Issues
Select Version
THE BOOK OF THE FOURS
THE BOOK OF THE FOURS

III.VOLITIONAL

Author: Bhikkhu Bodhi @ IAPT

III.VOLITIONAL

171(1)VolitionThe first part of this sutta,up to the section on the four acquisi- tions of individuality,is also atSN 12:25,I39-41,but addressed to Ananda.

“Bhikkhus,when there is the body,then because of bodily volition [158I pleasure and pain arise internally;
when there is speech,then because of verbal volition pleasure and pain arise internally;
when there is the mind;then because of mental volition pleasure and pain arise internally—with ignorance itself as condition.Mp explains this with reference to the Abhidhamma scheme of cittas,types of consciousness;see CMA32-40,46-64.I summarize Mp's explanation:Bodily volition is of twenty kinds by way of the eight kinds of sense-sphere wholesome cittas and twelve kinds of unwholesome cittas.So too for verbal volition.But mental voli- tion includes these as well as the nine kinds of sublime(mahag- gata)volition,namely,volition associated with the five jhanas of the Abhidhamma system and the four formless attainments. Because of bodily volition,there arises pleasure conditioned by the eight kinds of wholesome kamma,and pain conditioned by the twelve kinds of unwholesome kamma,that is,the kamma generated in the corresponding active types of consciousness.So too for the other two doors.Ignorance is a condition(avijjāpaccayā va)because,there being ignorance,volition occurs in the three doors as a condition for pleasure and pain.Thus this sutta statement refers to ignorance as the root cause.Pleasure and pain arise"infernally"(ajjhattam)when they arise in oneself.The word seems to underscore the retributive aspect of kamma.
“Either on one's own,bhikkhus,one performs that bodily.volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise in one internally,
or others make one generate that bodily volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise in one internally.
Either with clear comprehension one performs that bodily volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise in one internally,
or without clear comprehension one performs that bodily volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise in one internally.Mp:“One acts on one's own(sāmam)when one initiates the action without instigation from others.One instigates activity because of others when others encourage or command one to act.One acts with clear comprehension(sampajāno) when one knows the wholesome and unwholesome as such,and their respective results as such.If one does not understand this,one acts without clear comprehension.”
“Either on one's own,bhikkhus,one performs that verbal volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise in one internally,
or others make one perform that verbal volitional activity
conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise in one internally.
Either with clear comprehension one performs that verbal volitional activity conditioned by which pleasureand pain arise in one internally,
or without clear comprehen-sion one performs that verbal volitional activity conditioned bywhich pleasure and pain arise in one internally.
“Either on one's own,bhikkhus,one performs that mental volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arisein one internally,
or others make one perform that mental volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise inone internally.
Either with clear comprehension one performs that mental volitional activity conditioned by which pleasure and pain arise in one internally,
or without clear comprehen-sion one performs that mental volitional activity conditionedby which pleasure and pain arise inone internally.

“Ignorance is comprised within these states.Imesu.bhikkhave dhammesu avijjā anupatita.Mp:"Ignorance is comprised in the volitional states analyzed above,functioning both as a coexistent condition and as a decisive-support condition(sahajatavasena ca upanissayavasena ca).Thus the round of existence and its root,ignorance,are shown.”

But with the remainderless fading away and cessation of ignorance that body does not exist conditioned by which that pleasure and pain arise in one internally;that speech does not exist conditioned by which that pleasure and pain arise in one internally;that mind does not exist conditioned by which that pleasureand pain arise in one internally.Mp:“Arahants are seen acting with the body.They sweep the courtyard of the shrine and the bodhi tree,go out and return, do various duties,etc.,but in their case the twenty volitions occurring at the bodily door no longer produce kammic results (avipakadhammatam āpajjanti).Here,it is the volition that occurs at the body door that is intended by the word 'body.'The same method applies to the other two."Mp-t:“When arahants perform actions,how is it that they create no bodily or other kinds of kamma?In the sense that these deeds do not bear results,for an action done by an arahant is neither wholesome nor unwholesome but a mere activity (kiriyamatta)that does not yield results."

That field does not exist,that site [159]does not exist,that base does not exist,that location does not exist conditioned by which that pleasure and pain arise in one internally.Mp:"'Field,'etc.,are names for wholesome and unwholesome kamma.For that is a feild (khetta)in the sense of a place where results grow;a site (vatthu)in the sense of their foundation;a base(ayatana)in the sense of a cause;a location(adhikarana)in the sense of a locale."

“Bhikkhus,there are these four acquisitions of individuality.In Ee this sentence marks the beginning of a new sutta,and thus at this point Ee's numbering exceeds mine by one.Both Ce and Be,in accord with Mp,treat the previous passage and this one as a single sutta.While this paragraph certainly looks like the beginning of an independent sutta,and perhaps originally was,Mp takes it to be continuous with the analysis of volition stated above.It says that up to this point the Buddha has shown the kamma accumulated in the three doors;now he shows the places where that kamma ripens."Acquisition of individuality"(attabhavappatilabha)is an individual existence,the combination of body and mind that constitutes a particular life.
What four?
(1)There is an acquisition of individuality in which one's own volition operates,not the volition of others.
(2)There is an acquisition of individuality in which the volition of others operates,not one's own volition.
(3)There is an acquisition of individuality in which both one's own volition and the volition of others operate.
(4)And there is an acquisition of individuality in which neither one's own volition nor the volition of others operates.
These are the four acquisitions of individuality.”
When this was said,the Venerable Sariputta said to the Blessed One:
"Bhante,I understand in detail the meaning of this statement that the Blessed One has spoken in brief to be as follows.
(1)In that acquisition of individuality in which one'sown volition operates but not the volition of others,it is by reason of their own volition that beings pass away from that group.Mp identifies these beings as the devas corrupted by play(khiddāpadosika deva).While they are enjoying celestial delights in their heavenly realm,they sometimes forget to eat and drink and because they miss a meal they wither away like a garland placed in the sun.See Bodhi 2007:159-60.
(2)In that acquisition of individuality in which the volition of others operates but not one's own volition,it is byreason of the volition of others that beings pass away from that group.Mp says these are the devas corrupted by mind (manopadosikadeva);who dwell in the realm of the four great kings.When they become angry at one another,their mutual anger becomes the cause for both to pass away.See Bodhi2007:160-61.
(3)In that acquisition of individuality in which both one's own volition and the volition of others operate,it is by reason of both one's own volition and the volition of others that beings pass away from that group.Mp says that these are human beings.For people kill themselves and others kill them.Thus they perish either on account of their own volition or because of the volition of others.
(4)But,Bhante,what kind of devas should be understood as the acquisition of individuality in which neither one's own volition nor the volition of others operates?”Mp:“[Question:]'Why does Sariputta pose this question? Isn't he able to answer it himself?[Reply:]He is able,but he does not speak because he thinks,This question is in the domain of a Buddha."
"They are,Sariputta,the devas of the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.”
“Why is it,Bhante,that some beings who pass away from that group are returners,who come back to this state of being,
while [160]others are non-returners,who do not come back to this state of being?Mp:“The former,who come back to this state of being(agantāroitthattam),are those who return to the five aggregates in the senses phere;they are not reborn there [in the realm where they pass away] or in a higher realm.Those who do not come back to this state of being(anagantaro itthattam)do not return to the five aggregates or take a lower rebirth.They are either reborn there [in the realm where they pass away]or in a higher realm,or they attain final nibbāna right there.When it is said that they are reborn in a higher realm,this is said in the case of those who had been born in a lower existence.But from the realm of neither-perception-nor-non-perception,there is no rebirth into a higher realm."
“Here,Sariputta,some person has not abandoned the lower fetters.In this very life he enters and dwells in the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.
He relishes it,desires it,and finds satisfaction in it.
If he is firm in it,focused on it;often dwells in it,and has not lost it when he dies;he is reborn in companionship with the devas in the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.
When he passes away from there he is a returner who comes back to this state of being.
“But some [other]person here has abandoned the lower fetters.In this very life he enters and dwells in the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.
He relishes it,desires it,and finds satisfaction in it.
If he is firm in.it;focused on it,often dwells in it,and has not lost it when he dies,he is reborn in companionship with the devas in the base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception.
When he passes away from there he is an on-returner who does not come back to this state of being.
“This,Sāriputta,is the reason some beings here who pass away from that group are returners,who come back to this state of being,
while others are non-returners,who do not come back to this state of being.“

172(2)Analysis

There the Venerable Sariputta addressed the bhikkhus:
"Friends,bhikkhus!”
“Friend!”those bhikkhus replied.
The Venerable Sariputta said this:
(1)"A half-month,friends,after my full ordination I realized the analytical knowledge of meaning by way of its divisions and formulation.Odhiso byanjanaso.Mp glosses these two words respectively with karanaso akkharaso,"by way of reasons [or cases],by way of the letter."The meaning is not entirely clear to me and Mp-t does not elaborate.The patisambhidas are explained at Vism 440-43, Ppn 14.21-31,on the basis of Vibh 292-94(Be SS718-24),which analyzes them from several angles.Briefly:Knowledge of meaning is analytical knowledge of meaning (atthgpatisambhida);knowledge of Dhamma is analytical knowledge of Dharma(dhammapatisambhida);knowledge of how to express and articulate the Dhamma is analytical knowledge of language(niruttipatisambhida);and knowledge about knowledges is analytical knowledge of discernment (patibhānapatisambhida).This last analytical knowledge seems to refer to the ability to spontaneously apply the other three types of knowledge to clearly communicate the Dhamma.From a more philosophical perspective,attha is considered the result of a cause(hetuphala)and dhamma a cause(hetu)producing an effect.Therefore the analytical knowledge of meaning is correlated with knowledge of the first and third noble truths,analytical knowledge of Dhamma with knowledge of the second and fourth noble truths.Analytical knowledge of meaning is knowledge of each fact or of dependent origination in its role as an effect arisen from a condition,and analytical knowledge of Dhamma is knowledge of the same factor in its role as a condition giving rise to an effect.
In many ways I explain it,teach it,proclaim it,establish it,disclose it,analyze it,and elucidate it.Ee's pakasemi,as the third verb,is not in Ce or Be.Pakāseti is also absent in the same sequence of verbsat 3:136,I286,9-10,also in Ee.
[Let]anyone who is perplexed or uncertain [approach]me with a question;

I [will satisfy him]with my answer.The text is cryptic here and may have become garbled in the course of transmission.Mp supplies a verb to the first part of the sentence,upagacchatu,which I include and translate in brackets. Mp fills out aham veyyäkaranena with ahamassa panhakathanena cittam āradhessami(“I will satisfy his mind by answering the ques- tion").I have also added this in brackets.

Our teacher,who is highly skilled in our teachings,is present.Mp:"Our teacher,who is highly skilled in these things that have been attained by us,is present.If I had not realized the analytical knowledge of meaning,he would dismiss me,telling me to first realize it.'Even while sitting in front of the teacher,he roars a lion's roar.”

(2)“A half-month after my full ordination I realized the analytical knowledge of the Dhamma by way of its divisions and formulation.
In many ways I explain it,teach it,proclaim it,establish it,disclose it,analyze it,and elucidate it.
[Let]anyone who is perplexed or uncertain [approach]me witha question;
I[will satisfy him]with my answer.Our teacher,who is highly skilled in our teachings,is present.
(3)“A half-month after my full ordination I realized the analytical knowledge of language by way of its divisions and formulation.
In many ways I explain it,teach it,proclaim it, establish it,disclose it,analyze it,and elucidate it.
[Let]anyone who is perplexed or uncertain [approach]me with a question;
I[will satisfy him]with my answer.Our teacher,who is highly skilled in our teachings,is present.
(4)"A half-month after my full ordination I realized the ana- lytical knowledge of discernment by way of its divisions and formulation.
In many ways I explain it,teach it,proclaim it, establish it,disclose it,analyze it,and elucidate it.
[Let]anyone who is perplexed or uncertain [approach]me with a question;
I [will satisfy him]with my answer.Our teacher,who is highly skilled in our teachings,is present."[161]

173(3)Kotthita

Then the Venerable Mahākotthita approached the Venerable Sariputta
and exchanged greetings with him.
When they hadconcluded their greetings and cordial talk,he sat down to oneside
and asked the Venerable Sariputta:
(1)“Friend,with the remainderless fading away and cessation of the six bases for contact,is there anything else?'The dialogue here seems to be concerned with the"ontological status"of the arahant who has attained the nibbāna element without residue remaining,that is,with the question whether the liberated person exists or does not exist after death.
“Do not say so,friend.”
(2)“With the remainderless fading away and cessation of the six bases for contact,is there nothing else?”
“Do not say so,friend.“
(3)“With the remainderless fading away and cessation of the six bases for contact,is there both something else and nothingelse?”
“Do not say so,friend.”
(4)“With the remainderless fading away and cessation of the six bases for contact,is there neither something else nor nothing else?”
“Do not say so,friend.”Mp glosses ma h'evam with evam ma bhani,"Do not speak thus," and explains that the four questions are asked by way of eter- nalism,annihilationism,partial eternalism,and"eel-wriggling" (sassata-uccheda-ekaccasassata-amaravikkhepa).Thus Sariputta rejects each question."Eel-wriggling"is agnosticism,skepticism, or intellectual evasiveness.
“Friend,when you are asked:'With the remainderless fadingaway and cessation of the six bases for contact,is there something else?'you say:Do not say so,friend.'
And when you are asked:'With the remainderless fading away and cessation ofthe six bases for contact;is there nothing else?
……
Is there both something else and nothing else?..
……
Is there neither something else nor nothing else?'……
[in each case】you say:'Do not say so,friend.'
In what way should the meaning of this statement be understood?”
(1)“Friend,if one says:'With the remainderless fading awayand cessation of the six bases for contact,there is somethingelse,'one proliferates that which is not to be proliferated.Appapancam papanceti.Mp:“He creates proliferation [or speculations]in relation to something that should not be proliferated[or speculated about].He travels along a path that one should not travel on."The Pali word papanca suggests mental fabrication,obsessive mental construction,and deluded conceptualization,which the commentaries say arise from craving,conceit,and wrong views(tanhā,māna,ditthi).It seems to me that Mp understands appapanicam as'a contraction of appapanciyam.A Chinese parallel,SA249,says at:T II60a16-20:“Ifone [makes any of these assertions aboutthe six bases for contact],these are just emptywords(此則虚言).With the vanishing,fading away,cessation,and stilHing of the six bases for contact,one relinquishes emptyfalsehood(離諸虚偽)and attains nibbāna."
(2)If one says:Friend,with the remainderless fading away andcessation of the six bases for contact,there is nothing else,'one proliferates that which is not to be proliferated.
(3)If one says:Friend,with the remainderless fading away and cessation ofthe six bases for contact,there is both something else and nothing else,one proliferates that which is not to be proliferated.
(4)If one says:Friend,with the remainderless fading away andcessation of the six bases for contact,there is neither somethingelse nor nothing else,one proliferates that which is not to be proliferated.
“Friend,as far as the range of the six bases for contact extends,just so far extends the range of proliferation.Tavatā papanicassa gati.Mp:"As far as the rangeof the six basesextends,just so far extends the range of proliferation,distin-guished by way of craving,views,and conceit.”
As far as the range of proliferation extends,[162]just so far extends the range of the six bases for contact.
With the remainderless fading awayand cessation of the six bases for contact there is the cessation of proliferation,the subsiding of proliferation.”

174(4)Ananda

Then the Venerable Ananda approached the Venerable Mahä-kotthita
and exchanged greetings with him.
[This sutta is exactly the same as4:173 except that here Ananda asks the questions and Mahākotthita responds.]Ee treats this sutta as a continuation of the preceding one,without counting it separately.Thus at this point Ee's numbering catches up with Ce and Be.[163]
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……
……

175(5)Upavana

Then the Venerable Upavāna approached the Venerable Sariputta
...
...
and said to him:
(1)“Friend Sariputta,does one become an end-maker by means of knowledge?”The dialogue,according to Mp,refers to making an end to samsāra,the entire round of suffering(vattadukkhiassa anta-karo hoti,sakalam.oattadukkham paricchinnam parivatumam katvātifthati).
“This is not the case,friend.”
(2)"Then does one become an end-maker by means of conduct?”
“This is not the case,friend.”
(3)"Then does one become an end-maker by means of knowledge and conduct?”
“This is not the case,friend.”
(4)“Then does one become an end-maker otherwise than by means'of knowledge and conduct?”
“This is not the case,friend.”
“When you are asked:Friend Sariputta,does one become an end-maker by means of knowledge?'
you say:“This is not thecase,friend.
When you are asked:“Then does one become an end-maker by means of conduct?
...
by means of knowledge and conduct?
……
otherwise than by means of knowledge andconduct?'
[in each case]you say:“This is not the case,friend.'
Then in what way does one become an end-maker?”
(1)“If,friend,one were to become an end-maker by means of knowledge,even one who still has clinging would become an end-maker.
(2)If one were to become an end-maker by means of conduct,even one who still has clinging would become anend-maker.
(3)If one were to become an end-maker by means of knowledge and conduct,even one who still has clinging would become an end-maker.
(4)If one were to become an end-maker otherwise than by means of knowledge and conduct,then a worldling would be an end-maker;
for a worldling is destitute of knowledge and conduct.
"Friend,one deficient in conduct does not know and see things as they are.
One accomplished in conduct [164]knows and sees things as they are.
Knowing and seeing things as they are,one becomes an end-maker."Caranasampanno yathabhutam jānati passati.Yathäbhutam jānampassam antakaro hoti.This differs from the previous assertion(that one cannot become an end-maker by means of knowledge and conduct)in its emphasis on knowing and seeing(as well as conduct)as active functions rather than subjective possession stinged with clinging.

176 (6) A spiringThis sutta merges 2:130-33.

(1)“Bhikkhus,a bhikkhu endowed with faith,rightly aspir- ing,should aspire thus:
'May I become like Sariputta and Moggalläna!'
This is the standard and criterion for my bhikkhu disciples,that is,Sariputta and Moggallana.
(2)“Bhikkhus,a bhikkhuni endowed with faith,rightly aspiring,should aspire thus:
'May I become like the bhikkhunīs khemā and Uppalavanna!'
This is the standard and criterion for my bhikkhunī disciples,that is,the bhikkhunis Khemā and Uppalavannā.
(3)“Bhikkhus,a male lay follower endowed with faith,rightly aspiring,should aspire thus:
'May I become like Citta the householder and Hatthaka of Alavi!
This is the standard and criterion for my male lay disciples,that is,Citta the householder and Hatthaka of Alavī.
(4)“Bhikkhus,a female lay follower endowed with faith,rightly aspiring,should aspire thus:
'May I become like the female lay follower Khujjuttarā and Velukantakī Nandamāta!'
This is the standard and criterion for my female lay disciples,that is,the female lay follower Khujjuttarā and Velukantakī Nandamāta.“

177(7)Rahula

Then the Venierable Rahula approached the Blessed One,
paid homage to him,and sat down to one side.
The Blessed Onethen said to him:Much of this is also in MN 62.8-11,I421-23.See too MN28 and MN 140,which treat the topic more elaborately.
(1)“Rahula,the internal earth element and the external earth element are just the earth element.
This should be seen as it really is with correct wisdom thus:‘This is not mine,this I am not,this is not my self.'
Having seen this thus as it really is with correct wisdom,one becomes disenchanted with the earth element;one detaches the mind from the earth element.Ee's pannaya cittam virajeti is clearly wrong.In each of the four paragraphs,pannaya here should be replaced by the name of the element.
(2)“Rahula,the internal water element and the external water element [165]are just the water element.
This should be seen as it really is with correct wisdom thus:“This is not mine,this I am not,this is not my self.'
Having seen this thus as it really is with correct wisdom,one becomes disenchanted with the water element;one detaches the mind from the water element.
(3)“Rahula,the internal fire element and the external fireelement are just the fire element.
This should be seen as it really is with correct wisdom thus:“This is not mine,this I am not,this is not my self.'
Having seen this thus as it really is with correct wisdom,one becomes disenchanted with the fire element;onedetaches the mind from the fire element.
(4)“Rahula,the internal air element and the external air element are just the air element.
This should be seen as it really is with correct wisdom thus:‘This is not mine,this I am not,this is not my self.'
Having seen this thus as it really is with correct wisdom,one becomes disenchanted with the air element;one detaches the mind from the air element.
“When,Rahula,a bhikkhu does not recognize a self or the belongings of a self in these four elements,he is called a bhikkhu who has cut off craving,stripped off the fetter,and by completely breaking through conceit,has made an end of suffering."

178(8)The Reservoir

“Bhikkhus,there are these four kinds of persons found existing in the world.
What four?
(1)"Here,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
He attends to the cessation of personal existence.Sakkāyanirodham.Mp:"The cessation of personal existence,that is,the round of existence with its three realms;the meaning is nibbāna.”
As he is doing so,his mind does not launch out toward it,acquire confidence,become steady,and focus on it.
This bhikkhu cannot be expected to attain the cessation of personal existence.
Suppose a man were to grab hold of a branch with his hand smeared with gum.His hand would stick to it,adhere to it,and be fastened to it.
So too,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
……
……
This bhikkhu cannot be expected to attain the cessation of personal existence.
(2)“Here,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
[166]He attends to the cessation of personal existence.
As he is doing so,his mind launches out toward it,acquires confidence,becomes steady,and focuses on it.
This bhikkhu can be expected to attain the cessation of personal existence.
Suppose a man were to grab hold of a branch with a clean hand.His hand would not stick to it,adhere to it,or be fastened to it.
So too,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
...
...
This bhikkhu can beexpected to attain the cessation of personal existence.
(3)“Here,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
He attends to the breaking up of ignorance.
As he is doing so,his mind does not launch out toward it,acquire confidence,become steady,and focus on it.
This bhikkhu cannot be expected to attain the breaking up of ignorance.
Suppose there were a reservoir many years old.
A man would close off its inlets and open up its outlets,and sufficient rain would not fall.
In such a case,it could not be expected that this reservoir's embankment would break.
So too,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
...
……
This bhikkhu cannot be expected to attain the breaking up of ignorance.
(4)“Here,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
He attends to the breaking up of ignorance.
As he is doing so,his mind launches out toward it,acquires confidence,becomes steady,and focuses on it.
This bhikkhu can beexpected to attain the breaking up of ignorance.
Suppose there were a reservoir many years old.
A man would open up its inlets and close off its outlets,and sufficient rain would fall.
In such a case,it could be expected that this reservoir's embankment would break.
So too,a bhikkhu enters and dwells in a certain peaceful liberation of mind.
He attends to the breaking up of ignorance.
[167]As he is doing so,his mind launches out toward it,acquires confidence,becomes steady, and focuses on it.
This bhikkhu can be expected to attain the breaking upof ignorance.
“These,bhikkhus,are the four kinds of persons found existing in the world.”

179(9)Nibbāna

Then the Venerable Ananda approached the Venerable Sāriputta.
……
……
and said to him:
“Why is it,friend Sariputta,that some beings do not attain nibbāna in this very life?”
“Here,friend Ananda,[some]beings do not understand as it really is:‘These perceptions pertain to deterioration;these perceptions pertain to stabilization;these perceptions pertain to distinction;these perceptions pertain to penetration.'
This is why some beings here do not attain nibbāna in this very life.“
Why is it,friend Sariputta,that some beings here attain nibbāna in this very life?”
“Here,friend Ananda,[some]beings understand as it really is:“These perceptions pertain to deterioration;these percep-tions pertain to stabilization;these perceptions pertain to distinction;these perceptions pertain to penetration.'
This is why some beings here attain nibbāna in this very life."These are explained at Vibh 330-31(Be S799),though in terms of wisdom(panna).I quote only the text on the first jhana:"When perception and attention are accompanied by sensuality in one who attains the first jhāna,wisdom pertains to deterioration;when mindfulness is stabilized in accordance with its nature,wisdom pertains to stabilization;when perception and attentionare unaccompanied by thought,wisdom pertains to distinction.When perception and attention are accompanied by disenchantment,conjoined with dispassion,wisdom pertains to penetration”(pathamassa jhanassa labhim kamasahagatā saniamanasikarasamudacaranti hānabhaginī pannã;tadanudhammatā sati santitthatithitibhaginī panna;avitakkasahagata sainamanasikarā samudacarantivisesabhāginī panna;nibbidasahagatā sannamanasikara samudacarantiviragupasamhita nibbedhabhaginī panna).Similar distinctions are made for each of the higher attainments.

180(10)The Great ReferencesThis passage is also included in the Mahāparinibbāna Sutta,DN 16.4.7,at II 124-26.

On one occasion the Blessed One was dwelling at Bhoganagara near the Ananda Shrine.
There the Blessed One addressed the bhikkhus:
"Bhikkhus!“
“Venerable sir!”those bhikkhus replied.
The Blessed One said this:
“Bhikkhus,I will teach you these fourgreat references.Mahāpadese.Mp glosses as mahā-okāse (apparently as if the com- pound could be resolved maha +padese)and as maha-apadese, the latter explained as"great reasons stated with reference to such great ones as the Buddha and others"(buddhadayo mahante mahante apadisitva vuttēni mahakaranani).This second resolu- tion is certainly to be preferred.DOP gives,among the mean- Ings of apadesa,"designation,pointing out,reference,witness, authority."Cattaro mahapadesa is sometimes rendered"four great authorities"but the sutta actually specifies only two authorities, the suttas and the Vinaya.Walshe,in LDB,renders it as"four criteria."I understand the term to mean"four great references,"the four provenances of a teaching.[168]Listen and attend closely;
I will speak.”
“Yes,Bhante,”those bhikkhus replied.
The Blessed One said this:
“What,bhikkhus,are the four great references?
(1)“Here,bhikkhus,a bhikkhu might say:
'In the presence of the Blessed One I heard this;in his presence I learned this:"This is the Dhamma;this is the discipline;this is the Teacher's teaching!”'
That bhikkhu's statement should neither be approved nor rejected.
Without approving or rejecting it,you should thoroughly learn those words and phrases and then check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline.Tani padabyanjanāni...sutte otaretabbani vinayesandassetabbani.Mp gives various meanings of sutte and vinaye here,some improbable.Clearly,this instruction presupposes that there already existed a body of discourses and a systematic Vinaya that could be used to evaluate other texts proposed for inclusion as authentic utterances of the Buddha.Otaretabbani is gerundive plural of otarenti,"make descend,put down or put into,"and otaranti,just below,means"descend,come down,go into."My renderings,respectively,as"check for them"and"are included among"are adapted to the context Sandassetabbāniis gerundive plural of san-dassenti,"show,make seen,"and sandissanti means"are seen."
If,when you check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline,[you find that]they are not included among the discourses and are not to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the conclusion:
'Surely,this is not the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
It has been badly learned by this bhikkhu.'
Thus you should discard it.“
But a bhikkhu might say:
In the presence of the Blessed One I heard this;in his presence I learned this:“This is the Dhamma;this is the discipline;this is the Teacher's teaching!”'
That bhikkhu's statement should neither be approved nor rejected.
Without approving or rejecting it,you should thoroughly learn those words and phrases and then check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline.
If,when you check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline,[you find that]they are included among the discourses and are to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the concusion:
'Surely,this is the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
It has been learned well by this bhikkhu.'
You should remember this first great reference.
(2)“Then a bhikkhu might say:
In such and such a residence a Sangha is dwelling with elders and prominent monks.
In the presence of that Sangha I heard this;in its presence I learned this:“This is the Dhamma;this is the discipline;this is the Teacher's teaching.”
That bhikkhu's statement should neither be approved nor rejected.
Without approving or rejecting it,you should thoroughly learn those words and phrases and then check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline.
If,when you check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline, [you find that]they are not included among the discourses and are not to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the con- clusion;
'Surely,this is not the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
[169]It has been badly learned by that Sangha.'
Thus you should discard it.
“But...
……
……
……
……
if,when you check for them in 'the discourses and seek them in the discipline,[you find that]they are included among the discourses and are to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the conclusion:
'Surely,this is the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
It has been learned well by that Sangha.'
You should remember this second great reference.
(3)“Then a bhikkhu might say:
In such and such a residence several elder bhikkhus are dwelling who are learned,heirs to the heritage,experts on the Dhamma,experts on the discipline,experts on the outlines.
In the presence of those elders I heard this;in their presence I learned this:“This is the Dhamma;this is the discipline;this is theTeacher's teaching!”'
That bhikkhu's statement should neither be approved nor rejected:
Without approving or rejecting it,you should thoroughly learn those words and phrases and then check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline.
If,when you check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline,[you find that]they are not included among the discourses and are not to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the conclusion:
'Surely,this is not the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
It has been badly learned by those elders.'
Thus you should discard it.
“But...
……
……
……
……
if,when you check for them in the discourses andseek them in the discipline,[you find that]they are included among the discourses and are to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the conclusion:
‘Surely,this is the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
It has been learned well by those elders.'
You should remember this third great reference.
(4)“Then a bhikkhu might say:
'In such and such a residence one elder bhikkhu is dwelling [170]who is learned,an heir to the heritage,an expert on the Dhamma,an expert on the discipline,an expert on the outlines.
In the presence of that elder I heard this;in his presence I learned this:“This is the Dhamma;this is the discipline;this is the Teacher's teaching!”'
That bhikkhu's statement should neither be approved nor rejected.
Without approving or rejecting it,you should thoroughly learn those words and phrases and then check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline.
If,when you check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline,[you find that]they are not included among the discourses and are not to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the conclusion:
'Surely,this is not the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
It has been badly learned by that elder.
Thus you should discard it.
“But a bhikkhu might say:
In such and such a residence one elder bhikkhu is dwelling who is learned,an heir to the heritage,an expert on the Dhamma,an expert on the discipline,an expert on the outlines.
In the presence of that elder I heard this;in his presence I learned this:“This is the Dhamma;this is the discipline;this is the Teacher's teaching!”'
That bhikkhu's statement should neither be approved nor rejected.
Without approving or rejecting it,you should thoroughly learn those words and phrases and then check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline.
If,when you check for them in the discourses and seek them in the discipline,[you find that]they are included among the discourses and are to be seen in the discipline,you should draw the conclusion:
'Surely,this is the word of the Blessed One,the Arahant,the Perfectly Enlightened One.
It has been learned well by that elder.
You should remember this fourth great reference.
“These,bhikkhus,are the four great references.The clearer of the two Chinese parallels is in DA.2,at TI17b29-18a22.Here cattaro mahapadesā is rendered.四大教法,"four great teaching dhammas."I translate the first declaration(T I 17c2-13)as follows:“If there is a bhikkhu who claims:Venerable ones,in that village,city,country,I personally heard [this]from the Buddha,I personally received this teaching,'you should not disbelieve what you hear from him,nor should you reject it,but through the suttas determine whether it is true or false;based on the Vinaya,based on the Dhamma,probe it thoroughly.If what he says is not the sutta,not the Vinaya,not the Dhamma,then you should say to him:The Buddha did not say this.What you have received is mistaken![Or:You have received it erroneously!]For what reason?Because based on the suttas,based on the Vinaya,based on the Dhamma,we [find]that what you said deviates from the Dhamma.Venerable one,you should not uphold this,you should not report it to people,but should discard it.'But if what he says is based on the suttas,based on the Vinaya,based on the Dhamma,then you should say to him:What you said was truly spoken by the Buddha.For what reason?Because based on the suttas,based on the Vinaya,based on the Dhamma,we [find]that what you said accords with the Dhamma.Venerable one,you should uphold this,you should widely report it to people;you should not discard it.'This is the first great teaching dhamma."