of the suffering of searching [for things], grasping the root of the suffering of guarding [things]. This is the difference between them.
Becoming (bhava) is twofold: becoming as kamma and becoming as [resultant] arising.
Therein, the first is becoming in that it is that from which an effect becomes (bhavati); it is of twenty-nine kinds, consisting of the sense-sphere wholesome and unwholesome, etc.
The second is becoming in that it becomes; it is of nine kinds, consisting of sense-desire becoming, etc.Sense-desire (kāma), form (rūpa), formless (arūpa), conscious (saññā), unconscious (asaññā), neither-conscious-nor-unconscious (nevasaññānāsaññā), one-constituent (eka-vokāra), four-constituent (catu-vokāra) and five-constituent (pañca-vokāra) becoming (Vibh 137).
While in the statement from the causal condition of grasping there is becoming, becoming is arising is intended,
in the statement because of the causal condition of becoming there is birth, only becoming as kamma [is intended],
for it is this that is the causal condition of birth, not the former.
For the former is by nature the primary occurrence of the aggregates, which is birth itself, and that it should be its [own] cause is not appropriate.
Birth is a being's obtaining of an individual existence in the various destinies, etc.
Old age is the state of being old of the individual that has arisen in this way;
death is the end of that individual who is limited to a single existence;
grief is the mental torment of one stricken by the loss of relatives, etc.;
lamentation is his wailing speech;
pain is painful bodily feeling;
unhappiness is painful mental feeling;
despair is the terrible exhaustion produced by the excessive mental anguish of one stricken by the loss of relatives, etc.
It should be understood here that although there exist other causal conditions such as base and object, etc., each causal condition, beginning with ignorance, is taken as being a principal and clear [causal condition].
And herein, because it occurs in a [mental] continuity latent with that very ignorance resulting in formations, from the causal condition of ignorance formations come into being. And consciousness, having been generated by formations, is established in a new existence,
for in the absence of the generating [formations] there can be no arising of consciousness, hence, from the causal condition of formations, consciousness [comes into being].
And mind and materiality, being supported by consciousness which act as a prior basis, are established on relinking and [consciousness in] activity, so from the causal condition of consciousness mind and materiality [come into being]. And supported by that very mind and materiality - not otherwise - the six sense-spheres are active as the doors for the six kinds of contact as appropriate; hence from the causal condition of mind and materiality the six sense-spheres [come into being].
And contact touches its objects only when the six sense-spheres come into being,
for in the absence of the doors there can be no arising of contact; hence from the causal condition of the six sense-spheres contact [comes into being].
And only by contacting objects that are desirable, undesirable and moderately so does feeling feel, not otherwise; hence from the causal condition of contact feeling [comes into being].
And when one views the dhammas that are experienced (vedanīya) as pleasant, there arises craving caused by feeling; hence from the causal condition of feeling craving [comes into being].
And that same craving, attachment, and thirst in becoming firm lead to the grasping of dhammas that are the object of grasping,
for when, as a result of craving, one repeatedly enjoys visible objects, etc., they reach the condition of needing to be guarded (pātavyatā);This meaning and derivation from the root pā ('to protect, guard') is not given in PED, but the association of guarding (ārakkha) with the transition from craving to grasping has just been stated in this section and derives from D II 58: vedanaṃ paṭicca taṇhā, taṇhaṃ paṭicca pariyesanā ... lābho ... vinicchayo ... chandarāgo ... ajjhosānaṃ ... pariggaho ... macchariyaṃ, macchariyaṃ paṭicca ārakkho. hence craving is the causal condition for sense-desire grasping.
Similarly, enslaved to the different kinds of object such as visible forms, etc., one holds the wrong view that there is no giving, etc., [and] wanting to escape from saṃsāra, one follows as the path to purity what is not the path to purity, and holds the two kinds of view that constitute the doctrine of self, taking the aggregates as the self or as belonging to the self. Therefore, craving is also the causal condition for the grasping of views, etc.; hence from the causal condition of craving, grasping [comes into being].
Established in that very grasping as an associate [of consciousness] and latent defilement as appropriate, being turns towards the accumulation of kamma; hence grasping is the causal condition for becoming.
And birth, which is reckoned as becoming-as-arising, is precisely caused by becoming as kamma,
like a sprout that is obtained again and again from a seed; hence becoming is called the causal condition of birth.
And when there is birth, old age and death come into being,
for old age and death do not come into being for those who are not born; hence birth is the causal condition of old age and death. How these things come into existence from the existence of something [else] should be seen in this way.
Such is the arising of this whole mass of suffering: as a result of the succession of causal conditions in the said manner, and not as the creation of God (issara), etc., is the arising -- the existence -- of this -- reckoned as the round of rebirth -- mass of suffering which is wholly unmixed with happiness, etc., or an entire heap of suffering, and not of happiness and beauty, etc.
Here, in this section of the summary of causal conditions.
A time period (addhan) is what is on the move (atati), what continuously passes, occurs, that is, time.
Ignorance and formations are the past time-period, since it is the causes included in the past existence that are intended here, and because in considering the time period only the dhammas of ignorance and formations are considered, as a time free of those is not known.
For it is simply dhammas that have ceased and not yet arisen that are described by way of past and future time, and those that are included in the three moments of arising, etc., that are described by way of present time.
Birth, old age and death are the future time-period, since they happen in the future because of present causes.
In the middle ... are the present time-period; since they are by nature the presently occurring effect from a past cause, and by nature the present cause of a future effect, the eight components in the middle beginning with consciousness are the present time-period.
Should not grief, lamentation, etc., also be stated as factors? With this in mind he states the words beginning the terms grief, and so on.
The terms grief, and so on indicate mere secondary effects that issue from birth; the meaning is that they do not indicate separate factors.
Craving, grasping and becoming are also taken: since they have in common the nature of being defilements, by taking ignorance, craving and grasping are taken; since they have in common the nature of being kamma, by taking formations, becoming as kamma is taken;
and similarly by taking craving, grasping and becoming, ignorance and formations are taken. This is the construction.
In the latter case too, the inclusion of the items when taking [other] items should be understood in the manner [just] stated. And since it is just the birth, decay and dissolution of consciousness, mind-and-materiality, the six sense-spheres, contact, and feeling that are stated as birth, old age, and death, he states the words beginning by taking birth, old age and death.

In the past five causes: by way of those [items] that have been stated as similar in nature -- the two that are ignorance and formations and the three that are craving, grasping, and becoming, which are taken by virtue of being included [with the former] -- there are five causes that occurred in the previous existence as the causal conditions for the present effect.

Five effects now: because of the causal condition constituted by past causes, there are five effects beginning with consciousness occurring now in the present.

Five causes now: by way of those [items] that have been stated as similar in nature; the three beginning with craving and the two that are ignorance and formations, which are taken by being included [with the former], there are five cuases that are the causal conditions for an effect in the future.
In the future five effects: stated by taking birth, old age, and death [as above] the five effects beginning with consciousness occur in the future because of the causal condition constituted by present causes. In this way there are twenty reasons -- reasons (ākāra) in that they are dispersed (ākirīyanti) here and there through the past and so on.
Between the past causes and the five present effects there is one link (sandhi); between the five present effects and the present causes there is one; between the present causes and the future effects there is one; in this way there are three links.
For it is stated that
there is one link between formations and consciousness, one between feeling and craving, and one between becoming and birth.Vibh-a 191; Vism 579 (Chapter XVII, §289).
Herein, the first constitutes a transition from cause to effect since it represents the occurrence of the effect following the cause with no break. Likewise, the third, but the second constitutes a transition from effect to cause, since it represents the occurrence of the cause following the effect without a break.
For although a dhamma constitutes an effect it [still] acts as a causal condition for another dhamma that has the nature of a cause.
It is a collection in that ignorance, etc., and consciousness, etc., are collected in it. The four collections are the past cause, the present result, the present cause, the future result; hence there are the four collections.
That part of becoming reckoned as kamma-becoming: here the volition that is the causal condition of future relinking is called becoming, [while] the volition belonging to the previous kamma-becoming that is the causal condition of the present relinking should be understood as volitional force.
And the rest: the seven dhammas stated as the present effect, namely, the five beginning with consciousness and birth, old age, and death.
However, as for that part of becoming reckoned as arising, those [dhammas] should be understood as being included in the future.
When the word 'becoming' is used, kamma-becoming is also stated; therefore, he uses the expression that part of becoming.
The root of the first part is ignorance,
the root of the second part is craving, and so he states that by way of ignorance and craving there are two roots.
By the ceasing of those same roots of the round of rebirth reckoned as ignorance and craving -- as a result of their non-occurrence which is accomplished by penetration of the truths with the reaching of the condition of non-arising -- the round of rebirth ceases.
In the case of those beings who are continuously -- without a break -- oppressed by the confusion reckoned as old age and death, [and] become stricken by grief, etc., because of the arising of the taints of sense-desire, etc., once again ignorance carries on.
For it is said that from the arising of the taints, etc., there arises ignorance;M I 55

this indicates that ignorance too has a causal condition.

Since otherwise the wheel of dependent arising would not be closed,

End of the explanation of the method of dependent arising.