3(3)Maimed(1)
“Bhikkhus,possessing four qualities,the foolish,incompetent,bad person maintains himself in a maimed and injured condition;he is blameworthy[3]and subject to reproach by the wise;and he generates much demerit,
What four?
(1)"Without investigating and scrutinizing,he speaks praise of one who deserves dispraise.(2)Without investigating and scrutinizing,he speaks dispraise of one who deserves praise. (3)Without investigating and scrutinizing,he believes a matter that merits suspicion.(4)Without investigating and scrutiniz-
ing,he is suspicious about a matter that merits belief.Possessing these four qualities,the foolish,incompetent,bad person maintains himself in a maimed and injured condition;he is blameworthy and subject to reproach by the wise;and he generates much demerit.
“Bhikkhus,possessing four qualities,the wise,competent,good person preserves himself unmaimed and uninjured;he is blameless and beyond reproach by the wise;and he generates much merit.
What four?
(1)“Having investigated and scrutinized,he speaks dispraise of one who deserves dispraise.(2)Having investigated and scru-tinized,he speaks praise ofone who deserves praise.(3)Having investigated,and scrutinized,he is suspicious about a matter:that merits suspicion.(4)Having investigated and scrutinized;.he believes a matter that merits belief.Possessing these four qualities,the wise,competent,good person preserves himself unmaimed and uninjured;he is blameless and beyond reproach by the wise;and he generates much merit.”
He who praises one deserving blame,
or blames one deserving praise,
casts with his mouth an unlucky throw
by which he finds no happiness.These three verses recur at 10:89 with reference to the slanderous bhikkhu Kokālika.The story,including verses,is also at SN 6:9-10,I 149-53,and Sn 3:10,pp.123-31.
Vicinatimukhena so kalim,kalinā tena sukham na vindati.This could also have been rendered:“The fool collects a disaster with his mouth."Kali means both disaster and the losing throw at dice.
Slight is the unlucky throw at dice
that results in the loss of one's wealth,
[the loss]of all,oneself included;
much worse is this unlucky throw
of harboring hate against the fortunate ones.Mp:"This disaster is trifling,that is,the loss of wealth at dice along with all that one owns,including oneself.”Mp glosses sugatesu,"holy ones,"as sammaggatesu puggalesu,"persons who have rightly attained,"thus referring to all arahants,not only to the Buddha.
For a hundred thousand and thirty-six nirabbudas,
plus five abbudas,[4]
the slanderer of noble ones goes to hell,
having defamed them with evil speech and mind.Satam sahassānam nirabbudanami,chattimsati panca ca abbudani. I translate following Mp,which says of the numbers:“A hundred thousand nirabbudas,plus thirty-six more nirabbudas,plus five abbudas”(satam sahassānan ti nirabbudagananaya satasahassam;chattimsatī ti aparani ca chattimsati nirabbrdani;panca cā tiabbudagananāya ca panca abbudāni).Vanarata,however,holds that panca cannot directly qualify abbudānan and therefore he would conjoin sahassanam with chattimsatī and panca 'as well,making thirty-six thousand additional nirabbudas and five thousand abbudas.Mp,commenting on 10:89,explains the Buddhist numbering scheme as follows:one koti=ten million;a koti of kotis=one pakoti;a koti of pakotis =one kotipakoti;a koti of kotipakotis =one nahuta;a koti of nahutas =one ninnahuta;a koti of ninnahutas=one abbuda;twenty abbudas =one nirabbuda.