Issues
Select Version
Vimānavatthu-aṭṭhakathā
Vimānavatthu-aṭṭhakathā

EXPOSITION OF CHATTAMANAVA'S vimāna

Author: vimāna stories by P.Masefield @ 达摩难陀比库

EXPOSITION OF CHATTAMANAVA'S vimāna

"He who is the most excellent of speakers amongst Manu's breed1**. This is Chattamanava's Vimana.
  1. [232] For lust lust-free (rdgaviragarn): he speaks of the ariyan path;

for it is by means of this that the ariyans make themselves

lust-free for38, cause to go to destruction39, even that lust

cultivated from eternity40.

Imperturbable, grief-free (anejamasokam) is the ariyan fruit;

for this is called 'imperturbable',

'grief・free', on account of the complete abatement of the

defilements remaining that pertain to perturbance, to craving so

called, and that are characterised as grief.

Dhamma (dhammam):

Dhamma with its own nature;

for this is that Dhamma that is to

be grasped in its own nature41, viz. the path, the fruits and

nibbana, and not, like the Dhamma of the texts, by way of a

conceptual-dhamma42.

Or alternatively Dhamma (dhammam):

Dhamma in its intrinsic sense43, meaning nibbana.

That which is

conditioned is produced by conditions having come together,

having become co-existent44; since it is not conditioned it is that

which is the unconditioned,

that same nibbana.

It is unloathsome

since there is nothing whatsoever45 loathsome there.

It is sweet*

since it is wholly agreeable at all times 一 at the time of hearing it,

at the time of examining it and at the time of practising it.

It is competent due to its having been set going in a proper fashion46, in that it has been set going through attainment of that illumination of mind47 that is dependent upon48 omniscience, and due to its being subtle.

It is properly classified on account of the

proper classification of the matter to be classified by way of the

khandhas and so on49, by way of what is skilled and so on50 and

by way of the summaries and so forth.

Moreover with these three words he speaks only of the Dhamma of the texts.

For this same

reason 'this' is said with the aim of indicating the first hand

nature in both ways since, as at the time of perceiving it, so too at

the time of encountering51 it, the one hearing it is also, like the

one talking it, face to face with it.

Dhamma (dhammaqi):

Dhamma in the sense of upholding those practising in accordance

with the way things are52 from a fall into the dukkha in the states of loss. This is a general term for the fourfold53 Dhamma even.

For by virtue of the mere fact of establishment in the refuges and the precepts, even, the Dhamma of the texts also quite upholds54 (one), through practice in accordance therewith55, from a fall into

the dukkha in the states of loss;

and this same vimana is to be regarded as evidence in support of this fact.
Having placed at first hand the aforementioned Dhamma56 in a general way he again says 'this' indicating (this).
  1. Wherein (yattha)51: with respect to the Ariyasangha in which.

What is given (dinnam): a merit-offering of food and so on that is

given away.

What is given is of great fruit (dinna mahapphalam):

[233] the nasal is elided, metri causa;

with respect to the four

pairs of men who are spoken of by way of 'the sotapanna, the

one practising for the realisation of the sotapatti-fruit,58 and so on

who are absolutely pure due to purification as regards the

impurities that are the defilements.

The eight (attha): the eight individuals by way of taking them separately without (taking) them in pairs with respect to those established on the paths and those established in the fruits;
and here the term is shortened thus puggala59 dhammadasa, likewise metri causa.
Who are Dhamma-seers (dhammadasa): who see60 at first hand that Dhamma that is the Four Truths and that Dhamma that is nibbana.
To this Sahgha that is a SaAgha through being com pact(sarnghata-)61 by way of equality in (right) view and morality.

When the method of going for refuge, accompanied by an

indication of the good qualities associated with those refuges, had

thus been spoken of by means of these three verses by the Lord,

the youth, immediately following each verse, reiterated each

verse beginning with "He who is the most excellent of speakers”

explaining, by way of recollecting each good quality associated

with those refuges, the fact that the method of going for refuge

was firmly fixed in his heart.

As he remained after having thus

reiterated62 them (the Lord) explained the five items of the

training, as to the form taken by these and the advantage that is

their fruit, and then talked of the method of undertaking them.

He, his heart devoted after having well pondered this too, said,

"Well, Lord, 1 must be going", and, recollecting those very good

qualities associated with the Three Jewels, continued along that

same path;

whilst the Lord, knowing a skilled deed of this extent would be sufficient for his arising in the devaloka, went straight back to Jeta's Grove.

However as the youth, his heart devoted, and who, on account

of the recognition of the good qualities associated with the Three

Jewels, had been established in the Refuges63, in that he had

given rise to the thought proceeding thus, "I must come for

refuge”,and in the Precepts through a resolution for the Five

Precepts in the manner spoken of by the Lord, was going along

still recollecting in that same manner those good qualities

associated with the Three Jewels, those robbers beset him on the

path.

And he, not taking account of them, continued to go along

still recollecting the good qualities associated with the Three

Jewels.

Now one of those robbers, stationed relying on the cover

of a bush, struck him abruptly with a sharp64 poisoned arrow

[234] bringing him to his days* end, seized the bundle of

kahapanas and then departed65 together with his accomplices.

When the youth died, however, he came into being, as though

awakening from sleep, in a thirty-yojana golden vimana in the

realm of the Thirty-three surrounded by a retinue of a thousand

nymphs, his person being adorned with sixty cartloads of

ornaments66. The radiance of that vimana remained pervading in

excess of twenty yojanas.

Now when they saw that youth67 dead the people who were

residents of Setavya68 went to Setavya and told his mother and

father, whilst those who were residents of Ukkattha went to

Ukkattha and told the brahmin Pokkharasati.

When they heard

this his69 mother and father, relatives and friends and the

brahmin Pokkharasati, together with their retinues, went to that

spot weeping with tearful faces; and practically all the residents

of Setavya, Ukkhattha and Icchanahgala70 came together (there).

It was a great meeting.

Then the youth's mother and father

constructed71 a funeral pile not far from the path and began to

perform the funeral rites.

Then the Lord thought, “When 1 go

(there) Chattamanava will come to salute me and, having him

talk when he comes about the deed done (by him), I will have

him place at first hand the fruition of deeds and then teach

Dhamma - in this way penetration of Dhamma will arise to those

people”. So thinking he went to that spot accompanied by a great

order of monks and then seated himself at the foot of a certain

tree, emanating the six-coloured rays of a Buddha.

Then the devaputta Chattamanava72 reflected upon his own excellence

and, whilst pondering the reason for it, saw his going for refuge

and his undertaking the precepts; he was filled with astonishment

and, full of devotion and veneration towards the Lord, thought

that he should, as an acknowledgement of what had been done,

go right then, salute the Lord and the order of monks and make

manifest to the people the good qualities associated with the

Three Jewels. Rendering that entire spot in the forest one mass

of light he came together with his vimana, dismounted from the

vimana and, having approached, accompanied by a great retinue,

in a form that was visible, [235] greeted (the Lord), falling with

his head at the Lord's feet, and then stood to one side holding up

an anjali salute.

When they saw him the people were filled with

wonder and surprise thinking, "Who can this be? Is he a deva or

a Brahma?,\ and approached and surrounded the Lord.

In order to make manifest the meritorious deed done by him the Lord asked that devaputta:
  1. “Not so does the sun glow in the sky73, nor the moon nor

Phussa74 illustre,

as this great radiance beyond compare75 一 now

who are you, come to the earth from the Triple Heaven?

  1. And76 the radiance cuts off the radiance-maker's rays77 for

twenty yojanas 一 and more besides;

even78 the night it renders

just like day: this vimana is pure throughout, stainless, beautiful.

  1. With many padumas and variegated pundarikas, drenched

with blooms,

countlessly ornamented and covered with a dustless

net of gold, dust-free, it glows in the air, just like the sun even79.

  1. It is fulfilled, as are the heavens with stars, with those draped

in red rayment and yellow with make-up of fragrant aloe,

piyangu80 and sandal and whose fine skin resembles shining gold.

  1. Here are many men and women81 of countless appearances,

here are those with lovely hearts with decorations that are decorated with blooms;

released in the wind they blow forth82

entrancingly; they are stretched with glowing gold, covered with

gold83.

  1. Of what control is this the result? Due to the fruit of what

deed are you84 arisen here? [236]

And how this vimana has been

attained by you 一 come now, being asked you should speak of

that word for word".

Herein:
  1. Does glow (tapati): does illumine.
In the sky (nabhasmim): in the air.
Phussa (Phusso): the star Phussa.

Beyond compare

(atulam)* without compare85; or alternatively without measure.

This is what is said: As this, your vimana, is without compare85,

is without measure, on account of its shining nature, whence

alone it, a great radiance, illumines in the air - not so do stars

illumine, nor the moon; let be such as these86, not even the sun

(so) illumines. Now who, being thus, are you, come to this area

of ground from the devaloka? Talk to these people making this

manifest.

  1. Cuts off (chindati): prevents, meaning strikes against not

allowing them to proceed.

Rays : ramsi-rasmiyo (alternative

grammatical form).

The radiance-maker's (pabhankarassa): the sun's.

And the radiance of this vimana remains pervading for

twenty-five yojanas on all sides.

For this reason he said, “The

radiance . . . for twenty yojanas 一 and more besides”.

Even the night it renders just like day (rattim api yatha divatn karoti): even the night-time it renders like the day-time, scattering the darkness with its own radiance.

It is pure throughout due to its

purity on all sides throughout, both inside and out,

stainless due to the absence of stains in all respects,
beautiful on account of its loveliness.
  1. With many padumas and variegated pundarikas (bahupadu mavicitrapundarikam): with both many kinds of red kamalas and

also white kamalas of variegated colour87;

they also say that the white kamala is a paduma, the red kamaia a pundarika88.

Drenched with blooms (vokinnatn kusumehi): and89 besprinkled

with other flowers of various kinds.

Countlessly ornamented Cnekacittam): decorated in various ways with works of garlands and works of creepers and so on.

Covered with a dustless net of

gold, dust-free (arajavirajahemajalachannam): covered with a net

of gold that is dustless, without blemish, its dust having departed

on its own accord.

  1. With those draped in red rayment and yellow (rattambara pltavasasahi)*. with both those with red clothes and those with

yellow clothes;

for one who has dressed below in heavenly

clothes that are red uses a yellow upper-garment, whilst another

who has dressed below in those that are yellow uses a red upper garment

一 it was with reference to this that *with those draped in

red rayment and yellow* was said. [237]

With make-up of fragrant aloe, piyangu and sandal (agarupiyangucandanussadahi): with make-up {-ussadahi} of the scent of fragrant aloe90, of piyaftgu garlands and91 the scents of sandal, meaning with excessive

(ussanna-) scent of heavenly fragrant aloe and so on92 upon

them.

And whose fine skin resembles shining gold (karicanatanu sannibhattacahi): and whose subtle skin is similar to gold.
It is fulfilled (paripuram): it is filled with those intent on singing who are roaming about here and there.
  1. Here are many : bahuk* ettha=bahuka ettha (resolution of

compound).

Of countless appearances Cnekavanna): of various forms.

With decorations that are decorated with blooms (kusuma vibhusitabharana): with heavenly decorations that are adorned

with heavenly blooms so as to waft forth especially entrancingly.

Here (ettha): in this vimana.
Those with lovely hearts : sumana—sundaramana (alternative grammatical form), those with jubilant minds.

Released in the wind they blow forth

entrancingly (anilapamuncita pavanti surabhim): on account of

being tied on both sides93 with flowers whose scent is released94

into the wind as though a basket of petals had been let loose into

the wind95 and on account of being opened out, they blow forth

fragrantly.

They also read anilapadhupitaP6 (tossed in the wind),

meaning with flowers made of gold that are being tossed97

slightly98 in the wind.

They are stretched with glowing gold due to being spread on their braids" and so on with strips100 and so

forth of gold.

They are covered with gold since for the most part

their bodies are covered101 with decorations of shining gold.

Men and women (naranariyo) shows that here in your vimana are many devaputtas and devadhitas.
  1. Come now (ingha) is a particle in the sense of urging. Being

asked : puttho^pucchito (alternative grammatical form); for the

sake of the fruition of deeds being (demonstrated) at first hand to

these people 一 this is the meaning.

The devaputta thereupon explained with these verses:

10, “Here, on the road, you yourself102 gathered together with

the youth; the Teacher, pitying, instructed him;

and having heard Dhamma from you, the most excellent Jewel, Chatta spoke saying, <Thus103 will I act;
  1. [238] I will come104 to the most excellent of most excellent Conquerors105 for refuge, and also to the Dhamma and likewise the order of monks'.
At first I said106, 'No', Lord, but later I did your word precisely.
  1. And do not practise the divers execution of living beings

which is impure,

for those with insight did not applaud the lack of restraint as regards living beings

一 at first I said, 'No', Lord, but

later I did your word precisely.

  1. And do not think that that guarded by another person, that which is not given, is to be appropriated

一 at first I said, 'No',

Lord, but later I did your word precisely.

  1. And do not go with wives guarded by another person: this is unariyan 一
at first I said, 'No', Lord, but later I did your word precisely.
  1. And do not speak an untruth, equivocally, for those with

insight did not applaud telling lies -

at first I said, 'No', Lord, but later I did your word precisely.
  1. And shun all those intoxicants on account of which a man's awareness leaves him -
at first I said, 'No', Lord, but later I did your word precisely.
  1. That I, having here performed the five trainings, having practised with respect to the Tathagata^ Dhamma,
went along a dual road amidst robbers; these slew me there for the sake of wealth.
  1. To this extent I recollect this skilled deed; beyond that no other is known to me. [239]
Due to that good conduct, through that deed, am I arisen in the Triple Heaven with all my desires gratified.
  1. Behold the result of practice tn accordance with the

Dhamma, of an instant's, of a moment's, control;

many with inferior sense-pleasures107 observing me blazing, as it were, on account of my fame are envious.
  1. Behold how through few teaching I have gone to the happy destiny and reached happiness;
and those who continually hear Dhamma via you, these, methinks, touch the Deathless, the peace108.
  1. Even a trifling amount109 done with respect to the Tathagata's Dhamma becomes abundant110, with great result;
behold how Chatta, through having done a meritorious deed, lights up the earth, just like the sun even111.
  1. 'What is this "skilled deed”,whatm ought we to accomplish?* 一 thus some, having gathered together, consult; *
Ought we113, having once more114 gained the human state115, to stay practising (this), possessing morality?*.
  1. The Teacher, thus doing much and possessing pity, came, when I existed, early in the day;
that I went up116 to the truly named saying, TIease have pity, once more even ought we to hear Dhamma'.
  1. Those here who renounce the lust for sensual desire and (those who) have renounced the latent tendency of lust for becoming,

and delusion, these do not come again to bed-of womb for they are gone to parinibbana, are become cool”.

Herein:

  1. Here, on the road, you yourself gathered together with the

youth (sayam idha pathe samecca manavena): here, on this road,

on this great path, this very you yourself gathered together, met,

with the youth, the brahmin's son, who had come up (to you);

you, the Lord, who are the Teacher on account of appropriately

instructing beings in what is to their highest good as regards these

seen conditions and the next world117, [240] pitying, helping,

instructed that youth in accordance with the Dhamma; having

heard that Dhamma from you, the most excellent Jewel, the chief

Jewel, the Perfect Buddha, he, Chatta, the youth named Chatta,

spoke, talked, saying, “Thus, in that way, will I act118, I will

practise as instructed** 一 this is how the words should be

construed.

Having thus indicated as requested that deed by way

of the reason for it, he then says, "(I will come to) the most

excellent of most excellent Conquerors" and so on to indicate his

having been caused to take up (that deed) by the Teacher and his

having been later established therein on his own accord,

indicating (the deed) by way of the form it took and by way of its

classification. Herein:

  1. At first I said, "No", Lord (no ti pathamam avoc" aham bhante): Lord, when, Lord, you said, “Do you know what is

going for refuge?, at first 1 said, “No” and not "I do know119.

But later I did your word precisely (pacchd te vacanam tath"

akdsim): but later, reciting the verse spoken by you, 1 did, I

practised, your word precisely, meaning I approached the Three

Refuges.

  1. Divers (vividham): high and low, meaning incurring little

fault and incurring great fault.

Do not practise (ma carassu): do not perform.

Which is impure (asucim): which is not pure on

account of being mixed up with the impurities of the defilements.

Lack of restraint as regards living beings (panesu asannatam): not refraining from the slaughter of living beings.
For (those with insight) did not applaud (na hi avannayimsu)*.

for (those with insight) do not applaud, for this is the past tense in the sense of

the present tense.

Or alternatively avannayhnsu ((they) did not

applaud) is a synecdoche for all time spoken of partially;

therefore, just as120, in past times (they) did not applaud, so too

do (they) not applaud now and also will not applaud in the future.

  1. That guarded by another person (parajanassa rakkhitam): an item belonging to another.
For this reason he said, "That which is not given”.
  1. Do not go (ma agama): do not have intercourse.
  1. An untruth (vitatham): a non-truth, meaning a lie.
Equivocally (anfiathd),. quite equivocally, meaning aware that it is an untruth, thus realising full well121 that it is an untruth, do not speak (it).
  1. [241] On account of which (yena): on account of which intoxicants;on account of having drunk which - this is the meaning.
Leaves him (apeti)\ departs.

Awareness (saniid)\

awareness of Dhamma, or awareness of the world itself.

All (sabbam): without remainder, meaning starting from the (size of a) seed onwards.
  1. That I (svaham): that I who was at that time Chattamanava.

Here (idha)122: at this spot on the path; or alternatively here

(idha)123: in this Teaching of yours.

For this reason he said, "With respect to the Tathagata*s Dhamma".
The five trainings (panca sikkhd): the five precepts.

Having performed (karitva):

having taken upon myself, meaning having undertaken.

A dual road (dvepatham)*. a path forming the meeting point of the boundaries of two villages, meaning a path demarcating the boundaries.
These (te)\ these robbers.
There (tattha): on the path lying between the boundaries.
For the sake of wealth (bhogahetu): on account of some petty gain.
  1. Beyond, in addition to, that aforementioned skilled deed124

no other is known, is found, meaning that I can recollect.

With all my desires gratified (kdmakami): provided with the five strands of sense-desire as are wished for.
  1. Of an instant's, of a moment's, control (khanamuhutta sannamassa): of morality that occurred merely for an instant, for a moment.

Of practice in accordance with the Dhamma (anudhammapatipaUiya): behold, Lord, (the result) for one practising that Dhamma which accords with the fruit thus

attained; or alternatively of practice of Dhamma (wherein the

practice) accords with the Dhamma125 of your exhortation,

meaning of going for refuge and undertaking the precepts in

exactly the same manner as already mentioned.

Blazing, as it were, on account of my fame (jalam iva yasasa): as though blazing on account of my iddhi and on account of my excellence of

retinue.

Observing (samekkhamana): beholding.
Many : bahukd ^bahavo (alternative grammatical form).
Are envious (pihayanti): wish, "How might we, too126, become like this".
With inferior sense-pleasures (hinakdmd): with insignificant possessions compared to my excellence.
  1. Few (katipayaya): a trifling amount of.
Those who (ye): those monks and layfollowers and so on who.
The word ca (and) (denotes) something additional127.
Via you : te=tava (alternative grammatical form).
Continually (satatam): day in, day out.
  1. Abundant (vipulam)-. of lofty fruit, of abundant majesty.

With respect to the Tathagata's Dhamma (Tathagatassa dhamme):

done when stood in the Teaching, in the exhortation of the

Tathagata - this is how it should be construed.

He says "Behold” and so on indicating, by way of reference to himself, the matter thus (far) spoken of non-referentially.
Herein behold (passa): he is speaking to the Lord; or alternatively he is speaking merely to himself acting as though he might to another.
  1. [242] What is this 'skilled deed", what ought we to accomplish

(kim idarn kusalam kim acarema): what is the nature of, like

what is, this that is called a skilled deed, or how128 might we

accomplish this.

Thus some, having gathered together, consult (icc

eke hi samecca mantayanti): in this way some, having gathered

together, having met, consult, go over, doing what is very

difficult to do, as if causing the earth to rotate129 and as if

raising130 Sineru131; "Might we, moreover, accomplish once more

even this 'skilled deed' simply without any difficulty132?n - this is

the meaning.

For this same reason he said133, “(Ought) we" and so on.
  1. Doing much (bahukaro): of much service, or of great service.
Possessing pity (anukampako): compassionate,
the words being euphonically connected by the hiatus-filler -m-.
Thus (iti): in that way; he is speaking with reference to the Lord's manner of acting with respect to himself.

When I existed : me sati^mayi sati (alternative grammatical form), when (I) was known,

meaning whilst still unslain by those robbers.

Early in the day : divadivassa=divasassa134 pi diva (resolution of compound in

alternative grammatical form), meaning right early in the

morning135.

That I (svaham): that I who was Chattamanava.
The truly named (saccanamarn): the one who is not untruly named, the one who is factually named, by way of such names as the Lord, the Arahant, the Perfect Buddha and so on136.
Please have pity (anukampassu): please help.
Once more even (puna pi): further even ought we to hear Dhamma, meaning might we simply hear Dhamma from you137.
When the devaputta had thus138 said all this as an acknowledgement of what had been done he then spoke elucidating his total lack of satiation as regards sitting around paying homage to the Teacher and as regards hearing Dhamma.
The Lord surveyed the disposition of the devaputta and of the company that had come together there and talked a progressive talk;
then when he knew of their readiness of heart he made visible that Teaching on Dhamma which (the Buddhas) have themselves discovered.
At the culmination of that Teaching that devaputta and his mother and father139 were established in the sotapatti-fruit, whilst penetration of Dhamma arose to that great body of people.
Established140 in the first fruit the devaputta uttered the final verse (beginning:) “Those here who renounce the lust for sensual desire", explaining his respect and thought fulness141 with respect to the higher paths and the great advantageousness of attaining these.
  1. This is its meaning: those here, stood in this Teaching, who renounce, who extirpate without remainder, the lust for sensual desire, these do not come again [243] to bed-of-womb on account of their having extirpated the fetters leading to the lower (world)142;
whilst those, moreover, who having renounced delusion, having abolished it entirely, and who renounce the latent tendency of lust for becoming, to say that these come again to bed-of-womb would be quite improper.
Why?
For they are gone to parinibbana, are become cool. For these utmost of men are gone to parinibbana by way of that form of nibbana that is without any remnant of substrate (requiring further birth), and thus143 become cool through there being an end, right here, of all that is felt144, of all fevers.
The devaputta, thus making known the fact of his own entry to the hearing of the ariyans145, brought that Teaching to a climax146 by way of (that reference to) that form of nibbana that is without any remnant of substrate (requiring further birth); he saluted the Lord, circumambulated him by the right, showed his respect to the order of monks and, having begged leave of his mother and father, went straight to the devaloka. The Teacher also arose from his seat147 and left, accompanied by the order of monks.
Moreover the youth's mother and father, the brahmin Pokkharasati and all those people followed the Lord and went back.
That teaching was of benefit to those people.
The Exposition of Chattamanava*s Vimana is concluded.