Issues
Select Version
THE BOOK OF THE FOURS
THE BOOK OF THE FOURS

40(10)Udayī

Author: Bhikkhu Bodhi @ IAPT

40(10)Udayī

Then the brahmin Udayī approached the Blessed One...











When a sacrifice is timely and allowable,well prepared and non violent,[44]
the self-controlled followers of the spiritual life attend such a sacrifice as this.

Those in the world who have removed the coverings,Readings of this enigmatic term vary here and elsewhere across the Nikāyas.Here,Ce has vivattacchadda,Be vivatacchada,Ee vivattacchada.The expression often occurs in the stock passage on the two courses open to one with the thirty-two bodily marks of a great man:if he remains at home,he will-become a wheel-turning king,but if he goes forth into homelessness,he will become a perfectly enlightened Buddha,described as"one in the world who vivatacchado”(variants:vivattacchado,vivatfacchaddo,vivat-tacchaddo).See e.g.DN 3.1.5,I 89,8-9;DN 14.1.31,II 16,8-9;DN ·30.1.1,III142,4;MN 91.5,IⅡ 134,28;Sn 106.Though the origins ofthe term and its exact meaning are problematic,the commentar-ies consistently analyze and explain it in the same way.SinceMp(on the present sutta)does not offer an explanation,I citethe Digha Nikāya commentary,SvI250,34-251,3:“Vivattacchado:Here,havingbeen born into the world,he dwells having entirelyremoved the covering inthe world (loke tam chadanam vivaftetva),in the darkness of defilements covered by seven coverings(chadanehi):lust,hatred,delusion,conceit,views,ignorance,andmisconduct.” The old canonical commentary,Culaniddesa,commenting on Sn 1147,says:“Vivatacchado:There are five coverings(chadanāni):craving,views,defilements,misconduct,ignorance.Those cov-erings have been removed (vivatāni)by the Blessed Buddha;theyhave been dispelled,uprooted,abandoned,eradicated,settled,stilled,burned by the fire of knowledge so that they are unable toarise.Therefore the Buddha is one who has removed the cover-ings"(Nidd I251,i8-22;VRIed.204) Norman(1991:71-76)had proposed that the Pali expres-sion was to be derived from the BHS form vighustasabda andthus meant“one whose name (or fame)had rolled in different directions"or"one of widespread fame."In a later work(2006b: 228-29)he changed his position,stating:"although I was correctto see a connection betweeri thePali and Skt words,the directionof the development wasini the reverse order,and must representa hyper-Sanskritisation from vivattacchadda."At Sn 372 and else-wherehe renders this“with deceit removed.” The Chinese translators of the Agamas must have workedwith texts that.read vighustasabda or some variant with the samemeaning.Thus a parallel of 4:40,SA²90(at T II 404c6)has名聞極遠者,“whose name is heard extremely far away.”The parallel of DN 30,MA 59 (at T I493bz-8),reads:必得如來無所著等正覺名稱流布周聞十方;"he necessarily becomes a Tathāgata,unattached(=arahant),fully enlightened,whose name spreads around and is heardin the ten directions."MA161,the parallel of MN91,has the sameat T I 685b2-4.Though various conjectures might be proposedwith respect to the original expression and its meaning,giventhe difficulty of settling these questions across Buddhist textualtraditions,the most expedient course open to me is to translatethe term as it has been preserved and interpreted in.the Palitradition.

transcenders of time and destination,The readings here vary considerably.Ce and Be have vitivatta kulam gatim,“who have transcended family and destination.” Ee has a bahubbihi compound,vitivattakalamgatī,with still more variants in the notes.Mp(Be)reads kulam gatim in the lemma, but Mp(Ce)has kalam gatim.My rendering follows Ee.Note that in 5:55,at III 69,10,kalam and gatim are in immediate proximity, which supports the hypothesis that here too we should read kala-/kalarm.

the Buddhas who are proficient in sacrifice,I read with Be yaninassa kovidā,as against Ce and Ee punnassa kovida,"proficient in merit."Mp(Be)and Mp(Ce)show the same difference in their lemmas and glosses.Two Chinese parallels correspond to Be.SA·90(at TIⅡ 23a11)has佛於祀盛善,"the Bud- dha who is skilled in sacrifice,"and SA²90(at T II 404c8)諸佛所 稱善祀及祀之道,"this is the good sacrifice and the path of sacrifice praised by the Buddhas.”praise this kind of sacrifice.
Having prepared an appropriate gift,whether of the ordinary kind or in memory of the dead,
one makes the sacrifice with a confident mind to a fertile field,to followers of the spiritual life.
When what has been properly obtained is properly offered,properly sacrificed
to those worthy of offerings, the sacrifice is vast and the deities are pleased.
The wise person endowed with faith, having sacrificed thus with a generous mind,
is reborn in a happy worldin [a realm]without affliction.